Skip to content
Sign up
Log in
Vacation rentals in Fire Island

Vacation rentals in Fire Island

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Fire Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

KISMET Fire Island Beach House
SUPERHOSTEntire house · 10 guests · 5 beds · 2.5 baths
KISMET Fire Island Beach House

60’s modern/retro, award-winning (design) house. 45 secs to beach. Spacious, clean, social- well suited for groups and families (up to 10 max please, 8 is ideal). Fabulous retro mid house, open-roofed porch. BBQ, Outdoor shower, Hardwood floors, lots of light. 3 minutes from the ferry/ restaurants, but on a quiet street. Appliances and mattresses regularly replaced. Professionally cleaned weekly

What guests are saying:

“Wally is a very attentive host. He is engaged and cares tremendously about the experience that his guest have at his place. Wally sets very real expectations of his house. We found that the house and the amenities exceeded many of those expectations. The house has the character and authenticity you would expect in a Fire Island beach house. It also has many convenience amenities for cooking as well as enjoying the beach and the Island. We bicycled, and walked all over. We fished of the piers and belly surfed in the ocean. This was my daughter's boyfriend's first experience with a US beach and I could't have asked for more.. and he caught his first fish..”

Charming Cape Close to the Ocean
Entire house · 6 guests · 5 beds · 2 baths
Charming Cape Close to the Ocean

My home is a charming little cape in a quiet neighborhood. Just a walk to the beach and one and a half miles to the ocean. Enjoy the entire home all by yourself and your guest for the price of privacy. In light of the COVID-19 pandemic, I have not only participated in Airbnb's Enhanced Cleaning Protocols but I have enlisted the services of a cleaning company that specializes in complete disinfection of residential and commercial spaces. So you can relax with peace of mind.

What guests are saying:

“Carmen’s place was the perfect spot for our pandemic honeymoon! Her house was spacious and spotlessly clean, her yard immaculately landscaped, private and quiet. We had a great time grilling and eating on the deck while our dogs played in the yard. Right now the closest beach at Smith point is checking IDs to make sure you live in the area, so you can’t bring a car to park at the beach if you’re not a Suffolk county resident, but the park rangers told us you can still park at the marina then walk across the bridge to go to the beach. We chose to go to the smaller Shirley beach and the Mud Creek Dog Park instead, both of which were perfect for our purposes. All in all we loved our stay and would definitely stay here again! Thanks so much for having us!!”

My Happy Place
SUPERHOSTPrivate room · 2 guests · 1 bed · 1 private bath
My Happy Place

In-law Suite - Private bathroom, bedroom and entrance! Wake up to the beautiful view of our large property. Come see Suzy and Rosey our two beautiful horses and our adorable little flock of Red Star Hens. Enjoy a swim in the 50ft in-ground pristine swimming pool. Escape the hassles of crowded places and come to My Happy Place for your getaway. Always sparkling clean! Embrace the peaceful environment we provide for guests with room to spread out and enjoy.

What guests are saying:

“There are Airbnb hosts and then there's Lisa. This was my first time ever having interacted with an Airbnb in such an intimate manner. I'm so glad that I had the opportunity to meet Lisa and her lovely family (including her two beautiful horses and her chickens). From the moment my partner and I arrived we were overwhelmed by how friendly and accommodating Lisa was. When we finally met in person she greeted us with a smile and she introduced us to her horses. We had 24/7 access to a pool, hammocks, plenty of lounging space, time to be alone, and wonderful company when we wanted it. We got to roast marshmallows and listen to some pretty amazing stories by the fire pit too. Lisa's ”happy place" was certainly a breath of fresh air, especially after 3 months of lockdown in the city. The room is perfect for two. There are plenty of delicious restaurants nearby and the beaches are less that 30min drives away. Thank you for opening your home to us. We hope to return soon!”

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you.

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Fire Island holiday rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wi-Fi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Fire Island

Cozy home away from home!!
Entire guesthouse
Cozy home away from home!!
Price:$116 AUD / night
The Unhampton
SUPERHOSTEntire guesthouse
The Unhampton
Price:$187 AUD / night
Fire Island Pines Mid-Century Beach Cottage
SUPERHOSTEntire house
Fire Island Pines Mid-Century Beach Cottage
Price:$620 AUD / night
Cozy, Private Guest suite
SUPERHOSTPrivate room
Cozy, Private Guest suite
Price:$53 AUD / night
Amazing Fully Furnished near Fire Island Ferries
SUPERHOSTEntire apartment
Amazing Fully Furnished near Fire Island Ferries
Price:$220 AUD / night
SECRET HIDEAWAY: LUXURY L.I. STUDIO W/PRIV. ENTRN
SUPERHOSTEntire house
SECRET HIDEAWAY: LUXURY L.I. STUDIO W/PRIV. ENTRN
Price:$281 AUD / night
Mod 2 / private bath, deck & pantry kitchen*
Private room
Mod 2 / private bath, deck & pantry kitchen*
Price:$307 AUD / night
Bay Shore's Private Guest Suite
SUPERHOSTEntire guest suite
Bay Shore's Private Guest Suite
Price:$162 AUD / night
Bright Fun Dome Beach House (100 yards to Beach)
Dome house
Bright Fun Dome Beach House (100 yards to Beach)
Price:$669 AUD / night
Private Cozy and Comfortable 1 Bdrm Apartment
SUPERHOSTEntire apartment
Private Cozy and Comfortable 1 Bdrm Apartment
Price:$191 AUD / night
Studio Apartment in Cherry Grove
SUPERHOSTEntire apartment
Studio Apartment in Cherry Grove
Price:$321 AUD / night
☀️NEW LISTING! 2BR Oceanview Hideaway☀️
SUPERHOSTEntire cottage
☀️NEW LISTING! 2BR Oceanview Hideaway☀️
Price:$935 AUD / night
Show all