Island holiday rentals in Northeastern United States

Find and book unique island rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated island rentals in Northeastern United States

Guests agree: These island rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1

Guest favourite

An outdoor deck with a round table and four chairs is positioned near the water. A wooden bench runs along one side. Surrounding lattice adds privacy, while trees and a calm lake are visible in the background, enhancing the serene setting.

Island in Youngs Point

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Camping on a private island in the Kawarthas

Campout on your very own private island in the Kawarthas. Great for swimming, fishing, and enjoying nature. 14 foot aluminum boat provided, no motor...but it's only about 150 ft from our dock on shore to our dock on the island. Boat traffic on the Trent can be a little busier on weekends, so there could be the odd wave which could make it difficult for swimming with or even fun for children. Always wear proper PFD Weekend noise from the trailer park can sometimes go into the night past midnight.

Guest favourite

A quaint cabin surrounded by tall trees features outdoor seating composed of two wooden chairs. Hanging pots and tools adorn the cabin's exterior, complementing the natural setting. Sunlight filters through the foliage, creating a serene atmosphere in this forested area.

Bungalow in Greig

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

The Stabbin Cabin Grant Island w/Boat, HotTub, Pet

The Stabbin Cabin is a unique private bungalow on Grant Island, Brantingham Lake featured on ABC & Buzzfeed. Heres Why * Experience Island Life * Dogs can run free * Steamy HotTub * Electric Boat & Freedom to explore and travel * Great Fishing * Beach Area with Diving Board, Floats & Beach Toys * Beautiful Bathroom and Shower * 20% off Jetski, Boat and ATV rentals * BBQ grill & utensils * Fast Wifi * TV with Roku (Netflix) * 420 friendly * Build memories that last a lifetime * IG: @grantisland

Top Guest favourite

An aerial view captures the historic limestone mill surrounded by lush greenery and the winding river. The buildings are nestled along the water's edge, with willow trees providing shade. A wooden deck extends into the river, enhancing the serene natural setting.

Guest suite in Marysville

5 out of 5 average rating, 215 reviews

Island Mill Waterfall Retreat-Jan-April Night Free

Listing description *ALL INCLUDED* ( with seasonal variations) HotTub~4 Watercraft~Park Pass~Bikes~Outdoor Fire & Shower~Veggie Garden A one-of-a-kind experience awaits you in our 200 year old converted limestone mill. This eclectic space with a private entrance is nestled between two waterfalls on an island in the Salmon River. The beautifully appointed 525 sq ft suite is right on the edge of the river. Dine & relax on your private patio overlooking the waterfalls and the old one lane bridge.

Guest favourite

A charming boathouse features a light-colored exterior with a prominent weather vane and a wooden sign. Two red chairs are positioned on the deck, overlooking the serene waters. A backdrop of trees and a blue sky with scattered clouds enhances the rustic setting.

Island in Clayton

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Island Boat House - Fisher's Landing, NY

The Island Boat House is on a private 2 acre island in the 1000 Islands near Fisher's Landing, NY. You may bring or rent a boat, or we can provide rides in our boat for arrival and departure. This rustic & charming two br living space has a double & queen bed in the main room with a double bed in a separate room. An historic boathouse over the water, guests enjoy a private deck, with shower, dock & grill downstairs. Enjoy the majesty of the St. Lawrence River - fishing, swimming and sunsets!!

Guest favourite

The living area features a wood-paneled ceiling and walls, complemented by large windows allowing natural light. A cast iron gas fireplace stands against one wall, and a wooden coffee table sits in front of a spacious sofa. A small desk and two chairs are positioned beside the fireplace.

Cabin in Paul Smiths

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Mrs. Otis's Cabin with Woodland View

In the tradition of the Adirondack Great Camps - magnificent rustic compounds of comfort built a century ago by the rich and powerful on wilderness estates. White Pine Camp offers a year round restful retreat in unparalleled natural surroundings. Here, in the heart of the Adirondacks the largest protected wilderness in the continental United States, guests receive the key to peace and tranquility, a place to recharge the spirit. As a guest, you have your choice of 13 distinctive cabins

Guest favourite

Two green Adirondack chairs are positioned on a wooden deck, facing a scenic view of the ocean and surrounding greenery. A small glass table sits between the chairs, while the expansive landscape features grass and trees under clear blue skies.

Cottage in Tremont

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Sealport Cottage: Full week Saturday-Saturday only

Sealport Ocean Cottage is a magical place with sparkly days and starry nights! Beautiful ocean views of Seal Cove, Blue Hill Bay on the "Quietside" of this island. Rustic, family owned for 60+ years, this comfy, quiet summer only cottage is all yours to enjoy sunsets, days on the porch, woods and seashore near Acadia National Park. Weekly rentals Saturday to Saturdays only: check-in 4pm or later, check-out 10am, with 5 safety hours between guests for professional cleanings, relax & enjoy!

Guest favourite

A covered wooden dock extends over calm waters, framed by trees. A cozy hammock is suspended, inviting relaxation. A warm glow emanates from a nearby building, while a clear night sky above is filled with countless stars creating a serene and captivating atmosphere.

Island in Steenburg Lake

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

Off-Grid Private Island - Miracle Island

Sustainable eco-tourism nestled in the heart of Steenburg Lake enjoy the tranquility of your own private Island with breath taking 360-degree views. As a Superhost, we guarantee an unforgettable stay filled with comfort, convenience, and endless adventure. Our cozy bohemian inspired accommodations comfortably sleep up to 5 guests. With multiple outdoor areas to taking in nature and explore with use of kayaks and snorkelling gear. All linens and supplies are provided for your convenience.

Guest favourite

The rustic exterior of the historic retreat features a weathered brown shingle facade and a vibrant red front door. A spacious deck extends towards the water, surrounded by greenery and providing a serene view of the tidal Sheepscot River at sunset.

Farm stay in Westport Island

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

The Stilt House

Once the island Trading Post (in the 1820's) now serves as a private retreat on Westport Island. The whole property has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places since 1982. The building is nestled at the water's edge, half on land and half on stilts over the tidal waters of the Sheepscot River. The property has its own private deck, island, rocky beach, trails and hammock. This is an old structure - over 200 years old! A great piece of history and an absolute oasis.

Superhost

The cottage is set back on a private lane, surrounded by lush greenery and trees. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance, framed by a mix of grass and foliage. The structure showcases wooden details and a covered porch area, contributing to a natural, serene environment.

Home in Yarmouth

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Eagle's Nest on 8 acres next little john preserve

Nestled on 8 acres overlooking Casco Bay, the Eagle's Nest cottage has 1 bedroom and 1 bathroom. Open plan with full-kitchen and living room including a queen-size sofa bed. Located on an island, you're only 20 minutes from downtown Portland and 10 minutes from downtown Yarmouth. Last but not least the cottage is a 5-minute walk from a 23-acre preserve that has numerous scenic viewpoints, tide pools and ledges, and picnic tables. Coastal Maine at its best!

Top Guest favourite

An aerial view captures a secluded log cabin surrounded by lush greenery on a private island. A wooden dock extends over the tranquil water, providing access to the cabin, which is nestled among trees. Sunlight glistens on the lake's surface.

Island in Monmouth

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 257 reviews

Naughty Dog Private Island Log Cabin

Be alone with your pup enjoying leash freedom on this remote island. Your 1400 acre backyard is Annabessacook Lake. Enjoy pristine surroundings, a rustic, off-the-grid log cabin, with solar lighting and a hot shower. Swimming, boating, fishing, birding, and relaxing by the fire - do it all (or not). Prepare for adventure! Pack light: Bring your vacay clothes, pups, favorite food, & be ready for a blissful, private island get away. It's AWAY away.

Guest favourite

An aerial view captures a private island surrounded by calm waters, with lush trees densely covering the land. A small dock extends into the lake, providing access for activities. The tranquil setting is complemented by the clear water and dense forest, showcasing natural beauty.

Island in Saint-Adolphe-d'Howard

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Quiet private island! New SPA and Sauna!

New in 2024 – Thermal experience with private HOT TUB and SAUNA on the island! Private island for your exclusive use on a lake with exceptional water quality and surrounded by forest. Accessible in summer and winter. In summer, you can enjoy a private pontoon for crossing and your exclusive use on the lake. During the winter, the island is accessible on foot on the ice. Fully equipped cottage with many activities available year-round.

Guest favourite

A scenic aerial view of a private island surrounded by calm waters, reflecting the greenery from the surrounding trees. The landscape showcases a mixture of vibrant foliage and distant hills, providing a serene backdrop in the heart of Hudson Valley.

Island in Pine Plains

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 93 reviews

Private Island on Twin Island Lake

Embark on an off-grid luxury glamping adventure in the heart of Hudson Valley, discover one of Twin Island Lake’s private island with 360 degree views.. Reconnect with yourselves and nature in a Safari style tent furnished with a queen size bed. 13x10 gazebo with outdoor amenities. Park on the mainland next to the dock where a canoe awaits your arrival. This sweet escape is a once in a lifetime experience you will remember forever.