Holiday rentals with lake access in New Buffalo

Find and book unique lake access rentals on Airbnb

Quick stats about holiday rentals with lake access in New Buffalo

  • Total holiday rentals

    Explore 20 holiday rentals in New Buffalo

  • Nightly prices starting at

    New Buffalo holiday rentals start at $295 AUD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 2,520 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly holiday rentals

    20 properties offer extra space and kid-friendly amenities

  • Pet-friendly accommodation

    Find 10 rentals that welcome pets

  • Rentals with dedicated workspaces

    10 properties have a dedicated workspace

  • Wi-Fi availability

    20 of New Buffalo holiday rentals include Wi-Fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wi-Fi and Pool across New Buffalo rentals

  • 4.8 Average rating

    New Buffalo stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.8 out of 5!

Top-Rated Accommodation with Lake Access in New Buffalo

Guests agree: These options for accommodation with lake access are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
A modern kitchen is visible, featuring white cabinetry and stainless steel appliances. The living area includes a comfortable couch and a round table with a decorative runner. Natural light fills the space, highlighting the open layout and ceiling beams.
Home in Lakeside

Couples alert! PVT beach access, hot tub, firepit!

ADORABLE LAKESIDE COTTAGE W/YEAR-ROUND HOT TUB AND A GUEST FAVORITE - ACCESS TO SEMI-PRIVATE LAKE MICHIGAN BEACH SHARED BY JUST 10 HOMES SO IT'S NEVER CROWDED! BEACH ACCESS GATE IS 7 MIN WALK FROM COTTAGE. LOFT LIKE HOME IS SUPER CLEAN WITH VERY COMFY KING SIZE BED AND ONE PULL-OUT COUCH FOR 4 GUEST (MAX). FIREPIT SUPPLIED WITH WOOD, AN OUTDOOR PATIO AND WEBER GRILL - YOU WILL LOVE IT! Bike/walking path out front and just 10 mins to New Buffalo, Whistle Stop, coffee - just steps away!! HURRY!

NearbyOutdoor spacesFamily

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 307 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A bright living room features high ceilings with a chandelier above a central wooden coffee table. Comfortable dark gray sofas are positioned around the table, complemented by decorative cushions. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, and a stone fireplace adds a cozy focal point.
Cottage in Union Pier

Designer Cottage Relax Pool Beach & Spa—Windjammer

Escape to the Windjammer, Designer Cottage, Pool & Spa Relaxation in Lakeshore Cottages Union Pier. Enjoy 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, private resort-style neighborhood pool, private hot tub, fire pit, indoor fireplace, and loft for the kids! Take advantage of the beach and explore beautiful Harbor Country. Relax & unwind in this luxurious updated getaway with plenty of sun filled space for all to enjoy year-round. Professional Wolf stove for the chefs. Book your stay today! Create lasting memories!

NearbyViewHot tub

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 250 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The cabin's exterior is framed by colorful autumn foliage, with vibrant red leaves and dappled sunlight filtering through the surrounding trees. Stone steps lead to the entrance, enhancing the rustic charm of the well-maintained landscape.
Cabin in Michiana

Luxury Cabin Getaway •2 min to Beach• 1hr Chicago

Luxury meets nature: forest cabin steps from the beach, 1 hour from Chicago. Book your escape to our designer log cabin on Lake Michigan just steps from the beach and nestled in a peaceful forest, it’s the perfect retreat. Built in 1932, our charming cabin sleeps 8 in 4 bedrooms. Enjoy 2 living areas, a stone fireplace, fire pit, games, puzzles & books. Featured in Country Living and the NYT, it’s perfect for families, friends, or retreats. Book now and create lasting memories in Michiana.

Outdoor spacesViewFamily

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A screened-in porch features a cozy seating arrangement with two navy blue chairs and a matching sofa set around a narrow coffee table. Skylights and large windows create a bright space with views of the surrounding wooded area.
Cottage in New Buffalo

The Birdhouse – quiet luxury, walk everywhere

The Birdhouse is on a quiet wooded ravine steps from restaurants, shopping and a lovely 0.7 mile walk to the beach. This home hosts 4 guests only, including infants. Enjoy a screened-in porch with views to the woods, an outdoor eating area with grill, lovely terrace with firepit and laundry room. Bedrooms are cozy and comfortable. The bathroom features a luxurious rain shower with hand shower for junior guests. To allow our cleaning crew time to prepare, we're unable to offer early check-ins.

Outdoor spacesNearbyTV

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 314 reviews
Guest favourite
The game area features various arcade games, including a shuffleboard table and foosball. A large projector and ping pong table are present, alongside colorful murals depicting the local scenery. The inviting space emphasizes relaxation and entertainment, supported by comfortable seating arrangements.
Home in New Buffalo

Arcade/Game Room • Private Beach Access • Fire Pit

Spacious, completely remodeled home with 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, 2 living areas, game room w/ mural, arcade games, ping pong, shuffleboard, foosball & pop-a-shot, outdoor living space w/ screened in patio Located in a charming neighborhood with private beach access 1/2 mile from the house. -5 minutes to downtown New Buffalo -10 minutes to downtown Michigan City -10 minutes to Lighthouse Premium Outlets -20 minutes to Indiana Dunes National Park -within 10 minutes of 2 different casinos

Outdoor spacesNearbyAccess

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews
Top Guest favourite
An aerial view showcases a marina filled with boats, adjacent to modern waterfront homes. The calm water reflects a clear sky, while a tree-lined pathway and parking area are visible in the foreground, enhancing the serene environment.
Condo in New Buffalo

Live the marina life in New Buffalo!

Enjoy the unique experience of living in the center of a marina and in the heart of the waterfront district walking distance to the beach, restaurants & shops in downtown New Buffalo! Our penthouse 2bed/2 bath condo w 2 large balconies is thoughtfully outfitted for everything you need to enjoy your stay with water views from any window. We ask that guests do not smoke inside the home/ first floor marina. Pets & parties are also not welcome. Follow us on IG at "themarinalifenewbuffalo"

NearbyOutdoor spacesLayout

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews
Guest favourite
A stylish living area features a blue sofa with throw pillows, situated on a patterned rug. Natural light streams through a skylight, illuminating the open layout that includes a dining space and kitchen with modern appliances. Minimalist decor enhances the inviting ambiance.
Home in New Buffalo

Steps to Beach & Starbucks! Private Yard, Firepit!

Walk to Starbucks! Walk to beach, cafes, shops, ice cream, grocery! 2 queen bed 2 bath home is perfect to enjoy fenced yard, grill, fire pit, & yard games! Take a few days to explore wineries/breweries, art galleries, antique stores, kayaking, casino and more! Live bands Fridays/Saturdays till around 2am Memorial Weekend to Fall, New Year's at Casey's (behind property). Noise machines in each bdrm. Pet fee $100, 2 dogs MAX. Exterior areas have video/audio cameras w/live feeds. Wp#bcnbwmech

NearbyViewHospitality

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 239 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A cabin exterior is presented, featuring a screened-in porch that offers comfortable seating. The structure, painted in a muted green tone, is surrounded by trees and foliage. A set of steps leads to the porch, creating easy access to the welcoming retreat.
Cabin in Union Pier

Walk 2 Lake/Shops | Hot Tub | King Bed | Fireplace

Tucked away sophisticated cabin in the heart of Downtown Union Pier. Killer location that's just steps away from dining and drinks: Black Current Bakery, Neon Moon Gelato, Union Pier Market, and Union Pier Social. Townline Beach is a 10 minute walk, and the cabin is right off the bike path. Seeds Brewery is just down the road and local Wineries are 1 mile away. Back home enjoy a relaxing hot tub (available year round), wood burning fire place, spacious screened in porch & outdoor fire pit.

Outdoor spacesViewTV

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The exterior of the cottage displays a welcoming front porch, framed by tall green grass and lush greenery. The door is accented with a decorative arch window, while the roof features a gentle slope, contributing to the charming cabin feel.
Cottage in New Buffalo

Blue Haven Lake Cottage

Relax at our lake cottage retreat, near vibrant downtown of New Buffalo, MI, in a quiet and peaceful private wooded setting. Close to many local attractions and beaches! Walk or bike, to restaurants, boutiques, coffee shops and ice cream parlors. Four Winds Casino is only 5 minutes drive. Harbor Country wineries & breweries, trails, farmers markets, are all within a few minutes. Easy access to nearby beach towns and beautiful Warren Dunes. Ideal space for families, girl trips or couples!

NearbyOutdoor spacesIndoor spaces

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews
Guest favourite
Home in New Buffalo

Lux home, sauna, hot tub, firepit, 5 min to town

WELCOME TO GOLDIE’S BEACH HOUSE, a cheeky stay somewhere between home and hotel. GOLDIE'S is decked out with everything you need to feel right at home. From top-notch coffee for lazy mornings to sippy cups for the kiddos, we've got you covered. We’re a 3 bedroom 2 bath ranch designed for families who love a little luxury and a lot of sunshine. The sauna and hot tub don’t take seasons off and are available all year. If you’re looking for a quiet spot close to town THIS IS THE PLACE.

Outdoor spacesNearbyHot tub

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The exterior of Twin Cottage A is shown, featuring a light blue front door framed by white columns. A white bench is positioned beside the entrance on a wood deck. Lush greenery and sunlight illuminate the area, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.
Cottage in New Buffalo

Twin Cottage A- Walk to Beach & Town!

Twin Cottage A is your home for convenience & comfort! 2 blocks from town shopping & restaurants, Church Brewing Co. around the corner, an artisanal cocktail lounge up the block and only 3700 feet to the beach! You'll have a private, fenced in backyard for the kids and/or dogs. gas grill, outdoor dining & a fire pit stocked with wood. Check out Cottage B as well for a complete look at our reviews. *Stays 28 days or longer require weekly cleaning fee added after inquiry or request

Outdoor spacesNearbyAmenities

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 460 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The exterior of the cottage is surrounded by trees, with a designated seating area featuring two blue Adirondack chairs and a wooden table. A firepit sits in the gravel yard, offering a natural gathering space among green foliage.
Cottage in Union Pier

Beach Bird Cottage- 5min walk to the lake! 3BR/1BA

Dear friends, Welcome to Beach Bird Cottage, situated on a quiet street with other vintage cottages in the heart of Union Pier. It is an easy 5-minute walk to an association beach. The cottage has many updates, including a new kitchen, bathroom, washer/dryer, outdoor shower and a wood stove. The master and second bedroom each have queen-size beds and the children's bedroom has two twin beds. Enjoy an early swim before breakfast or have an evening beach picnic under the sunset.

NearbyOutdoor spacesWalkability

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Popular amenities for New Buffalo lake access rentals

Lake access house rentals

Top Guest favourite
A cozy living area features a comfortable couch adorned with soft pillows. A modern coffee table sits in front, complemented by a small potted plant. A fireplace is surrounded by a white stone wall, with flickering flames providing a warm glow, and large windows allow natural light to enter.
Home in Michiana

House of Lotus- Chicago getaway

Outdoor spacesNearbyIndoor spaces

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews
Guest favourite
The exterior of the cottage is framed by lush greenery, featuring a covered patio with wooden beams. Seating is arranged under the structure, inviting relaxation. The space is surrounded by decorative landscaping and opens to a tranquil forest backdrop.
Home in Union Pier

Barn & Beach Guest house New Buffalo/Union Pier

Outdoor spacesNearbyCleanliness

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 208 reviews
Top Guest favourite
Home in La Porte

Aunt Betty's Lakeside Abode, Hot Tub Steam Shower

Outdoor spacesNearbyIndoor spaces

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 258 reviews
Guest favourite
The dining area features a large wooden table surrounded by comfortable seating, illuminated by a modern pendant light. Nearby, the hot tub area is visible through large glass doors, nestled among lush greenery, providing a tranquil outdoor experience.
Home in Michigan City

Beach! Hot Tub! New Buffalo! Firepit! King Bed!

ViewOutdoor spacesSleep quality

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews
Top Guest favourite
Home in Benton Harbor

LakeMichigan•Beach•Hot Tub•Sauna•Amazing Views

ViewNearbyAccuracy

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The charming two-story home features a wide front porch with ample seating and decorative lighting. White railings and a wooden design enhance its appeal. Flanking trees provide some greenery, and the entryway is welcoming with its open doors and stylish decor.
Home in Michigan City

5 Bedroom Luxury Home In Heart of Beachwalk Resort

NearbyOutdoor spacesPool

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 206 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A spacious living area showcases a light-colored sectional sofa adorned with plush pillows. Large windows allow natural light to fill the room, revealing wooden flooring and eye-catching artwork on the walls. A dining table is visible in the background, complemented by a minimalist plant.
Home in Michigan City

House of Zen: Peaceful Modern Cabin on Tryon Farm

NearbyOutdoor spacesCondition

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 350 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The exterior of the barniminium is displayed, featuring a red and white color scheme. Windows are positioned symmetrically along the front, with a small seating area consisting of four white chairs and a table. The surrounding landscape includes grassy areas and subtle gravel pathways.
Home in Bridgman

The Schmidt House

ViewOutdoor spacesLaundry

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Lake access apartment rentals

Lake access cottage rentals

Guest favourite
A cottage exterior is showcased with blue siding and a welcoming porch. Lush greenery and colorful flowers surround the home, adding to its appeal. Large windows offer ample natural light, while trees enhance the privacy of the property.
Cottage in Lakeside

Pebble Path Cottage - Less than a block to beach!

NearbyOutdoor spacesLocation

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A charming cottage is nestled among tall pine trees, partially obscured by greenery. The natural surroundings create a tranquil setting, while the rustic stone chimney adds character to the cozy structure.
Cottage in Michiana Shores

1930’s Cozy Cottage in the Woods.Walk to the beach

ViewNearbyBackyard

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A rustic cottage is nestled among lush greenery, featuring a stone path that leads to the entrance. The home, with blue shutters and a welcoming porch, is framed by a flowering tree and various plants, creating a peaceful setting.
Cottage in Valparaiso

Flint Lake Cottage.

ViewNearbyWalkability

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 633 reviews
Guest favourite
Cottage in Sawyer

Cozy Sawyer Beach Cottage- Walk to Warren Dunes

Outdoor spacesNearbyQuiet

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 281 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A charming cottage is surrounded by lush green landscaping and vibrant flowers. A screened-in porch is adorned with lights, leading to an inviting entryway. A separate storage garage is visible in the background, complementing the colorful exterior of the cottage.
Cottage in Union Pier

Steps to the Beach! Screened in Porch & Firepit!

ViewNearbyCleanliness

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 412 reviews
Top Guest favourite
The tranquil surface of Flint Lake reflects a colorful sunset, with soft hues of pink and orange blending into the serene blue sky. The surrounding tree line is silhouetted against the fading light, creating a peaceful and calming atmosphere.
Cottage in Valparaiso

The Lake Escape -Cozy Lakefront Cottage Valparaiso

Outdoor spacesNearbyQuiet

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 471 reviews
Top Guest favourite
A spacious deck with metal furniture is surrounded by tall trees and lush greenery. A nearby screen porch offers a view of the natural setting, creating an inviting atmosphere for relaxation outdoors.
Cottage in Union Pier

Harbor Country Michigan Hide-Away

ViewOutdoor spacesAmenities

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 292 reviews
Guest favourite
An inviting cottage exterior features a wooden fence and a screened porch. Surrounding greenery showcases tall grasses and autumn foliage, creating an appealing atmosphere. A chimney and part of the roof can be seen, indicating the cozy interior space.
Cottage in Union Pier

J’s Beach House: Hot Tub & short walk to beach!

Outdoor spacesViewDecor

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 366 reviews

When is the best time to visit New Buffalo?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJuneJulyAugSeptOctNovDec
Avg. price$316 AUD$306 AUD$299 AUD$322 AUD$457 AUD$521 AUD$621 AUD$555 AUD$416 AUD$334 AUD$306 AUD$316 AUD
Avg. temp-4°C-3°C3°C9°C15°C20°C22°C22°C18°C11°C4°C-1°C