Skip to content

Vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

When results are available, navigate with up and down arrow keys or explore by touch or swipe gestures.

Top-rated holiday rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Guest favourite
Apartment in New Buffalo
Peach by the Beach! 1 Bdrm Apt close to downtown
The Peach by the Beach is a one-bedroom private apartment that sleeps two people. It's a two-minute walk to downtown New Buffalo and a ten-minute walk to the beach! This chic apartment is close to the beach, restaurants, shopping, and all kinds of fun! This location is perfect for couples, singles, and business travelers. It is the perfect getaway from the hustle and bustle of daily life. This location includes free wifi, coffee and tea, beach towels and chairs, and a full-service kitchen.
3 – 10 Dec
Guest favourite
Barn in Michigan City
The Black Pearl Great Escape Spa & Art Shop
Check out our website! thegreatescapespah.com The Black 🖤 Pearl is perfect for a Special Occasion for the Evening. Book a Couples Massage @ 3p.m. & Check into your Spa Suite @ 4 p.m. Kick your feet Up & Order in.... Or Dine Out~ This quaint property is located in a woodsy setting 5 minutes from Lake Michigan. The keyless entry door to The Black Pearl is located on the East wall of The Great Escape. Upon entry the Black Pearl door will be directly in front of you. Mini Luxury awaits!
8 – 15 Dec
Guest favourite
Cottage in New Buffalo
The Birdhouse – quiet luxury, walk everywhere
The Birdhouse is a cottage on a quiet wooded ravine steps from restaurants, shopping and a lovely 0.7 mile walk to the beach. This home hosts 4 guests only, including infants. Enjoy a screened-in porch with views to the woods, an outdoor eating area with grill, firepit and laundry room. Both bedrooms are cozy and comfortable. The bathroom features a luxurious rain shower with hand shower for junior guests. To allow our cleaning crew time to prepare, we're unable to offer early check-ins.
27 Aug – 3 Sept

Popular amenities for New Buffalo holiday rentals

Stay near New Buffalo's top sights

The Stray Dog Bar & Grill198 locals recommend
Redamak's117 locals recommend
Galien River County Park96 locals recommend
Oink's Dutch Treat96 locals recommend
Barney's87 locals recommend
Brewster's Italian Cafe87 locals recommend

Other great holiday rentals in New Buffalo

Guest favourite
Cottage in Union Pier
Steps to Lake! Fully fenced yard w/hot tub & sauna
10 – 17 Jan
Guest favourite
Cottage in Union Pier
Steps to the Beach! Screened in Porch & Firepit!
9 – 16 Oct
Guest favourite
Home in New Buffalo
Farmesque with a splash of modern
11 – 18 Jan
Guest favourite
Cottage in New Buffalo
Cozy New Buffalo Retreat
25 Jan – 1 Feb
Guest favourite
Tiny home in New Buffalo
SoulShine Inn • Pets Welcome•Fully fenced backyard
14 – 21 Sept
Guest favourite
Farm stay in Sawyer
Your SW Michigan Modern Farmhouse Cottage Awaits
28 Sept – 5 Oct
Guest favourite
Home in Lakeside
Adorable couples escape with year-round hot tub!
8 – 15 Aug
Guest favourite
Cottage in New Buffalo
Perfect Get Away - Private Hot Tub - Lots of Room
19 – 26 Oct
Guest favourite
Home in Michigan City
Beautiful beach bungalow with hiking and hot tub!
18 – 25 Nov
Guest favourite
Home in Michigan City
TRYON FARM MID-MODERN SPA IN THE WOODS
14 – 21 Oct
Guest favourite
Cottage in New Buffalo
The Lemonade Cottage, New Buffalo. Walk to beach!
27 Mar – 3 Apr
Guest favourite
Cabin in Michiana
Steps to the beach at cute cabin 1hr from Chicago
25 Apr – 2 May

Quick stats about holiday rentals in New Buffalo

Total rentals

170 properties

Rentals with a pool

50 properties have a pool

Pet-friendly rentals

60 properties allow pets

Family-friendly rentals

150 properties are a good fit for families

Total number of reviews

9.7K reviews

Nightly prices starting at

$137 AUD before taxes and fees

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Michigan
  4. Berrien County
  5. New Buffalo