Guesthouse holiday rentals in Indiana

Teri & Dave thank you so much for the amazing hospitality, your place is amazing and just what we needed for my friend’s wedding near by.

Traveling solo this trip…. Nothing to fear! Tim was a great host! Always felt safe and at ‘ home’. Guesthouse was clean, quiet neighborhood, and responsive host. Would definitely return

We arrived at night so had a hard time finding the driveway despite perfect directions. The entry and check in instructions were clear. It was early March with still a bit of chill in the air but the space was warm and cozy on arrival. The area was safe and walkable in the day and at night, in spite of our unfamiliarity with Indianapolis! We attended events at Gainbridge Fieldhouse - such an easy walk! - and explored the downtown, Mass Ave, Fletcher Place, and Upper Canal neighborhoods. While we didn’t spend a lot of time in the space, we did use the kitchen for all our breakfasts and even dinner twice. The kitchen area is small but provided everything we needed! This space is great for one or two people traveling for any sporting event downtown. Highly recommend! We also asked Josie and Rob for one area recommendation and they responded quickly and were more than helpful.

The positives: Adam was very hospitable and even cleared snow from the landing pad outside the garage, which was very helpful. The unit was super private and we were able to come and go as we pleased. The garage door was loud but the times the owners were coming and going did not affect us. AND we had our own enclosed parking space that went straight to our unit. Super nice! Overall, I would highly recommend! The unit was super clean and looked just like the pictures. Privacy was key and the coming and going was simple. Great price. Definitely would stay again! Thanks Adam!

The property was clean and comfortable and allowed for easy access. It was as described and was very close to the worksite that our guys were working on. Elise was very easy to contact if you had any questions and was also very friendly and helpful!

I was so happy with the stay. It absolutely exceeded my expectations. The area is beautiful and the structure really nails the cottage vibes. Leslie is very accommodating and even let us know when we arrived that we could stay past check out. Will stay here again if we are ever in town for a game.

Lovely home in a nice area. We were traveling through the state and needed a last minute stay. Sue responded to our request immediately. Her home was perfect and well stocked with anything we may have forgotten. We really enjoyed the banana muffins that she left.

Tom and Charyl were amazing hosts ! We had open communication throughout our stay and even got a tour upon our arrival. The airbnb was everything as described and more ! The pool was incredible and the airbnb was only a 5 minute drive to the nearest beach. They even had a binder of recommendations available to us of local attractions/things to do. Our expectations were exceeded for this trip, and we can’t wait to come back !

This guesthouse is even more beautiful and private than we anticipated. Huge circle drive with convenient parking. Easy check in and great communication. Lots of restaurants to order in from. 10-15 mins or less from anything you could possibly need (food, shopping, entertainment). Lovely, romantic, and 'almost' perfect decor and finishings surround the comfortably, furnished space. Very clean, has vaulted ceilings, and the backyard oasis makes it hard to believe Chicago's just 45 mins away. Shower stays hot, sauna and home gym is a nice bonus, but we didn't use them, hot tub's private and clean, and outside noise level is a low 2 out of 10. No ice or firewood so you may want to bring your own. MJ isn't legal in Indiana, so proceed with caution. Toll road into Chicago from Indiana is $12+ each way. The piano is beautiful, but for show. My wife and I got a huge kick out of all the Mr. & Mrs. and His & Hers home decor. We loved it, but understandable some may not. Would stay again.

The host is the best experience we’ve ever had with communication! The cottage was extremely clean, nothing over looked. It felt like home! Extremely peaceful! If you are looking to visit Madison but don’t want to stay in town with all the noise, look no further than the Amish cottage! We will 1,000% be back to stay at the cottage!

Carol & Dave are wonderful hosts! I enjoy visiting Chicago, but love that I can disconnect. This little oasis has become my place of tranquility and peace. Carol & Dave have created the perfect, cozy retreat. It's the little things they do such as the personalized Welcome sign, the robes, the heat or ac being on, remembering I like 1/2 & 1/2 for my coffee, leaving snacks like kind bars , a freshly baked coffee cake to make our stay that much more homey & pleasant, to checking in to see if we need anything. I can't express how truly wonderful they are. You need to experience their wonderful hospitality to truly appreciate what amazing hosts they are! I'm looking forward to my next stay in 2025. Jodyann & William

Absolutely wonderful place! Incredibly cute and perfect for our stay. Would love to come back!

I had a great stay at the hillside hideaway. The cabin is small but cozy and had everything we needed. 10 beds and the best couch ever. I would recommend. Gloria was a great host that reached out to make sure we had everything we needed and found the place alright. Full kitchen to make meals was awsome. My only issue was that the shower water had a tough smell of sulfur, which was unpleasant.

The touches of elegance that Logan and Kerry have added to their Airbnb put this stay a step above many others. In particular I loved having the gift basket with fuzzy socks!

The place was nice and clean. Was close to downtown, had everything needed. The owner "Jonathan" was communicative by responding fast and understanding. It had an easy check-in and check-out. It was also felt very private and safe. I would definitely go again if needed.

This was our second time booking this property which ended up being a longer stay. Kelly and George are great hosts who were attentive and easy to communicate with. The place is very comfortable, very clean, very quiet and has everything you need for both a short term and long term stay. It’s within walking distance of the charming downtown area with great restaurants, cute boutiques, a gourmet market and coffee houses. I highly recommend booking this place if ever in the Valpo area!

Perfect for a one night stay! Wanted to be close to the children’s museum so the location was great. Jennifer was even able to get us in a little early to accommodate our son’s nap time. Thanks for a great stay!

We have traveled all over the country and stayed at many different places. The carriage house is now one of our favorites. As soon as you walk in you can tell Kevin and Michael put their hearts into this place! Everything was on point, from the craftsmanship to the decor. I dare you to say you've slept in a more comfortable bed! We didn't want to leave!!!!

Loree was an incredible host! The home was very comfortable and homey. It was equipped with everything we needed to make us feel at home.

Nichole’s carriage house was the perfect place to unwind! I was traveling for work and needed a peaceful place to recharge between shifts- this was it. Check-in was easy, plenty of privacy, perfectly decorated, and in the gorgeous Meridian neighborhood.

2nd time staying here when visiting downtown. it checks the boxes off. only issue is delivery since its located in an ally between 2 streets or uber findinf us. however, we like it enough to book a 2nd time and will again in the future.

Kelly & Dana’s place was perfect for visiting our daughter. The carriage house studio was bright, cheerful, and impeccably clean. We felt like the first guests to stay there. We enjoyed Amelia’s coffee shop and the Sidedoor Bagel shop, both within walking distance. We would definitely stay again.

We loved staying here. It was so clean. It was absolutely wonderful. Convenient to shops, restaurants etc. Dana replies quickly to messages. I’d stay here again without hesitation if I needed to stay in the area.

Great place in a location that was close to lots of restaurants and activities!