House holiday rentals in Buckeye Lake

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Buckeye Lake

Guests agree: These houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favourite

Home in Westerville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Uptown Westerville - Otterbein University

This cozy home has been updated top to bottom and is located on Otterbein University Campus in the heart of Uptown Westerville, next to the historic Hanby House. Walkable to several Locally owned Restaurants, Coffee shops, Bars, unique shopping, Ice Cream, parks, 911 memorial. Under 20 mins to The Columbus Zoo and Zoombezi Bay waterpark, Downtown, Easton Town Center, The Columbus Convention Center, and The Ohio State University. Polaris Fashion Place, Costco, and high-end dining minutes away.

17 – 24 Oct

$1,646 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Newark

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

The Oak Ridge House

Welcome to the Oak Ridge House. Just 5 miles North of I-70 and 5 miles south of State Rt.16. Our tree cover hillside is very close to Flint Ridge Nature Preserve and about 15 minutes from The Virtues Golf Club, Black Hand Gorge Nature Preserve and Sand Hollow Winery. It's a three bedroom home on 2 acres, one king size bed, one queen size bed, and the third room is a sitting room / hang out space with a futton. The enclose back porch is a great hangout space but is not heated. Gov. ID required.

28 May – 4 June

$1,100 AUD total

Superhost

Home in Grove City

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

The Blue House 4BR 2BA Historic Home

Renovated historic home. Space for 8 with 4BR and 2BA in the heart of downtown Grove City. Tastefully decorated and stocked with everything you need for a short stay. Walking distance to restaurants, shopping and library. Under 2 miles to the grocery store and park and easy access to both 270 and 71! We live part time in Ohio. While away we open our home to other travelers! Our hope is that it will be a place relaxation and fun with your friends and family. No smoking and no pets on premises.

5 – 12 July

$1,822 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Alexandria

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

HIdden Valley Farm —Guest House

Situated on a scenic hill in a wooded country setting it’s like waking up in a state park every morning. Just 20 min E of Columbus in Alexandria, Oh. Forget city noise and enjoy wooded hiking trails just outside your door. The Guest House is one of two Airbnb units available on our property. Private entrance, parking at the door ... totally separate from our personal living space. All welcome. This listing is for Guest House only. Large master suite, 2 full baths, laundry and garage.

10 – 17 Dec

$1,950 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Reynoldsburg

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Sophia's Yellow Door House.

Extended Stays Welcomed, Military Discounts offered. Open, airy, cozy ranch has a Chef's kitchen for those who love to cook. Easy living public space, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths. Dining table can seat 8 if needed. Privacy fenced yard, Patio with fire pit and Weber charcoal grill. Great for; couples, families, or a group of friends wanting to be together in one space. Parking for 1 car in drive. Unlimited parking on street. NO GROUPS LARGER THAN 10! Quiet neighborhood convenient to everything.

24 – 31 Aug

$2,245 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Westerville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 404 reviews

Serene Private Space in the Heart of the Ville.

Feel at home in quaint uptown Westerville. A newly renovated space with private entrance off a serene back yard features a patio with a therapeutic hot tub, as well as a spa-like bathroom to provide all the the R&R you'll need to complete your day. Stroll on a nearby walk/bike path or through beautiful Otterbein campus as you make your way to unique shops, coffee houses, ice cream parlors, or restaurants where you can enjoy an adult beverage in the historic town where prohibition began!

4 – 11 Dec

$1,548 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Grove City

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Cozy Cottage w/ Walkability to Downtown Grove City

Our quaint and comfortable 2 bedroom cottage is located just south of Columbus in Grove City. The perfect location for a walk to local brewery/winery, shops, restaurants, the library, and local theater. Also, conveniently located within 10 miles of downtown Columbus, the Ohio State University, Children's Hospital and the Greater Columbus Convention Center. Features include brand new furniture, 1.5 baths, a large fenced yard and optional 2 car garage for longer term accommodations.

13 – 20 Sept

$1,286 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Alexandria

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Cozy Weekend Getaway w/ Hot Tub, Pet Friendly

Conveniently located only 30 mins from Columbus, 5 miles from the village of Granville, home to Denison University, and 5 miles from Intel, this 3BR Home sleeps 6 and is situated on 4 acres in the village of Alexandria. This cozy home features a Hot Tub, Outdoor Patio and unique and stylish interior design features for the ulitmate relaxation getaway. Whether you're in town to visit Denison University or escaping the city, this home in Alexandria is a quiet, peaceful oasis.

30 Aug – 6 Sept

$3,071 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Lancaster

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 345 reviews

Lancaster Luxury Apartment

Your own private entrance, off street parking spot, kitchen, bathroom, dinning area, laundry, and furnished patio. Additional person and extra bed charge at $10 a night per guest with a maximum of four guests. We accept dogs for an additional $25 per stay fee but they must be crated when left alone in the apartment. We do not charge a cleaning fee :-) Minutes from everything Lancaster--bike path, Mt. Pleasant, the downtown historic district, restaurants, and museums.

20 – 27 Nov

$1,210 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Grove City

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Family Home w/ Game Room: Grove City/Columbus

Beautiful, newly remodeled home in Grove City just south of Columbus. Features include brand new furniture, rec room in garage with ping pong, arcade and table shuffle board, 2 full bathrooms, a 4 season room and back yard. Park, playground and pickleball courts right across the street!I It is just a short drive from downtown Columbus and the many amenities it has to offer. 10 miles to Downtown Columbus, The Ohio State University and Greater Columbus Convention Center

8 – 15 July

$1,915 AUD total

Superhost

Home in Thornville

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

The Lookout at Buckeye Lake

Welcome to The Lookout at Buckeye Lake! We stumbled upon this cozy cottage in the summer of 2018 and spent the next 12 months renovating the dream Buckeye Lake getaway. Our first project was an off-grid cabin featured on DIY Network’s Building Off The Grid. We took inspiration from that design to transform The Lookout into the perfect place to unwind and enjoy the lake. Located just 3 miles off I70, and walking distance to neighborhood favorite Papa Boos.

22 – 29 Dec

$3,002 AUD total

Guest favourite

Home in Logan

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 214 reviews

Natures Crest Retreat, Hocking Hills

10/29/22 The gravel driveway has been paved. Welcome to Natures Crest Retreat! This property is on the very top of a hill with complete privacy in the beautiful Hocking Hills less than 2 miles from Boch Hollow Nature Preserve. Natures Crest Retreat offers two bedrooms and two full bathrooms. Enjoy a soak in the Jacuzzi hot tub, hang out by the fire pit or relax on the porch swing you are going to love this secluded retreat.

26 Apr – 3 May

$2,876 AUD total