Cottage holiday rentals in Presque Isle

As other reviewers have said, Cynthia has a great little get-away. We changed arrival plans/departure plans and she was very accomdating to each request. Really enjoyed the cats, they are very friendly. Beware, the stairs to the upstairs living area are bit tricky to navigate, especially when carrying a bag.

I stayed at many airbnbs and this one easily takes a spot in the top 3. Kelly's place was everything you could wish for. We felt right at home as soon as we walked in. The cottage was clean and way better than its description. The kitchen was stocked with everything one would need and even included snacks and water. Kelly also provided us with firewood for the fire pit! The beds and linen were comfortable and clean and the bathroom was spotless. Kelly proactively reached out to us and even suggested nearby places we should visit. The place is within an hour drive of multiple attractions and if you don't feel like driving far, the lake has everything you need. This is one of those places where after just day the first thought is "I need to book here again"

My group of friends and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay at BL Cottage. It is a fantastic place for large groups. We especially loved the large dining area, where we could all share a meal together, while looking out onto the beautiful lake. Having the hot tub and sauna was an added bonus! It is a great place to stay and enjoy all it has to offer! We will definitely come back again! Thanks Kristina for all the great info you shared with us and for always responding quickly to my questions!!

Overall, Amanda’s place was adorable and a great getaway for a long weekend! Amanda is very responsive and kind. We had a few hiccups with the house (technical things) and she was very responsive and willing to help as much as she could despite not being in the area. It is a tight space for more than 6 people. There were 7 total in our group so keep in mind it only having one shower and some close sleeping quarters. The beds were very comfy and clean though. It was still cool with the AC window units on too (if staying in the summer). All in all would stay again!

The home is so beautiful, I took pictures because I really want to build a home and it’s what I’m going to base it off of!!! Kathlene was so helpful. Anything we needed she was right on it.!! we will plan on coming again in the future! You will not be disappointed in this location or the home itself!!

My family and I stayed at Tony’s place for a long weekend and I have to say it was amazing!! First of all Tony made sure that we had proper directions to the property and how to access the house. Upon entering the house we were astounded by how lovely Tony’s lake house is and then the views of the lake were just panoramic!! We could not have found for a better place to stay! We had easy access to our own private little beach, it was literally right outside the sliding glass doors and we could sit on the patio and watch the sun both rise and set. The kitchen was fully equipped, the house was very spacious and we were excited to find a bookshelf full of childrens books which made our little one very happy. Yes there were quite a few steps to access the property but we found the journey up and down the steps very doable and the path was very well lit. It was exciting going down those steps through the wooded property and watching the lake views unfold. We would definitely return!!

Very comfortable. It shows that you get breakfast but I think that is for the bed and breakfast price. Our price was excellent for what we received.

Staying at Sally’s rentals has become a family tradition for us. She is an excellent host who has provided us with kindness, flexibility, and extremely quick responses when anything has come up. Her properties are well-stocked, offering the comforts of home and so much more. We come back every year because we’ve had such positive experiences. It truly feels like a home away from home for us!

We had a great time at the Lodge. Big beautiful plot of land the lodge sits on. The fire pit and pre cut wood made the evenings outside very enjoyable. We will be back!

Absolutely amazing place. Clean, comfy, on the water. parking, spacious. fire pit. unbelievable local town with amazing people. awesome local restaurants. HIGHLY recommend this listing.

What a gem! Short walk to a beautiful beach and lots of space for the whole family. Cottage was squeaky clean and full of everything you could possibly need (new appliances, beach toys, etc).

Ray and Patty were accessible even though we had no issues or need to contact them. The little treats and breakfast items were a nice touch. We would stay there again.

Exceeded our expectations. Perfect get away for us and our dog.

The house was very welcoming and cozy. Very quiet area and the neighbors were really nice as well! Very safe area and very clean.

Lovely little cottage, fit our needs perfectly. Clean, clear instructions for use, easy to find, and private.

This little cottage was adorable! It’s within 15-20 minutes of Erie. We went to splash lagoon, the mall and to the kids museum. There’s an AWESOME playground within walking distance of the cottage. Several great restaurants/diners within a mile of the cottage. Host was very accommodating and responsive. Overall the place is a gem! We will definitely be staying again.

Beth's place is exactly like the description and photos. Our family had a great stay (grandparents, infant and small dog). Long Point Park was within walking distance. Even though you're surrounded by other cottages - it is very private - you don't notice the neighbours. It gets VERY quiet at night so the campfire is so peaceful. We made our own meals so the kitchen/BBQ grill/firepit are very accommodating for our group. All cookware and utensiIs available. I really liked the screened in gazebo since we could eat outside and avoid the bugs (and rain!). Beth is very responsive if you have any questions or concerns. 5/5 great place and I would definitely stay here again :)

The Sunrise Inn provided a cozy and comfortable stay where great memories were made. Due to the weather, we unfortunately did not get to make a bonfire or enjoy the beautiful front porch with views of the lake, but we did see a rainbow over the lake! The kitchen and bathroom were spotless, and the kitchen was well equipped for cooking / entertaining. We made breakfast at the cottage and enjoyed eating at the local restaurants (The Anchor, Frog Pond, and Happi Jax). Valerie was a very friendly and responsive host, and we would definitely recommend her place to future guests visiting the lake!

Kurt has a cute house! He was also very responsive. Would recommend!

Great place and beautiful view.

Their little pocket of Conneaut is perfect. It’s so private and yet close to pier, beach, paths, etc better than we actually walked around and saw all the other rental properties and this one’s space and location are the tops!

This was a great stay! It was very relaxing with absolutely beautiful views. Excellent location, responsive host, and great amenities.

It was a great house. Plenty of room and everything you need. Great location and close to the lake. Beds were very comfortable. Lots of things to keep your kids occupied, if you have them here. We were very pleased with our stay.

The stay at David's cottage was perfect! our focus was fishing, so we did not spend a lot of time at the cottage besides sleeping and meals. David was helpful in getting us parked, supplying amenities for our boats and getting us situated. Overall, very satisfied with our experience and would absolutely stay again!