Holiday rentals with lake access in Lake Montauk

This was a fabulous destination! We were looking for a big place to have a special anniversary party weekend with extended family, and this house had everything we needed. Plenty of bedrooms upstairs and first floor, many common gathering areas, large kitchen and dining room tables, and lots of Space. (And this doesn't even include the explorable property outside.) The dozens of photos in the listing were very helpful, as well as the detailed descriptions. We had specific needs for elderly relatives with disabilities, and owner Lynne was so responsive in her replies to my many messages with varied questions. Truly, Lynne, you deserve a gold star from Airbnb for promptness and offering up ways and help that made our stay both easier and fulfilling.

We had a wonderful stay at Bonney’s home. The house is peaceful and private and just what we were looking for. Bonney was very responsive and made sure we had everything we needed for a great stay. We can’t wait to come back in the future.

Sean was a great host! The home is perfect for a getaway!

We've stayed at Mae's lovely house several times, in many different seasons, and once again it did not disappoint. Excellent fireplace, comfortable furnishings, nicely equipped kitchen, stylish bathroom. And the gorgeous view of the pond and its abundant birdlife is always a treat. We can't wait for our next visit!

Darren's place is great! Beautiful location, with amazing sunset views. Interior is so nice and bright. We had a lovely stay.

This place was a great stay! spotless just like the pictures, a beautiful view where we got the chance to see a wonderful sunset! Instructions were clear and my family had a great time!

Beautiful house, great location. Walkable to the beach. Ume was very responsive and proactive in reaching out with instructions and recommendations. The welcome gift was a really nice touch. Would look to book again!

We really enjoyed our stay at Jake's place on the salt pond! The location is wonderful and close to everything-beaches, restaurants, grocery store etc. The house is tiny but felt spacious enough for all 5 of us to have our own space. The newly finished lower level was a bonus. The view was so serene and a nice reprieve after busy days at the beach.

We had an amazing stay! Beautiful condo the decor is spotless & the outdoor deck is a huge bonus. Watching the sunset or having coffee in the morning really lade the stay even more relaxing. I cant wait to go back. :)

Kevin is a great Host - very responsible and accountable. We fully enjoyed staying his place. He was always willing to help while needed. The AirBnB is clean and has full of required amenities. We left some stuffs while checking out, he communicated quickly and shipped it out very fast. I highly recommend to stay at his place at East Lyme, CT.

This was our 2nd stay at Andrea’s place. Very peaceful and convenient location for our visits to Connecticut. We come to visit family but the small river towns like Deep River offer much to do and excellent restaurants to boot. We highly recommend Andreas property!

Margie’s place is an amazing hidden gem. The inside is very clean and comfortable. The outside is an experience of its own. The lake will drop your blood pressure immediately. Gorgeous surroundings. The dogs are friendly and lovable. We will be back! 👍🏼

A very accurate listing with a super helpful host. This was our first time using Air BnB and I was a little nervous. Everything was beyond my expectations! Listing was exactly as pictured and described. Host was very explicit with self-check in instructions, guest instructions, etc. We are very familiar with the area but never stayed in Matunuck before. Beautiful and very chill vibes! Thank you so much!

We had a very enjoyable time in the apartment. Everything was as described. Would come back without hesitation.

This might be the best place to stay in Montauk...so many things to walk to and you wake up right next to the water it's perfect. Westlake Marina is perfect if you want the real Montauk experience you can go fishing and a lot of other activities. The room feels brand new and really nicely done they even have heated floors! 10/10 would return

I can’t say enough about Vicky and Rick‘s place. Not only is it the cutest little cottage on the water, but it is in a great location and a perfect little neighborhood. The house has all the amenities needed. All instructions for everything were very laid out. It was clean and modern, but with a vintage feel. The bedroom is amazing with all around windows and a great view of the water. I would definitely come back here again perhaps in the fall or summer. Highly recommended!

This is a very well equipped house with 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms all on one level - something hard to find. Dana was exceptionally professional and responsive. The neighborhood is super quiet and only a few blocks walk to the small beach on the Narrow River. We kayaked almost daily! The local RI beaches are spectacular and the biking is also great. The house and environs met all our expectations. We highly recommend this property and Dana and hope to return again!

The place was perfect for us as a weekend getaway: at such peaceful and secluded location, you can really unplug and feel the warmth of the sun and wind from the ocean. Elizabeth was a super responsible and supportive host. Make sure to book if you are looking for a nice vacation at the beach!

Our stay could not have been better. Was the perfect place to stay to run the Newport marathon and we really enjoyed the cozy feel of the place. Everything was so clean and the yard was a great bonus in nice spring weather. Could not have asked for a better or more thoughtful host!

We lived our stay at Carey’s place and plan to come back next year. Amazing location if you want to relax and take a few days away from the city. The house is very cozy and comfortable with a great backyard facing the water. Thanks Carey!!

Deb’s place was very peaceful, comfortable, and well appointed. We immediately felt at home and enjoyed the interesting decor and personal style. It felt like staying in your own bed and breakfast. There were so many places to relax, and the front and back porches were so welcoming. The location can’t be beat if you want to check out the local wineries, farmstands, and great restaurants. An easy walk across the street to Peconic Bay, you can see from the upstairs bedroom. Kitchen was well appointed with everything you would need for cooking. Short ride to markets, farmstands, and Love Lane for shops and restaurants, about 20 minutes to Greenport.

Great little bungalow in a wonderful location. We stayed in January but I imagine it to be a bustling little community in the summer season! We can’t wait to checking it out then! The space is very clean with all that is needed for a comfortable stay. Kathy was very kind and communicated extremely well prior to and during our stay. Highly recommend staying here!

I had the pleasure of staying at this charming cottage nestled in a private property, and it was an absolute delight from start to finish. The host went above and beyond to ensure my comfort, offering warm hospitality that made me feel truly welcomed. The cottage itself was exactly as depicted in the photos—cozy, clean, and full of character. Nestled in a serene setting, it provided the perfect backdrop for a relaxing getaway from the city. Every detail, from the tasteful decor to the well-maintained amenities, contributed to a peaceful and rejuvenating stay. I highly recommend this lovely little cottage to anyone seeking a tranquil escape with a host who genuinely cares about their guests' experience.