Holiday houses in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
Dome in Beulah
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

WYnDome located in Beulah, WY

Welcome to WYnDome! The first Air BNB dome in Northeastern WY! Right at the entrance of the Black Hills! Secluded, but 15 minutes from the nearest town of Spearfish, SD. The entire place comes with heating/cooling, mini fridge, tv, full bathroom, microwave, Keurig iced and hot coffee maker, water bottles provided, hotel amenities, etc. (On nights the Buffalo Jump is open - you get a coupon to eat there as well. We also have mini highland cows and Nigerian dwarf goats roaming the property!

Top Guest favourite
Tower in Rapid City
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

Allard Tower

Perched dramatically on the edge of a quartzite cliff and surrounded by towering pines, this two-story rustic tower offers an unforgettable Black Hills escape. With panoramic views stretching across the forest and mountains, it’s the perfect hideaway for those seeking solitude, romance, and a deep connection with nature. Inside, you’ll find everything you need for a comfortable stay. The tower features 1 bedroom, 1 and 1/2 bathroom, and a fully equipped kitchenette—all styled with a warm touch.

Top Guest favourite
A charming red house is surrounded by lush green grass and tall trees, with a sloped hill rising in the background. A small deck with white chairs is visible at the front, offering a welcoming outdoor space.
Cabin in Hill City
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Grandma's House in the Heart of the Black Hills

Grandma's House is in the heart of the Black Hills, located 1 mile from Hill City, it is minutes away from Mt. Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park and more. It sits alone on the edge of a meadow with hills directly behind it and a small, bubbly creek in front of the house. It has plenty of room for kids to run and play outside, and a cozy, quaint inside for families to enjoy each other's company. Grandma’s House is available for extended stays November thru April. Contact host for details

Guest favourite
Cabin in Custer
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 206 reviews

Nature Stay with Views Like No Where Else

This home is truly one-of-a-kind and straight out of a magazine! Beautifully modern and furnished to an exceptional standard. Open the windows and let the soothing sounds of the nearby creek transport you to your own private paradise. Located close to Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, Custer State Park, and many other top attractions, you’re also just under 5 minutes from Hill City. We truly believe this is the ultimate spot to fully experience the breathtaking beauty of the Black Hills.

Top Guest favourite
A cozy sunroom bedroom features a king size bed adorned with a floral quilt, light streaming in through multiple windows. Decorative wall hangings complement the natural wood ceiling, while a bedside table with lamps offers functionality. Plants in the foreground create a touch of greenery.
Apartment in Keystone
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

The Sage - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Sage is part of Hinterwood Inn and Cabins and sleeps up to 4 people. It has one bedroom with a king bed, a daybed/trundle (two twin mattresses) in the living room. It has a full kitchen with a gas stove, refrigerator, microwave, a regular coffee pot, dishes, utensils, and pots and pans. It includes one full, spacious bathroom with a shower (no tub). It's approximately 500 sq. feet. Enjoy the private fire pit area, the gas grill outside, and the expansive outdoor spaces on the property.

Top Guest favourite
A panoramic view reveals a verdant canyon surrounded by towering pine trees. Jagged rock formations line the cliffs, with splashes of green foliage contrasting against the earthy tones. The sky, filled with soft clouds, adds a serene backdrop to this natural landscape.
Apartment in Hermosa
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

Peaceful Canyon Retreat | Luxe Apt + Wildlife

Enjoy the perfect summer escape—warm days, open skies, and peaceful canyon views. Just 11 miles from the historic Game Lodge and the start of the famous Wildlife Loop. Nestled beside the stunning Box Canyon, our newly built 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom apartment offers a quiet retreat in one of the most breathtaking corners of the Black Hills. Spend your days exploring scenic drives, iconic landmarks, and endless trails, then return to unwind, and take in the natural beauty that surrounds you.

Guest favourite
Home in Rapid City
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Castle in the Sky

Are you looking for a luxurious, unique place to stay? This house sits overlooking Rapid City with incredible skyline views, every evening is as picture perfect as the glowing city lights. This unique house is a fun mix of eclectic and fancy. Originally built as a local builder's "Coup de Grande", he ended up only finishing the guest house. You will find high-end finishes mixed with eclectic choices. We promise this will be one of the most memorable places you'll ever stay!

Top Guest favourite
The lodge is surrounded by tall pines, showcasing a modern structure with a sloped roof. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance, highlighting the expansive natural landscape of forested hills and distant mountains under a soft twilight sky.
Cabin in Lead
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 85 reviews

Luxury Escape w/Hot Tub, Firepit and Barrel Sauna

"We loved our stay here so much that we contemplated not even leaving because the lodge was so comfortable. It was snowy and the wood burning fireplace and latte machine was like a little piece of heaven!!" ~Kelle Welcome to "Six Pines Lodge" An exquisite retreat nestled in the breathtaking beauty of Lead, South Dakota. This 2-bedroom mountain sanctuary offers a stunning blend of luxury and tranquility, making it a premier choice for travelers seeking a memorable escape.

Top Guest favourite
A charming cabin is surrounded by greenery and blooming flowers. Climbing vines adorn the exterior, while a striped awning adds a pop of color. A small sitting area is visible next to the cabin, featuring a blue lounge chair on a grassy lawn.
Cabin in Keystone
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Cozy, private cabin 5

Small cabin, 2 miles from Mt.Rushmore and walking distance to Keystone, SD shops. Just a queen bed, AC, refrigerator, shower and deck overlooking Battle Creek, 30 feet below. Scenic views of surrounding forest hilltops and canyon. We also have another hill top cabin #4 if this cabin isn't available or if you'd like to book both for a party of 4, just click on our host (Diane's) photo to see both cabin listings. Seasonal openings. June 1- Oct. 11. Not open winter months.

Top Guest favourite
A modern tiny house features warm wooden siding and a sleek black exterior. A spacious wrap-around deck showcases seating and soft lighting. The surrounding landscape includes distant rock formations under a cloudy sky, providing a serene atmosphere for relaxation.
Tiny home in Custer
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Rustic Modern Tiny House Next To Custer State Park

Enjoy this modern Tiny House, located just 5 minutes to Custer State Park. Experience unique views of rock formations while you drink your morning coffee. You will have access to the entire house, all to yourself. Great area to hike, bike, see the fluffy buffalo. Just a two minute drive to downtown Custer. This area has great ATV, trail ride and kayak rentals near by! Feel refreshed when you stay in this rustic gem.

Top Guest favourite
A modern tiny cabin features reflective walls, blending into the surrounding nature. Tall trees and a blue sky are mirrored on the surface, creating a seamless connection with the forest. The cabin's structure is set among rocky terrain, emphasizing its unique design.
Tiny home in Lead
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

Mirror Cabin in the Black Hills

You'll love this unique and romantic escape. This tiny mirror cabin, REFLECT+RECONNECT, is nestled in the serene beauty of the Black Hills of South Dakota. It creates a rejuvenating and memorable experience. This unique retreat is designed to offer you a chance to disconnect from the hustle and bustle of everyday life and reconnect with the special person in your life, yourself, and the surrounding nature.

Guest favourite
A private hot tub is situated on a covered patio, surrounded by lush greenery. The calming waters reflect the natural light filtering through the canopy of trees. Nearby, a wooden bench and a swing add to the serene outdoor setting.
Cabin in Custer
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

Tenderfoot Creek Retreat

Welcome to Tenderfoot Creek Retreat! You will find yourself surrounded by towering evergreens of the Black Hills National Forest, and steps from the Mickelson Trail. You will occupy the entire main or 2nd floor of this rustic residence. Close to all the major Black Hills attractions yet you will feel at one with nature. Tenderfoot Creek can lull you to sleep or greet the morning with its soothing chatter.

Popular amenities for Horse Thief Lake holiday rentals