Holiday houses in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top Guest favourite
A cabin is showcased, featuring a green metal roof and large windows. A stone patio with a pergola is visible nearby, surrounded by lush trees. Grass covers the area, creating a natural setting.
Cabin in Lead
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

The Ranger Cabin - Luxury Off-Grid

This cabin is rich with history as it is the original National Forest Ranger Outpost dating back to the late 1800’s. It is the perfect starting point for all your outdoor adventures with immediate access to ATV/snowmobile/hiking/mountain bike trails, endless gravel biking, hunting, and more. A perfect winter getaway, one of the heaviest snowfall areas in the hills. This property is so deep in the National Forest, it is solar powered. However, that does not mean rustic! Lots of parking too.

Top Guest favourite
A vibrant red barn contrasts with lush green trees and a clear sky, with a colorful rainbow arching above. An inviting hammock is shown in a tranquil setting, while a glimpse of the home's exterior reveals a charming farmhouse next to scenic hills.
Farm stay in Nemo
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Restored Nemo Farmhouse on Centennial Trail W WiFi

Bring your ATV'S! Plenty of parking. On the Centennial Trail system. Fast wifi, smart TV with Dish channels. We are about 20 minutes from Sturgis, half an hour from Deadwood, and 40 minutes from Rapid City. The nighttime sky is very dark for viewing all the constellations; we have solar lights around the house, but it can be dark without a flashlight. Please keep in mind we are in the forest, and there are bugs, flying insects, and small critters. We work very hard to keep them out of the house!

Top Guest favourite
A charming red house is surrounded by lush green grass and tall trees, with a sloped hill rising in the background. A small deck with white chairs is visible at the front, offering a welcoming outdoor space.
Cabin in Hill City
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Grandma's House in the Heart of the Black Hills

Grandma's House is in the heart of the Black Hills, located 1 mile from Hill City, it is minutes away from Mt. Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park and more. It sits alone on the edge of a meadow with hills directly behind it and a small, bubbly creek in front of the house. It has plenty of room for kids to run and play outside, and a cozy, quaint inside for families to enjoy each other's company. Grandma’s House is available for extended stays November thru April. Contact host for details

Guest favourite
An inviting interior showcases a spacious living area with wood accents. A serene view of two bedrooms is visible in the background, featuring cozy queen beds. A rustic charm is highlighted by the wooden beam accent wall and decor, enhancing the cabin's welcoming atmosphere.
Cabin in Keystone
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

The Notch Cabin - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Notch Cabin is part of Hinterwood Inn & Cabins, situated 60 ft. from National Forest. Enjoy hiking and wildlife sightings from your front door! The cabin has 2 bedrooms, each with a queen bed, a queen murphy bed in the living room, a bathroom with a shower (no tub), and an apartment size kitchen w/ essentials. Custom built by the owners, enjoy the beautiful wooden accent wall, pine slab table, and vaulted ceilings. Includes a private deck with a gas grill, private fire pit area, and more!

Top Guest favourite
The cabin's exterior features warm wooden siding and a covered porch with seating. A picnic table and grill are located nearby, set against a natural landscape of pine trees. A gravel pathway leads to the road and surrounding forest, enhancing the peaceful setting.
Cabin in Custer
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Shirttail Canyon Cabins -Cabin 3

Welcome to Shirttail Canyon Cabins! This lovely cabin is ready for you to come and enjoy a peaceful hillside getaway in the beautiful Black Hills of South Dakota. It’s located back in the canyon with wildlife and beautiful views bordering National Forest Service Land. Bring the the whole family and experience Custer State Park, Mt Rushmore, Mickelson Trail, Wind and Jewel Caves, Crazy Horse and more just minutes away! We also have more cabins nearby, great for smaller reunions or retreats!

Top Guest favourite
The bungalow features a spacious wooden deck with a rail, furnished with four outdoor chairs and a table. Large windows showcase the stone and wood exterior, while the warm lighting highlights the architectural details against the backdrop of trees.
Home in Custer
5 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Beautiful Bungalow Next to Custer State Park

Enjoy this newly built 2023 modern Beautiful Bungalow, located just 5 minutes to Custer State Park. Experience unique views of rock formations while you drink your morning coffee. You will have access to the entire house, all to yourself. Great area to hike, bike, see the fluffy buffalo. Just a two minute drive to downtown Custer. This area has great ATV, trail ride and kayak rentals near by! Feel refreshed when you stay in style and comfort with amazing accommodations.

Top Guest favourite
A charming front porch features a welcoming staircase leading to a red door. Floral decorations hang from the railing, enhancing the entrance's appeal. Comfortable seating is visible on the porch, framed by a well-maintained green lawn and decorative outdoor lighting.
Apartment in Deadwood
5 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Newly remodeled in the Heart of Deadwood

This newly remodeled, comfortable apartment is right in the heart of Deadwood! This home, built in the early 1900's is on Deadwood's Historical Registery, and is located on famous Main Street just a couple blocks from the action. It is a one bedroom apartment with one bath and a full kitchen. Laundry facilities are available. You'll love coming back to this cozy space with all the comforts of home, after enjoying all Deadwood and the Black Hills has to offer!

Guest favourite
The kitchen and dining area feature wood accents and cozy seating. A round table is paired with four chairs, and a well-equipped kitchen counter is visible. Decorative items and a sign welcoming guests to the farm add charm to the space.
Cabin in Custer
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Farmhouse Cabin in the Black Hills (Cabin 2)

Enjoy a farmhouse cabin on 120 acres. Experience the best of the Black Hills from your massive front porch. Add a farm tour to your experience if you want to interact with farm staff and animals. Enjoy Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Jewel Cave, and hundreds of other attractions only a few miles from your door. Cabin 2 Sleeps 7 1 Private Bedroom (Queen Bed) 1 Loft Bedroom (2 Twin Beds +1 Partial Trundle {kids only}) 1 Foldout Couch (Queen Bed)

Guest favourite
The exterior features a newly remodeled wooden facade with a welcoming entrance. A set of steps leads to a deck with a simple railing, providing access to large windows that illuminate the interior.
Guest suite in Rapid City
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Modern Luxury | 2BR/1BA | Minutes from Downtown

Experience upscale comfort in this newly remodeled, 2 King Bedroom, modern-luxury unit—just minutes from downtown. Enjoy a private entrance, serene deck with wildlife views, full gourmet kitchen, spa-style walk-in shower, washer/dryer, and high-speed Wi-Fi. Peaceful, quiet, and close to top tourist spots. Note: Steps required for access. This is a secondary unit. The property is split into two units, with this unit being on the upper level.

Guest favourite
A cozy sleeping area features a king bed with a textured blue coverlet, surrounded by warm wooden paneling. A kitchenette with essential appliances can be seen in the background, alongside a wall-mounted TV and two windows covered by dark curtains.
Cabin in Rapid City
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Pine Haven King Bed Log Cabin

Relax & unwind in the center of the Black Hills in this cozy log cabin at Pine Haven Venue & Lodging. Located 10 minutes from Rapid City & 10 minutes from Mount Rushmore. Features include: King bed Kid's loft has full size mattress ( pillows and bedding can be requested at front office) Full bathroom with standup shower Kitchenette (sink, refrigerator, hot plate, toaster, coffee maker, utensils) Smart TV Must 18+ years old took book

Top Guest favourite
The exterior of a handmade strawbale cottage is shown, featuring a wooden facade with large windows. Solar panels are visible on the roof. A spacious driveway leads to a covered parking area, framed by greenery and landscape elements, creating an inviting entrance.
Cottage in Spearfish
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 262 reviews

Off-Grid Cottage at Granny Flats

Welcome! Cappie, Star of Building Outside the Lines on Magnolia Network, built this adorable off-grid cottage as his own, but now you have the opportunity to stay! This beautiful 3-acre property, once the Swisher Farm, is today a working homestead, dozens of chickens, and a large garden. This cottage is handmade, from the bespoke front door to the custom 2-headed shower. We know you'll appreciate the details!

Superhost
Apartment in Hill City
4.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Black Hills Luxury Loft 6

Located right downtown Hill City at McGregor & Main | Luxury Lofts, this luxury loft is above With the Wind Winery's NEW tasting room and is within steps of inspired restaurants, boutique shops, art galleries, shopping, biking, breweries and much, much more! **Our luxury lofts are strictly an animal-free zone, including service animals, due to the owners severe allergies.**

Popular amenities for Horse Thief Lake holiday rentals