Holiday rentals with a fireplace in Whitefish Bay

Find and book unique fireplace rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated Accommodation with Fireplace in Whitefish Bay

Guests agree: these holiday homes with a fireplace are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top Guest favourite

Guesthouse in Richfield

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews

Peaceful weekend or extended stay, full amenities

The Country Retreat at the historic Schmitz Family Farm is close to many attractions, ideal for couples, families, girls' weekends, extended stays, business travel, and is dog friendly. Enjoy a sunrise or sunset, get cozy at the fireplace, or indulge in the many activities our area has to offer. We feature two beautiful bedrooms, living room with two sleeper sofas (can also be used as a third bedroom, as door closes for privacy), laundry room, full kitchen, coffee nook, quiet deck and backyard.

Top Guest favourite

Home in Thiensville

5 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Charming retreat-like 3BR in desirable northshore

Charming retreat-like 3BR in desirable northshore community walkable to coffee shops, restaurants, parks & the riverwalk…or a quick 23 minute ride to the front of the Fiserv Forum in downtown Milwaukee! Great for the weekend getaway, business trip or extended vacation. WIFI, well appointed kitchen, 2.5 bath, gas FP & front porch rocking chairs to watch the parade of dog walkers. Walk to (excellent) authentic Himalayan food at the Cheel or a glass of wine at Glaze while painting a new coffee mug!

Top Guest favourite

Barn in Cedarburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Big Red Barn with a basketball court

A beautifully transformed dairybarn turned into a rustic Lodge with all the accommodations. Enjoy a full kitchen and bar filled with a gas fireplace, dart board and pool table. Head upstairs to the basketball court and onto a wraparound deck that over looks acres of wetlands with wildlife A birdwatchers paradise. If you need to detox we have a wood-burning sauna with all the wood and kindling for you to enjoy. We are located 2miles outside historic Cedarburg Wi and 25 minutes north of Milwaukee.

Guest favourite

Farm stay in Germantown

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

Lace & Woods Farm "Hammer Hideaway"

HEATED POOL MAY-SEPT FOR ADDITIONAL CHRG. Cozy designer custom built guest house nestled amongst a 10 acre hobby farm. come for a relaxing getaway. This home is an artistic gem! Boasting an open concept, with a queen bed on main level and twin mattress underneath , a full kitchen, cozy living area, wood burning fireplace. The loft has extra sleeping with a double bed and twin bed.Custom designed. Great location winter and summer, enjoy snowmobiling trails and skiing near by or beaches & hiking

Guest favourite

Apartment in Bay View

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 324 reviews

Bay View MKE Hideaway - with Parking!

Cozy, inviting, one bedroom apartment in the heart of Bayview, literally steps away from some of Milwaukee's best restaurants, bars and shops! One of two Airbnb guest spaces in our house, this downstairs apartment is our home base when we're in Milwaukee, and we love sharing it with guests when we’re on the road! We are within five minutes of Summerfest grounds and East Side & Historic Third Ward districts, and within 10 minutes of the airport, downtown, Marquette University, and Miller Park.

Top Guest favourite

Home in Bay View

5 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Gorgeous Bayview 2Story Loft w/Upper Deck/Firebowl

Located right on South Shore Park with views of Lake Michigan. Just a 3 minute walk to South Shore Beach and the Oak Leaf Trail, and just a 6 minute drive to downtown Milwaukee. This two story treetop loft occupies the upper two levels of a large historic house and has a large 400 sqft 2nd story deck overlooking the park and lake with a 4' natural gas fire bowl. Also features indoor bioethanol fireplace and full bar with a wine-chiller. The perfect place to kick back and relax with friends!

Guest favourite

Condo in Lower East Side

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Private East Side Milwaukee flat with fenced yard

Enjoy the best that the East Side and downtown have to offer in this second floor standalone home on the Oak Leaf Trail with no shared walls, private fenced-in yard with spacious deck and patio, and private parking lot. This historic cream city brick building was constructed in 1897 and completely renovated in 2017 with custom features throughout. Gas fireplace, 70" TV in living room with custom hi-fi built-in stereo system, tons of natural light. Double guest suites with amenities galore.

Top Guest favourite

Home in Mequon

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Historic cottage with fireplace. Pets Welcome!

Step back in time and immerse yourself in the charm of our historic 3-bedroom cottage, part of the renowned Jahn Farmstead, proudly listed on the National Register of Historic Places. Built in the mid-19th century, this Greek Revival-style farmhouse offers a unique blend of historical elegance and modern comfort, ensuring a relaxing and memorable stay. Located 2 miles from the Mequon Public Market and 5 miles from Cedarburg. Pets are welcome and we have acres of land for you to explore!

Guest favourite

Home in Wauwatosa

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Spacious Wauwatosa Home In Prime Location

We just finished remodeling the kitchen and all 3 bathrooms in our unique tri-level mid-century modern home. There are 4 bedrooms offering an array of accommodations as well as a couch with a pull-out queen bed. If you like to cook, our new kitchen is amazing! There is a fireplace room with a lovely view outside, a laundry room and a TV with cable, a DVR, and streaming apps like Netflix. WIFI is available. This is a quiet family neighborhood. No parties and please be respectful.

Guest favourite

Home in Wauwatosa

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Relax close to everything in Milwaukee

Ranch Style home in a quiet Neighborhood. You will feel at home and comfortable! The home is well maintained and very clean. In the winters you could cozy up to a nice fire upstairs and relax with a glass of wine. Downstairs is a second fireplace you have going and play a game of pool. In The summer you can enjoy the three seasons room, with looking a cup of coffee and look at the planted flower garden. Close to the Wauwatosa village down town. Even closer to Elm Grove Village.

Top Guest favourite

Home in Bay View

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Sunny Retreat | Huge 6BR w/ Patio + Balcony

Find peace in this spacious, family-friendly home near Lake Michigan, Downtown Milwaukee, Walkers Point, and Oak Creek. 🏡 Enjoy fast Wi-Fi, Aquasana water filtration, central A/C, high ceilings with fans, free laundry 🧺, a fenced patio with fire pit 🔥, covered balcony, and secure 2-car garage 🚗. With easy access to highways, parks, cafés, and entertainment, it’s perfect for families, wedding groups, and business travelers. ✨

Top Guest favourite

Condo in Milwaukee

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 269 reviews

Downtown MKE Vibes • Roomy Stay + Cool Perks

Escape to our cozy, spacious retreat in the heart of Downtown Milwaukee. Located on vibrant Old World Third Street, you’re steps from bars, restaurants, and historic charm. Enjoy plush bedding, a full kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, and stylish decor. We also offer exclusive add-ons—like curated food & drink packages or celebration setups—to make your stay extra special. Let us know how we can help create a 5-star experience!