Villa holiday rentals in Wemyss Settlement

No Plans was just incredible! The hosts were amazing and followed up with us very quickly with any questions we had. The home was beautiful and very private with a lovely front beach and palm trees. Everything you could ask for was in the home and the decor was very beachy and relaxing. The sunsets from the screened porches were straight out of a movie stunning. They provided linens and towels, bath & beach and had every appliance or kitchen need you could think of. The furniture was comfortable and clean. The beds felt like clouds! lol I even asked for the name of the mattresses! We hope to return to No Plans many times in the future. If you’re looking for water front, private beach, boat mooring, all the comforts of home, this is the place! Thank you so much for allowing us to have the privilege of staying in your Long Island home! A+++++, 5 Stars

Robin is super helpful and the place was perfect for our stay. The views are amazing. The snorkeling is challenging with some of the tides out front, but if you time it right, well worth the effort! Would definitely stay here again.

Our stay at this home and Stella Maris exceeded all expectations! The accommodations were even better than imagined, and the staff were incredibly friendly and beyond helpful. If you can make the journey, this is a place you won't want to miss out on. It's certain to recharge your batteries and leave you and your family with lasting memories. Our boys will never forget their days and nights in our private pool and your lovely property -- and the evening walks to Moonshine for a strawberry daquiri and to explore the natural tide and all of its creatures. Thank you, Jill, for an unforgettable experience at the most beautiful place on Long Island! 🌴✨

We had a great stay at RH Pool House! The living area and bedrooms were spacious, the view was beautiful, and it was conveniently located to Stella Maris Resort and all their amenities. It was extremely clean and had everything we needed, including a cooler to use. Bruno was incredibly friendly and helpful and we appreciated him checking in on us and going above and beyond to help when we had trouble connecting to the Internet the first day. The pool was a nice bonus at the end of the day. We would definitely stay again!

Absolutely loved it! The screened in porch and the views from the deck were amazing. Robin and Mike were excellent hosts and recommended several places to eat and stuff to do around the island. We can’t wait to come back!

The Harbor Breeze Villas are beautiful! All situated on a hill one after another but yet it feels so private. The walk down the beach is on a nicely lit path. Theres chairs, umbrellas, kayaks and paddle boards all for use. Our issue was no response from the host. No instructions on how to check in or where. We eventually were able had to find other guests and ask them how to check in. There’s a separate building down the road called Great Harbor Club House, no signs for it until you drive down the street and unclear on google maps that they were even associated. Check in was easy once we found it. There was a small shop, restaurant and amazing pool all situated there. We would definitely stay there again!

Great Location, the beach is walking distance, host was amazing, place was extremely clean! I will definitely stay here again!!