Cabin holiday rentals in Story

We had a great time and the house was wonderful! The house has everything you need to cook and we enjoyed dinner at the cabin most nights. The house is only a few minutes to multiple restaurants and shops! The house was large and more than enough space for our family! The kids loved the creek and mom and dad enjoyed the hot tub!

Samuel was very responsive, gave us an early check-in, and great recommendations for places to eat. Kids enjoyed the hot tub, we enjoyed the fire pit and watching all of the wildlife. Sheets were super soft, and there was an abundance of towels!! Kitchen was fully stocked. My only complaint, if any, was having to walk through the bathroom to get to the bedrooms. Makes it harder to get through the house, but a minor inconvenience to enjoy the property. Thanks for the stay!!

Amazing stay! The cabin was clean and amenities were exactly as described. Great location and we would love to stay again!

We had the most incredible weekend at Garrett & Ewa’s place! They communicated so well with us before hand when planning my sister’s wedding celebration! Everyone loved the space. It was all as pictured and even better than expected!

We were looking for a place last minute for my mom and I to stay while we attended my uncle's funeral. we did not have any idea what nashville was we just saw it was close to columbus and had a hot tub. let me just tell you how amazing Angela and her cabin was.... we booked at 10:30 pm the night before. I know, I know. like ordering a well done Ribeye 5 minutes before close. Angela took it upon herself to make sure the house was clean despite thinking she had no renters for a few days and the last guest checking out that morning. the cabin was so cozy and peaceful. in such a stressful and emotional time it was our calming place. mom absolutely loved sitting on the porch listening to the creek. Angela was so amazing would definitely stay there again. and probably will. thanks Angela for going above and beyond in a high stress moment.

Allison was super responsive and helpful. The cabin and property are beautiful!

There was 8 men from 62 to 75. Played golf all week, cooked at the cabin. Very private, comfortable, beautiful. We all loved this Airbnb. One of our best stays from FL to TN and back to Indiana. We've stayed in several Airbnb we loved this one. Thank you, Apolonia,

Melissa was a great host. We had to cancel our trip on short notice and then rebooked on even shorter notice. She was very understanding and helpful. The house is very cute and quiet with a lot of space indoors and out. We didn't get the chance to use the fire pit or the hot tub (maybe next time).The living room furniture and the beds and pillows were very comfortable. The kitchen table was perfect for eating and playing games. The kitchen appliances were top notch. The house feels remote but is not far from Nashville, IN and all it has to offer. Good pizza and beer at Bog Woods Pizza. Also check out the Farm House Cafe & Tea Room, just down the road, for great food and a nice nursery with a lot of plants. We'd definitely stay here again.

Super clean cabin. Host was very responsive. Wonderfully private and quiet setting. Kitchen was fully stocked with the cooking appliances we needed. We had our 16 month old grandson with us and really appreciated having a high chair, portacrib and baby gate on site so we didn’t have to haul those items. We wouldn’t hesitate to book this Airbnb again!

Beautiful cabin in the woods!!

We absolutely loved staying here! The cabin was so cozy and welcoming. It had everything we needed and more. The outdoor space is perfect! Waking up and enjoying our coffee under the new pergola was pure bliss! The birds singing created the most enchanting and relaxing atmosphere. It was the perfect way to start each day and truly unwind. Highly recommend taking advantage of this beautiful outdoor space! We couldn't have asked for a better place to call home during our trip. We would highly recommend this spot to anyone!

The property was absolutely beautiful! Came for a wedding that was close by and enjoyed a wonderful night around one of the two fire pits. Wish we had more time in the morning to explore more of the property. Our dog really enjoyed the expansive forest. Alexandra was amazing and super communicative with anything we could have needed. Can’t wait to come back!

Beautiful place to stay. Lots of activities to do. Me and some friends are planning on coming back!

Absolutely love the house. I loved the view from the top decks. The waterfalls is very nearby and beautiful. I love the fact that we was able to book this place and keep our dog with us. Thats what sold us on staying here and the fishing for the kids. Very big bass in the pond. Good pass time with the family. Unfortunately the general store wasn't open. The lady was sick that runs it. Very nice community. Jeff did great with communication. Especially when i stupidly locked myself out of the house. I did accidentally check in early after 24 hours of no sleep to get from NC to IN. He was very nice about it, and it was no problem. I knew the water did not smell good from previous reviews. So no complaints there. I was just greatful to get this place last minute so we could be close to the club to compete in the UKC TOC. Very blessed to stay here.

We love to stay at the cabin when we’re in Brown County. It’s peaceful and secluded while still close to Nashville and other sites. I super appreciate being able to take our little dogs, and we joke about the dogs thinking it’s our vacation house since they’ve been there enough times to feel comfortable right away.

Jonah's cabin was absolutely beautiful it was as promised. the cabin had a woodsy rustic feel to it while being buried in the woods and yet it had a touch of class with the walk-in steam shower. everything about the place is fantastic. the open concept kitchen-living space was a perfect family environment.

I received clear instructions that were helpful in finding the cabin and getting inside. We needed nothing after that, as the little cabin is well set up. It’s an adorable space, and even though it is nestled in between the YMCA and housing, it feels very private. It was warm and muggy during our stay, so we very much appreciated the dehumidifiers! Overall it was a very pleasant stay at the cabin while we visited family in Bloomington. Next time we’re in town, we want to rent the upstairs space just for a change of scenery!

Amanda’s home is a hidden gem! The cabin is spacious and meticulously kept, our experience exceeded our expectations in all categories. Amanda’s historic place has a rich and interesting history as does Brown County and the town of Nashville. Although close to Bloomington and Indianapolis, you feel transported to a faraway place with beautiful topography and woods. Highly recommend!

Tim and Shane were extremely nice, and very welcoming. Showed us all the animals, and made us feel at home and very welcome. Overall was a phenomenal experience and would recommend this, and them, to anyone trying to experience a great weekend! More then what I was hoping for! And greatly exceeded expectations!!

Another wonderful stay at the Goat Conspiracy. Beautiful, spacious cabin and private, peaceful surroundings. Private location where you wake up to the sounds of nature, with goats providing a special bonus. Cabin is spacious and clean - can't wait to stay again.

What great place to stay! Centrally located to so many cool destinations in Southern Indiana. The home is clean, beds are comfortable, and the setting is private. Kitchen fully equipped. Enjoyed the hot tub and listening to a huge variety of birds. We would highly recommend!

Peaceful, serene spot. Saw a deer just a few feet from the porch. Be aware no cell signal, but Wi-Fi is good and fast. Host is responsive to all inquiries, would recommend!

Three of my brothers and myself stayed at the cabin from Nov 7 - 10, we were in town to attend the Indiana vs Michigan football game. the cabin was as advertised and was a perfect match for us, we each had our own bedroom and private bathroom, the cabin is a couple miles off the beaten path, it was very quiet, secluded, the cabin was very clean, and we enjoyed our stay immensely. Our hosts Peter and Suzanne, answered our questions promptly and provided lots of information. would recommend the cabin

What a magic place to stay. We loved every moment and the wildlife made us feel right at home. The beds were comfy and helped us recover from our jetlag from our flight from Australia. Just perfect. Thanks for giving us ideas on things to do whilst in the area. This was much appreciated. One day, we hope to come back with the rest of the family.