Holiday rentals with beach access in Sterling Forest, Greenwood Lake

The view of the lake was amazing. She was very quick to respond if there was anything needed. I loved the recommendations that she sent over. We overall had a wonderful experience!

I would highly recommend this place, Tracy was very helpful. She gave us clear instructions. She had the place prepared for us. She even customized for us a card and guiding us to where everything is, the place was very clean, very well taken care of, and a lot of thoughts went into designing this place with all the amenities and comfortabilities

What a wonderful stay! Bee was so responsive and hospitable, and shared so much local information to make the best of my family trip. Bee’s home was truly a home away from home. It was stocked with all the essentials and more, and very spacious for my family of 5. Very clean, and had no issues at all. There was a grill and fire pit available for our use as well. The lake and beach were all very accessible as well, and Bee had plenty of beach passes available for us to use. All in all an unforgettable experience, a short summer trip my family will never forget. We will definitely come back!

What a great little studio for a Birthday get away trip to Bethel Woods concerts, etc. Relaxing on the deck overlooking the lake for coffee in the morning or a nightcap after your days activities. 2 restaurants within a 100 yards, the Tap n Table was excellent with really Friendly staff. Must have breakfast at least once at Bethel Market Cafe, the Best! All this less than 15 minutes in any direction. I would like to come back in the Summer to take advantage of the Lake activities. Wonderful stay!

Great location—perfect for me and my son, and comfortably fits 4–5 people. The AC is strong, the TVs are huge, and the home has a cozy, welcoming feel. If you're visiting your cadet and need a peaceful, comfortable place to relax afterward, this spot is ideal. A few tips for future guests: Toilet Paper: Only one roll was provided, so plan to bring or buy more during your stay. Not a big deal, but worth noting. Transportation: I tried to get a Lyft for over an hour with no success. One finally came from over 25 minutes away. Lyft and rideshare options are very limited in town, so if you can rent a car, definitely do so. First Aid Kit: I cut my finger on my luggage and couldn’t find any bandages in the unit. I recommend bringing a basic first aid kit just in case—always good to have on hand. Overall, a great, peaceful stay in a very convenient location. Would absolutely stay here again and recommend it to others!

Anthony's place was exactly as advertised, and it was clean and bright. The apartment was fully stocked with everything I needed, it was comfortable, and I felt completely safe there. I would rent it again should I need to stay in the Hawley area, and I would recommend the space to others.

Great hiking base, just short walk to trails. So convenient to main st, supermarket, restaurants etc but is a bit noisy due to the convenient location it’s a trade off- no driving required though which was great for us. Loved sauna and grill outside esp after long hike!

We are appreciative of a clean place to lay our heads. Cindy’s place is exactly as described. We didn’t use the kitchen, but it was stocked with pots, pans, spices, coffee, and tea. The bathroom was spotless and beautiful. The bed and pillows were very comfortable. The linens were clean and fragrant free. Cindy was proactive in helping us to check-in, and quickly responded to my texts. People live upstairs, so we did hear some activity, but it was not disruptive in any way. In mid-October, the weather was chilly, and so the room was chilly too. We needed the space heater that was provided. We were grateful for a great stay!

This place is an absolute gem. From the moment I arrived, I felt a deep sense of peace—it’s incredibly tranquil, surrounded by beautiful natural scenery, with a running stream just steps from the front door. The home itself strikes the perfect balance between rustic charm and modern comfort. Inside, the decor is thoughtful and unique: a nostalgic mix of vintage childhood sports photos, striking modern art, and beautiful antiques. It all blends together to create a space that feels both stylish and deeply personal. The fireplace is a centerpiece—warm, inviting, and stocked with enough firewood to last all summer. This isn’t just a house—it’s a welcoming home. You can feel the care and intention behind every detail. Located just 15 minutes from Bethel Woods, it’s the ideal escape from NYC. I can’t wait to return.

Spent a week in a cozy cabin tucked away in the woods, and it was exactly the reset I needed. Peaceful, quiet, and surrounded by nature—waking up to the sound of birds and falling asleep under the stars felt like a dream. The cabin itself was warm, clean, and had all the essentials. Whether we were sitting by the fire, going on nearby hikes, or just enjoying the view on the porch, every moment felt grounding. No traffic, no stress—just stillness. Highly recommend if you’re looking to disconnect and recharge. Can’t wait to go back.

We stayed up here for a weekend and it was very quiet and there is stream nearby which is lovely to listen to the water falling over rocks--so incredibly peaceful. The neighbors are very close and its right off the road but you're tucked away into a little cove so it feels more nature. Great natural light and lots of windows!

Amazing place to stay in. Very quiet with a lot of room for a large group of people. The game room is amazing.

Heather was very interactive with my stay and gives very clear instructions! The house is exactly as described and photoed! Fun activities to do at home and very clean! Plenty of space in the house with a great kitchen! Definitely would stay again and recommend to friends/family!

It was a beautiful stay and everything were just like the photos! We enjoyed our stayed!

The view of the lake, and the large covered porch were fantastic! Even on a rainy day we all enjoyed hanging out. The place was clean and spacious and the kitchen was well stocked. As other reviewers have mentioned, the many steep stairs to access the house are definitely a consideration before renting. They would be a real challenge if you had mobility issues. You have to unload/load your car at street level and use the stairs. But a lovely house for a large group!

We traveled to Nyack for a family wedding and this place was absolutely perfect for what we needed! Plenty of space, beautiful outdoor area overlooking the river, and located close to everything we needed. The rest of my family decided we had the best AirBnB for the wedding weekend! Mia was very responsive when we needed anything. Furthermore, my son left his kindle in the bedroom he slept in and Mia shipped it to us immediately after it was found. We will absolutely be booking here again.