Holiday rentals with a fire pit in Siesta Key

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Pool house by the bay

Come stay in our beautiful, Mid-Century Modern, light drenched home just one block from the bay with a private pool. The private yard is surrounded by lush landscaping & the pool is the perfect place to cool off on hot afternoons. The house is spacious & minimally decorated with finds from our world travels. We've recently replaced the bed and the neighborhood is quiet and easy to explore on foot. Note: this is our home, so please expect a warm lived in feel in the space, not that of a hotel.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 506 reviews

The Cottage At Central Park

There is no more charming place to stay! From the minute you step inside this immaculate and cozy private residence you will feel right at home. With a beautiful open kitchen, natural light that pours into every room, a spacious back porch overlooking the pool and fenced in yard with a fire pit, this is the perfect place to entertain AND relax. Minutes from the #1 rated Siesta Key beach and downtown Sarasota in one of the areas most sought after neighborhoods you are in the middle of it all!

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 370 reviews

☀Coastal Gem☀Heated pool & amazing location!☀

- Located in a quiet Sarasota neighborhood minutes from shopping, restaurants, & Siesta Key, this amenity packed home is perfect for families and beach enthusiasts! - Enjoy the pool and patio (renovated in July 2025) and comfy outdoor furniture in your fenced in backyard where you can bask in the sun. - Beautifully designed coastal interior w/ new appliances, Smart TVs, and fast WiFi. - Your on-site Superhost is available if needed to assist with making your stay enjoyable and worry free.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Guest suite in Sarasota

Sweet, pet friendly Siesta Suite

Sweet spot with the best of both Sarasota and Siesta Key - your private oasis for relaxing and rejuvenating. Whether you choose to chill or find adventure it is all within reach! Siesta Key beaches, Village with shops, restaurants, and bars; Sarasota culture, arts, and entertainment; quaint Gulf Gate shops and eateries ...the possibilities truly are endless. Regardless of how you choose to spend your time here, you will be sure to create lasting memories to share and leave wanting more.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Adorable Bungalow Fire pit/outdoor shower 2/1 Cute

Charming and tranquil two bedroom home located in central Sarasota. This adorable bungalow is just 6 miles from world famous Siesta Key Beach. Located on a quiet street you are just minutes from great restaurants and shopping. The house is an adorable bungalow with a sweet cottage feel inside. The backyard is private with a fence all around. You can enjoy laying in the hammock and by night sit around the fire pit. There is an outdoor shower with cold and hot water to enjoy.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

The Wisteria Oasis W/ heated pool & hot tub

Come Relax with your family at this peaceful 3 bedroom cottage, It has a private fenced in backyard w/ new heated saltwater pool, hot tub, hammock & swings,and a fire pit to make s’mores! Yes its stocked with beach gear and a short drive to the beautiful siesta key and lido key beaches. Also minutes from the Bayfront park where u can watch amazing sunsets and the downtown sarasota dining spots! Arlington park is in the neighborhood with trails- play area- pool- outdoor gym.

Home in Indian Beach-Sapphire Shores

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 683 reviews

Charming Apt. in old Florida home

Cozy, charming suite in a historic 1920's home. Lots of character and charm. Amazing location. One block from the bay with beautiful sunsets. And just a few miles to the beach and downtown. Clean, comfy and a welcoming host. Great for 1 or up to 3 guests. ****Please read the full detailed description for more information before booking. This is very old home, not fully restored, old Florida house. Owner occupied Non- Smoking guests 🙏 Hope to see you soon

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Bright & Peaceful 1920s Cottage: Close to UTC!

Experience the timeless charm of this 1920s beautifully preserved cottage – where original details meet modern comforts. A bright & peaceful property nestled on half an acre with plenty of space to spread out, natural light that pours into every room, & a private fenced in yard - it's an ideal spot to entertain AND unwind. Whether you are headed to the beach, Benderson Park, Downtown or UTC mall, this neighborhood is central to anything you'll need!

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 214 reviews

The Oasis-Private Heated Pool Hot Tub-5mi to beach

"The Oasis" is a newly renovated beach cottage with heated private pool & hot tub in the heart of Sarasota. It's 5 miles to the #1 beach in the USA, Siesta Key Beach. The cottage offers 2 bedroom & 2 bathrooms, and a bonus room that can be used to sleep 6 comfortably. The one-of-a-kind fully private, fully enclosed backyard includes heated pool, hot tub, BBQ grill, outdoor dining table & fire pit for families & snowbirds to enjoy Florida living!

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

1 Bed 1 bath 7 mins to the beach

This charming 1 bedroom 1 bath space has a calming coastal vibe with dedicated driveway parking, front porch, and fenced backyard. This unit is newly renovated and furnished, and is part of a duplex with a large shared backyard. It is within walking/biking distance or a short drive to grocery stores and restaurants, and 7 mins to Siesta Key - FL's #1 beach! Longboat Key, St. Armands, Turtle Beach, and Downtown are all a short drive away!

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Condo in Sarasota

2/2 condo with garden+heated pool+6min from Siesta

🌴 Stylish Retreat Near Siesta Key – Private Garden & Heated Pool! Welcome to your perfect Sarasota getaway! This 1,000 sq. ft. pet-friendly home offers a private fenced garden, heated pool access, and a prime location just 6 minutes from Siesta Key Beach. Whether you're here for a beach vacation, a family trip, or a remote work retreat, this home has everything you need for a comfortable and stress-free stay.