Holiday houses in Town of Otisco

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Town of Otisco

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top Guest favourite

A rustic cottage is perched on stilts, surrounded by vibrant autumn foliage. Large screened windows provide expansive views, while a wooden deck with railings offers outdoor space below. The structure features a charming blend of dark wood siding and a light-colored roof.

Cottage in Homer

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Cottage Over Water - Skaneateles Lake

Located directly over the beautiful waters of Skaneateles Lake. Enjoy incredible views and immersive soundscapes from a rustic, knotty-pine cottage. Ideal for small-family vacations & couples retreats. Sleeps 4-6. Includes: updated kitchen, bathroom, queen bed set, sleeping loft (w/queen), 8 pc. modular sofa, TV, cable, wi-fi, heat, a/c, water & ice. Patios have seating for dining, sunbathing, net-covered bunk bed, boat dock, swim dock (Jun-Sep), gas grill, big swing, 4 kayaks & a paddle board.

LocationFamilyCleanliness

Top Guest favourite

An A-frame house is situated amidst lush greenery, featuring a spacious outdoor area with seating arrangements around a fire pit. A grill is positioned nearby, with colorful chairs and picnic tables complementing the scene, while string lights add a soft glow as twilight approaches.

Chalet in Marietta

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 34 reviews

Pickleball + Hot Tub | Luxe A-Frame Escape

Modern A-frame meets full-on getaway vibes. Just 1 mile from Otisco Lake and under 10 miles to Beak & Skiff, A-Frame and Chill stuns with exquisite design and curated details. Enjoy 2 king bedrooms with balconies and fireplaces, a hot tub, fire pit, full-size pickleball court, half basketball court, 3-hole disc golf, and stylish living with a Vestaboard, spiral staircase, Tempurpedic sleeper, smart TV, games, and a fully stocked kitchen. Note: Guests will be required to sign a short rental agre

ValueFamilyAir conditioning

Top Guest favourite

A private fire pit area is set on lush green grass, surrounded by several light wooden chairs. In the background, Song Lake glistens under the sun, and a private dock extends into the water, providing access to the serene scenery.

Cottage in Tully

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 380 reviews

Lakefront Getaway - Relax & recharge on Song Lake!

Private lakefront getaway on Song Lake! Spectacular rural setting with room to roam. Enjoy views of autumn foliage by day, relax by the firepit at night! Private deck & dock - bring your kayak and fishing gear! Fully equipped kitchen. Outdoor gas grill. 5 min to Onco brewery. 2 min to Heuga's Alpine & Song Mountain. Ski/snowmobile in winter. Year round access to Finger Lakes wineries, breweries, spas. 25 min to charming Skaneateles dining & shopping. Near 6 colleges including Cornell & SU.

FamilyLocationBathroom

Guest favourite

A serene lakeside area is viewable, featuring a circular fire pit surrounded by four brightly colored Adirondack chairs in red, green, blue, and yellow. A large red umbrella provides shade nearby, with a backdrop of lush greenery and calm lake waters reflecting the landscape.

Holiday home in Marietta

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Nest at Heron Cove - Lakefront Private Apartment

This private apartment w/ EV charger (small added fee) located right the water on Otisco Lake, w/ over 300 ft of lakefront at your front door. Incredible views! The apartment is attached to the main house w/ a private entrance. Beach, seasonal dock, canoe, 2 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, paddle boat, gas grill & fire pit with wood (May - Oct). Fishing, swimming, snow skiing, wine tasting, fine dining, beautiful sunsets await your arrival! 15 min to Skaneateles, 10 min to Song Mountain Skiing.

LocationValueComfort

Guest favourite

A vibrant sunset casts shades of orange, pink, and purple across the sky, reflecting onto the calm waters of the lake. The silhouette of a distant tree line adds depth to the horizon, creating a serene and peaceful landscape.

Home in Marietta

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Otisco Lake park like setting

Year round home located on a unique lakeside country setting with a newly renovated bathroom. Over 2 acres of outside green space offering a park like experience to enjoy many recreational activities * please note this space is shared with family and another guest house. There is plenty of area for all to enjoy including 900 feet of lake frontage with a creek running though the property. Enjoy a campfire lakeside at a dedicated private fire pit. Amber Inn is within walking distance.

LocationFamilyCleanliness

Top Guest favourite

A charming wooden cabin features a large screened-in porch and multiple windows. A stone fire pit is surrounded by rustic stools, creating a cozy outdoor gathering space. Lush greenery and trees provide a natural backdrop, evoking a serene atmosphere for relaxation.

Cabin in Freeville

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Hot tub under the stars at cozy cabin in the FLX

Nestled in a grove of Norway spruce, your peaceful cabin getaway rests in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Built by a local carpenter (with help from his dog Indiana), the cabin has enough coziness and charm to make any stay special. Hike down to Mill Creek (on the property), grill up some burgers on the gas grill, or lounge in a hot tub beneath the stars. The cabin is 15 minutes to Ithaca / Cornell, has a living room with a Switch + BluRay + Netflix, and has satellite wifi (30+ MBPS).

LocationValueQuiet

Top Guest favourite

A serene sunset view over Otisco Lake is captured, with soft orange and pink hues reflected on the water. A wooden deck offers metal tables and chairs, while a grassy area is visible, featuring several kayaks and a shared dock under a tree.

Home in Marietta

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Otisco Lake Cottage

Lovingly renovated cottage on 50 feet of lakefront on the southeastern end of Otisco Lake. Beautiful sunset views. Located within 30 minutes of Syracuse, Skaneateles, Finger Lakes wineries and hiking trails. Large open kitchen and family area, with two bedrooms (one queen, one twin with trundle convertible to a king) and sleeping loft with two twins. 2nd bedroom has a convertible desk. Well-stocked kitchen, books, DVDs, games, shared dock and sloping beach to take out watercraft.

LocationFamilyDecor

Top Guest favourite

Cottage in LaFayette

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

The Old Orchard Cottage

Tom and Lisa welcome you to “The Old Orchard Cottage”. The Cottage was built in the summer of 2025 and we are excited to make this awesome property available to guests. Take in the spectacular views and amazing sunrises from either our huge front porch or lodge-like deck/pavilion out back!The Cottage offers the perfect place to kick back and relax anytime of the year. The area offers many activities for all 4 seasons and The Cottage is the perfect home base to explore Central NY.

LocationValueBarbecue

Top Guest favourite

An inviting living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. A neutral-toned sofa and seating chairs are arranged around a central area rug, while a stone fireplace adds a rustic touch. Greenery can be seen through the windows, connecting indoors and outdoors.

Home in Skaneateles

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews

Sunset House- Beautiful Home with Gorgeous Vistas

Experience a home full of windows and light that take in breathtaking views from every angle. You feel like you are on top of the world surrounded by beautiful rural landscaping that is only 1.8 miles from the charming Village of Skaneateles! Lovely interior furnishings with your comfort in mind. You are within close reach to the Skaneateles Polo Fields, a free public boat launch, Skaneateles Country Club, wedding venues and a winery. This newer home is fresh, clean and cozy!

LocationFamilyCondition

Top Guest favourite

A vibrant sunset reflects on the calm surface of Otisco Lake, featuring shades of orange, pink, and purple. Silhouetted trees line the horizon, while the soft outlines of neighboring cottages can be seen along the water's edge, creating a serene lakeside scene.

Cottage in Marietta

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Beautifully Renovated Lakefront Cottage on Otisco!

This recently renovated cottage is located on 60' of lake frontage on Otisco Lake. Enjoy everything lakefront living has to offer in a cute little package! The cottage is on a rare flat lot! There is easy access to the water from the sloping beach to take out the kayaks provided. Take in the beautiful sunsets while sitting in the backyard by the fire! The cottage is located just 20 minutes from the Village of Skaneateles and 30 min from Syracuse University and SUNY Cortland.

FamilyValueCleanliness

Superhost

A couple is seen dancing in front of a whimsical hobbit-themed structure nestled among trees. A picnic setup lies on the ground, surrounded by greenery. The entrance of the unique dwelling is decorated with intricate woodwork and natural elements, creating an enchanting atmosphere.

Guesthouse in LaFayette

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 352 reviews

Stay a night at our tiny Hobbit House

We are close to Syracuse NY, Jamesville Beach,and Tully. You’ll love our place because - Well, its a Hobbit House :). Very cozy 12 by 12 cabin set in the back of my land right where the woods start. Small cabin good for a couple and maybe a child or two but no more than that. It has an outhouse. If this is sounding too basic or off the grid then please don't book! :) because that's exactly what is. But you also get to say you stayed in a cozy little hobbit house.

ValueFamilyCheck-in

Guest favourite

Home in Tully

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Modern Luxury Escape on Private Acreage

Welcome to your serene retreat just outside of Syracuse, nestled in the picturesque town of Tully, NY. Whether you're seeking peace and quiet or adventure in nature, this new, modern home offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience for your stay. Unique Features: Speakeasy Retreat Outdoor Oasis Modern Comforts We are currently building more homes on this 10 acre property to help accommodate all of your friends and family!

LocationFamilyTV