
Holiday houses in New Middletown
Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb
Top-rated holiday rentals in New Middletown
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Staycation Lake View HUGE Year Round Spa Firepit
This mid 1800's log cabin, built as humble servant's quarters, has been completely transformed. It's now a spacious home with multiple additions set on a scenic and peaceful lake. Did I mention the unexpectedly gigantic year-round swim spa for ultimate relaxation, romance or fun! Feel at home connecting with loved ones in a tranquil natural setting. 6 Adults plus space for kids! WIFI & Smart Roku TVs Boardman, Youngstown and state line attractions. Discounts increase with 4+ day stays!
ValueFamilyView
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews
Cozy Cabin Nestled In The Hills
Escape to a cozy cabin with breath taking river views. This cabin features seclusion but still close to many amenities. Located minutes from a beautiful 18 hole golf course for the avid golfer. During the warmer months, enjoy the close proximity to the Ohio River. Spend your days boating, kayaking, or fishing. Feeling lucky? Take a ten minute drive to Mountaineer Racetrack and Casino to enjoy great food and games. Make a short drive to The Pavilion at Star Lake to see some big name concerts.
LocationValueAmenities
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews
Cozy Holiday Home | Pets Stay Free | Yard | YSU
Make yourself at home in our cozy, holiday-decorated retreat near YSU! Perfect for family visits, work trips, holiday getaways & traveling pet parents! 🐾 ALL pets stay FREE! ✨ Entire private 2-story home ✨ Fully fenced yard ✨ Fast WiFi + dedicated office ✨ Stocked kitchen + cozy living room ✨ Quiet neighborhood ✨ 12-15 mins to YSU & Youngstown attractions ✨ Warm, festive holiday touches Your home away from home awaits! Please note: Stairs are semi-steep. Stovetop works; oven does not.
LocationValueWalkability
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews
Carlson’s Northside
Sorry…no instant booking available. Each request is to be reviewed. This listing is for the upstairs only and does not include the use of the downstairs with golf simulator, pool table, and cigar room. Please search and book that listing separately if you would like to use of the entire building with amenities. Located in downtown Lowellville, OH next to the beautiful Mahoning River, this historic building has been restored to its original beauty. The passing of trains adds character.
FamilyLocationDecor
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews
Shipping Container Cabin with hot tub!
Enjoy our secluded getaway, that's not too far away! This cabin is made from three combined shipping containers to create one memorable experience for our renters. Housed on ten acres on Beaver creek and surrounded by nature's beauty, this rental is sure to give you the adventure and relaxation you need. Enjoy your favorite drink on one of two beautiful patios, by the fire inside or out, and end your evening in the warmth of our hot tub. Only 6 minutes from Route 11 in Lisbon, OH!
ValueLocationCleanliness
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 192 reviews
The Power Haven
Escape to The Power Haven, where tranquility meets adventure! Set on a serene acre, this unique retreat is perfect for family escapes, golf trips, girls’ getaways, and rejuvenating retreats. Stay in themed rooms—Inspiration, Positivity, Power, and Confidence—each designed to uplift. Melt stress away in the Relaxation Room’s massage chair, soak in the Tranquility Tub, or gather by the fire pit. With a game room and top attractions minutes away, your perfect getaway awaits. Book now!
LocationFamilyBathroom
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews
“The Thomas” House with Private Hot Tub
A picturesque countryside getaway with the convenience of shopping and restaurants nearby. If you love breweries, hot tubbing, golfing, cruising the neighborhood in a Model T golf cart, or just relaxing in a really cool house, this place is for you! Antiquing and open summer concerts minutes away. Comfort awaits in beautiful cozy interiors with vintage industrial vibe. With a touch of history and a lot of charm, your stay at “The Henry” will be a fun and welcome retreat.
LocationValueNearby
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 337 reviews
Michelle’s Log Cabin @ Horse Farm
Secluded log cabin getaway on a peaceful farm. Relax and enjoy the sounds of nature, pasture views, and beautiful sunrises. Note: Incinerator toilet. Feed the horses at the fence—treats provided! Enjoy a ½-mile winding trail around the pasture. Comcast Wi-Fi, 3 TVs, gas grill, gas fire table, fire ring, cornhole Please book for the correct number of guests. Pets welcome with approval—please keep them off furniture, bedding & carpets. Must be crated when unattended
ValueLocationBackyard
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews
Quiet Country Side Home w/Hot Tub & Dog Friendly!
Three bedroom, two full bathrooms. We have 2-4 parking spaces available along with a huge backyard perfect for grilling season! We have a fully equipped kitchen and dinner table. On the main floor you will find the main bathroom. We are located 15-20 mins from your major shopping in Boardman, and yes DoorDash delivers! Pitts. Int. Airport is approx. 50mins and Mercy Health is approx. 15 mins away. Pets are welcome with a small fee!
ValueFamilyAccuracy
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews
The Nantucket Nook @ Pine Lake
The Nantucket Nook is a gem featuring a beautiful view of the lake off the back deck. A huge 70-inch TV makes the living area perfect for watching a movie or keeping up with your favorite sports! Being right beside Route 7 gives you quick and direct access to Columbiana, Boardman, and Youngstown. Local favorite places to check out are the Vineyards at Pine Lake, The Amish Market, Firestone Farms, and the Shaker Woods Festival!
ValueLocationIndoor spaces
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews
Wayside Getaway with cozy patio & private hot tub!
Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay! You have the whole house, a front porch to relax on, smokeless firepit & seating, secluded patio out back with pergola, another seating area and a private 7 person hot tub! Bikes and toys for kids, and welcome public access to over a dozen playsets right next door on our sales lot. Play to your heart's content! 2 car garage with level 2 EV charger available.
LocationFamilyNearby
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews
Cozy A-Frame Getaway Minutes from Nelson Ledges
Welcome to a new space for rest. You will be greeted with the coziness and peace of the nature without sacrificing luxury and convenience. Whether you decide to stay in and enjoy the hot tub, or get out and explore the ledges and quaint town of Garrettsville, you are sure to create lasting memories. We also provide top notch wifi and a designated workspace so working from home just got a whole lot comfier.
ValueLocationGetting around
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 270 reviewsPopular amenities for New Middletown holiday rentals
Other great holiday rentals in New Middletown

The John Collins House
FamilyLocationAmenities
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews
Relaxing Farmhouse retreat
FamilyValuePets
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews
Hideaway On Hatcher
LocationValueBathroom
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews
Fishing pond Lower Level Guesthouse with hot tub
FamilyLocationGetting around
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews
Boardman Ranch | 15 Min to YSU
LocationValueCleanliness
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews
The Silo @ Red Mud Hollow Farm
ValueLocationIndoor spaces
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews
Neshannock Creekside Log Cabin
FamilyLocationCheck-in
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews
The Ember Cabin | Sky Cinema - Stargazing - Farm
FamilyLocationIndoor spaces
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviewsDestinations to explore
- Philadelphia Holiday rentals
- Washington Holiday rentals
- Pittsburgh Holiday rentals
- Columbus Holiday rentals
- Cleveland Holiday rentals
- Cincinnati Holiday rentals
- Niagara Falls Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- Mississauga Holiday rentals
- Baltimore Holiday rentals
- Richmond Holiday rentals
- Buffalo Holiday rentals
- Acrisure Stadium
- PNC Park
- University Of Pittsburgh
- Carnegie Mellon University
- Pro Football Hall of Fame
- David Lawrence Convention Center
- Gervasi Vineyard
- Pittsburgh Zoo & PPG Aquarium
- Raccoon Creek State Park
- Moraine State Park
- Mosquito Lake State Park
- Punderson State Park
- Point State Park
- Petersen Events Center
- Phipps Conservatory and Botanical Gardens
- PPG Paints Arena
- Schenley Park
- Carnegie Science Center
- McConnells Mill State Park
- National Aviary
- Children's Museum of Pittsburgh
- Senator John Heinz History Center
- Randyland
- Cathedral of Learning





