Cottage holiday rentals in Kelleys Island

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Top-rated cottage rentals in Kelleys Island

Guests agree: These cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Superhost
A grouping of six colorful Adirondack chairs is arranged around a circular fire pit on a concrete patio, overlooking the waterfront. The serene view features trees on the shoreline and clear blue skies reflecting on the water's surface.
Cottage in Sandusky
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 229 reviews

White waterfront cottage, close to cedar point

Cute waterfront cottage. Completely updated summer 2021 with new flooring throughout, new kitchen, kitchen appliances. New bathroom (2021). Waterfront seating and propane fire pit. Views of Pipe Creek and the east bay of Sandusky Bay. Sleeps 7. Recently added 28’ dock for use (for 2023 season) Close to everything Sandusky and the surrounding areas have to offer. Minutes to Cedar Point, downtown, Sports Force. Check out my guidebooks by clicking on my profile for restaurants and activities!

Guest favourite
A cozy cottage is nestled among autumn leaves, showcasing a light-colored exterior. The wraparound deck features a set of chairs and a small table, providing a space to enjoy nature. Trees with vibrant fall foliage frame the scene, enhancing the tranquil setting.
Cottage in Milan
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Private Hillside Cottage near Cedar Point, Milan

The Odd Cottage is an old house with new tricks. Built in 1853, it stood during the time that Thomas Edison himself wandered the streets of historic Milan, Ohio. Inspired by his story, inside you'll find a modern space that's designed to enable both comfort and creativity. We're centrally located between the area's best attractions: North - Kalahari Resort / 10 min - Sports Force Park / 15 min - Cedar Point / 20 min South - Summit Motorsports Park / 10 min East - Edisons Birthplace / 3 min

Top Guest favourite
A light-colored, single-story house is presented, featuring a front porch with steps leading to the entrance. Lush green bushes and flower beds are visible along the front, while a neighboring house is partially seen to the right, showcasing a well-maintained yard.
Cottage in Huron
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 226 reviews

Lake Front Park Cottage - Huron, OH. Lake Erie

Located in the historic Old Plat district this completely updated, high-end home is nestled between Huron’s Lake Front Park or a secluded sandy beach! Park has picnic tables, grills, play-ground, rest rooms. Shortwalk to the Boat Basin & Amphitheater as well as the Huron Lighthouse & Pier. Less than 15 minutes to Cedar Point, Sports Complex, Kalahari, Great Wolf. Near numerous golf courses and everything else that the Lake Erie Islands area has to offer! Minutes to Nickleplate Beach too!

Top Guest favourite
A modern single-story home is shown, featuring a light-colored exterior with multiple windows. An outdoor patio area is visible, furnished with a table and chairs. A grill is positioned nearby, and the well-maintained surroundings contribute to the inviting ambiance.
Cottage in Port Clinton
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Catawba Island (Lake Erie) Marina House

Recently remodeled, open floor plan; 3 bedrooms (6 beds), 2 full bathrooms and 1,600+ SF of living space. Fully equipped kitchen, full-size washer and dryer, cable TV, dining area, play area, central a/c, parking for 4 cars, outdoor patio with grill, sitting area and fire pit. Located on a private road on doorstep of Foxhaven Marina. Quick and easy access to Lake Erie. Only minutes from beaches, island ferry’s and numerous restaurants, wineries, breweries, waterparks and area attractions.

Superhost
A cozy living room is presented with a light grey sofa adorned with decorative pillows, accompanied by an accent chair in a soft blue hue. Natural light enters through sheer curtains, and a decorative area rug enhances the space. A TV stand holds a Roku Smart TV, with a door leading outside.
Cottage in Vermilion
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Pet-Friendly Cottage • Mins to Downtown Vermilion

Ahoy! Sailor’s Way is a relaxing, pet friendly cottage minutes away from the quaint, downtown Vermilion. Whether you’re shopping, eating, boating, or checking out the farmer’s market, Vermilion always has something going on, so book your stay! Although there is no beach access, at the end of the road, you can see Lake Erie! The cottage is close to public beach access, the lighthouse and several parks. Approximately 45 minutes to the Miller Ferry Port and 35 minutes to Cedar Point.

Top Guest favourite
A mid-century cottage is set within a lush garden, featuring a stone fireplace and a covered porch. The exterior showcases a blend of siding and a stone chimney, surrounded by blooming flowers and greenery, creating a peaceful outdoor setting.
Cottage in Amherst
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 282 reviews

The Farmer's Cottage

The Farmer's cottage is a cozy one bedroom mid-century farm cottage on 2 acres of land nestled among farm fields and woodlands . It features a queen-sized bed, bath and full custom kitchen along with a smart TV and Wi-Fi. . A park-like yard with a stone fireplace and solar installation awaits. This country property features self contained utilities including a water well, sanitation and electricity. Enjoy fresh eggs from our chickens and baked goods from our farm kitchens.

Top Guest favourite
An open living area is highlighted, showcasing a stone fireplace and a cozy seating arrangement. A round area rug lies on the floor, while a wooden dining table and chairs are positioned nearby. Sunlight filters through large windows, enhancing the welcoming ambiance.
Cottage in Huron
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 167 reviews

Routh@Rye...Huron, OH Cottage with a Lovely View!

Beautiful cottage located on the shore of Lake Erie, next to a private community park. Minutes from Cedar Point, Sports Force Parks, boats headed to Kelleys Island, Put-in-bay, and other fun. Centrally located between Toledo and Cleveland and all the attractions northern Ohio has to offer. Step back in time and enjoy a home large enough for 7-9 people, cozy enough for two, featuring an open living/dining/kitchen; first floor laundry and bath; and three 2nd floor bedrooms and bath.

Top Guest favourite
A welcoming front porch is shown, featuring two small chairs and a round table. A patterned rug lies underneath, complemented by greenery on either side. The entrance is framed by a black door, allowing natural light to brighten the space.
Cottage in Lakeside Marblehead
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Lakeside Love

Full interior renovation in 2025 & new furnishings! Amazing outdoor space with grill and plenty of outdoor seating. Great location in walking distance to parks, Lake Erie and all Lakeside amenities. Private parking for up to 3 cars. Fully equipped kitchen, dishwasher, induction range, French door refrigerator with ice and filtered water, microwave, washer/dryer. TV, and WiFi. Bathroom with shower/toilet room and separate vanity room. 2 bedroom, 1 sleeping porch, sleeps 6.

Top Guest favourite
A two-story white house is positioned on a raised deck, surrounded by large rocks at the water's edge. Windows line the upper level, providing scenic views. The deck offers ample space for outdoor seating, creating a relaxing area by the water.
Cottage in Oak Harbor
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Pet Friendly Water Front Private Beach Lake Erie

Bring your fur babies. Let them vacation with you! Amazing views of the water! Truly spectacular! Private beach with lots to do we offer water toys like the Water lily or kayaks, or lay in the sun and play in the sand. You can take a nice long walk or go for a bike ride. We are Walleye capital of the world, so go fishing! Many fishing charters OR you can dock your boat at nearby marina. The house is completely stocked with all the essentials & some non-essentials too.

Top Guest favourite
The living room features a spacious sofa with light-colored cushions and accent chairs. A coffee table with decorative items sits in the center, and a smart TV is mounted on the wall. Natural light enters through sheer curtains, enhancing the neutral color palette.
Cottage in Port Clinton
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 147 reviews

Cozy Lake Cottage 5 min walk to the BEACH

As comfortable as it is beautiful, our renovated lake house is ready for you to enjoy all that the Port Clinton area has to offer. Spend the day at the beach, island hopping via the Jett Express, wine tasting in Catawba or adrenaline seeking at Cedar Point. Come home and cook in our fully equipped kitchen or throw your catch of the day on the grill and enjoy the backyard. Not into cooking? We're just a mile from the downtown restaurants and bars! Smart TV, Wifi, beds for 6.

Top Guest favourite
A group of individuals enjoys the water at sunset, with arms raised in celebration. The calm lake reflects warm hues of orange and pink from the setting sun, creating a serene backdrop against the rippling surface of the water.
Cottage in Vermilion
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

The Dean’s List, Lake View Cottage

Beautiful Vintage Cottage with Lake Erie views! Across from beautiful sunsets at Brownhelm Lakefront Park with a small beach. Close to Farm Market, grocery store, restaurants, shopping, and downtown Vermilion. Enjoy the comforts of home while experiencing all that Lake Erie shores has to offer! Use as home base for boating, fishing, and vacationing at Cedar Point, Lake Erie Islands, Kalahari, Port Clinton to west, Lorain and Cleveland to the east!

Guest favourite
The exterior of the cottage features a light blue facade with white shutters and a welcoming front door. A small, colorful chair is positioned beside the entrance, surrounded by manicured grass and a few decorative plants. Sunlight casts gentle shadows on the pathway.
Cottage in Vermilion
4.85 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Beachfront #5 at Plaz Vilka Cottages Vermilion OH

Plaz Vilka Beachfront Cottage #5 is a Quaint cottage located next to Lake Erie at Plaz Vilka Beachfront House & Cottages. Beautiful views and sunsets. Relaxing seating areas to watch the water or read. A perfect place to unwind. Nearby is the nautical town of Vermilion, with shops and restaurants. Rates are taxed 6.75% OH sales & 7% Erie County lodging tax. Seasonal rental available May 15th thru October 15th.

Popular amenities for Kelleys Island cottage rentals

Quick stats about cottage rentals in Kelleys Island

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Kelleys Island holiday rentals start at $268 AUD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 390 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi and Pool across Kelleys Island rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    Kelleys Island stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Ohio
  4. Erie County
  5. Kelleys Island
  6. Cottage rentals