Monthly Rentals in Fish Creek Harbor

Eric and Natalie's cottage is one of my favorite places I've ever stayed in Door County. Nestled on a quiet street and only about one mile to downtown fish creek - the location was perfect. The cottage is tastefully decorated, and we felt right at home here. Like most fairytale cottages the internet was quite slow, but fast enough for streaming music, checking emails, and using maps. Pet friendly was a huge plus, our two dogs had as much fun as we did! We hope to be back again next summer.

We had an amazing stay at John and Tracy’s Airbnb! The view of the lake was absolutely spectacular—sunrises and sunsets were pure magic. The property was spotless and clearly well taken care of, with every little detail thought through. John and Tracy were fantastic hosts—welcoming, responsive, and full of great local tips. The highlight for our family was the massive game room, complete with a pool table and a huge variety of games. The kids had a blast, and honestly, so did we! It made for some unforgettable evenings. This place truly felt like a home away from home, and we’re already talking about when we can come back. Highly recommend!

Absolutely adored the cottage and our stay in Fish Creek! The house is so idyllic and charming, and right in the center of everything there is to do in Fish Creek. We would love to return someday!

Karen's #5 Brook Point was the perfect getaway retreat. The location was ideal - walking distance to everything in Fish Creek and to all the trails at the Peninsula State Park. We barely used our car during our 4 night stay, which was ideal. The townhouse was very private, pristine, and incredibly well stocked with kitchen supplies, bathroom supplies, and bed/bath linens. Internet and many TV streaming channels are provided. The mattress in the primary bedroom was very comfortable, and the kitchen was a joy to cook in. Many brochures and pamphlets were provided showing local activities. Karen was proactive in providing all information we would need to check-in, check-out, and was quick responding when we texted her upon leaving. We highly recommend staying at Brook Point! We will be back.