Lake house holiday rentals in Cooperstown

The Swindon House

PRE APPROVAL NEEDED FOR PETS !Only ADA certified pets are considered a service pet. Emotional support animals are not considered service dogs so fee applies. Please no early check in. Stunningly beautiful new construction home with state of the art kitchen fully stocked. High end appliances, double oven, gas stove, Cathedral ceilings, electric double recliner, gas fireplace, smart T.V.s in every room with satellite. Luxury linens and towels locally sourced amenities .There are 2 fenced in yards.

Location · Family · Hospitality

Beautiful Big Lake Front home near Cooperstown

“The Third Base” is a perfect lake front property close to Cooperstown/Oneonta. Home will allow you to relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. Big and spacious home with tons of room for the family!Very Beautiful Lake Front property right on the lake. 2 kayaks and 1 body board to use at property. Enjoy fishing and swimming off our private dock. This home offers extremely great views from every level of the home. This house is one-of-a-kind!! You need to see it to believe it.

Value · Location · Nearby

Goodyear Lake Rental - Lakeside Baseball Getaway

Just 15 minutes from Dreams Park & All Star Village, Bluegill Cove is one of the best Goodyear Lake rentals. On the quiet side of the lake, enjoy 100 feet of private lakefront with a glacial pebble beach, dock, kayaks, paddleboard, giant float, firepit, and beautiful sunset views. Perfect for a family of 5 looking to relax - two porches sit over the water views. A family favorite for 20+ years, it ranks among the top 5% of Airbnb listings and often books a year in advance. The views say it all.

Family · Value · Quiet

Cooperstown - Sunset Dinners and Private Dock Days

Private lakefront escape on iconic Arnold Lake. This newly renovated 4-bedroom 2.5 bath retreat is tucked among whispering pines with breathtaking water views from lakefront floor to ceiling windows. Kayak, swim, stargaze on the deck, or simply unwind in total serenity. Minutes to Cooperstown and the Baseball Hall of Fame, yet a world away. Perfect for families, nature lovers, and anyone ready to reset in unforgettable style and peace, surrounded by timeless views that inspire and restore deeply

Value · Family · Wi-Fi

Young Lake House - near Dreams Park & Hall of Fame

Come escape to a different time and place, where people are neighborly and relaxed, and where the only noises you’ll hear are the gentle waves of a lake, the cascading of the creek, and the soft buzzing of hummingbirds in the morning. Enjoy spectacular mountain views, breath-taking pastoral meadows, and the picturesque beauty of the lake. This truly unique property envelops you in privacy and warmth. Take a daily stroll through the property, practice your golf swing or go fishing in the lake.

Location · Family · Accuracy

Beautiful Farmhouse & Majestic Waterfall

The Sparrow House is a beautiful farmhouse with a private trail to a majestic 120' waterfall. With vintage wallpapers, eclectic antiques, a cozy fireplace, an outdoor cedar sauna, a large fenced in yard surrounded by honeysuckle vines and a spectacular mountain view, the house is a perfect getaway spot in unspoiled nature and still-wild forests of the Catskills. The waterfall is a truly magical place and considered a sacred site. The house is not appropriate for loud groups or parties. 🙏🦋🙌

Value · Family · Backyard

Lakefront, 5 Min to Colgate, Sleeps 8

- 🌅 Waterfront lake views - 🚣 Self-serve kayaks & paddleboard - 🛏️ 2 bedrooms + trundle bed + pull-out couch (sleeps 8) - 🎓 5 minutes to Colgate University - 🕹️ Giant Connect Four - 🎯 Lawn games - 🔥 Electric fireplace - 🍳 Fully stocked kitchen - ☕ Drip & Keurig coffee maker - 🛁 Linens & towels provided *⚠️ Lake Moraine is currently drawn down 10 ft through 2028 for a NYS dam project. Kayaking, paddleboarding, and fishing continue unaffected at the Colgate Boathouse next door 🚣*

Value · Location · Quiet

Lakeside Retreat

Welcome to Lakeside Retreat—a cozy cottage on Goodyear Lake offering stunning lake views and all the modern comforts you need for a relaxing stay. Just minutes from Cooperstown and Oneonta baseball camps, spend your days kayaking or canoeing along over nine miles of peaceful shoreline, fishing from your private dock, and soaking in the outdoor hot tub under the stars. In the evenings, unwind fireside with your favorite drink. The perfect blend of adventure and relaxation awaits you here.

Value · Family · Amenities

Little Red Lake House

Relax with the whole family at this comfy, newly renovated from top to bottom home. We have lakefront access on a very quiet road. The house has all the comforts needed to relax, enjoy and make memories. Our back deck leads to the grill and down the steps to the grass area. walk 20 steps to the water. Brand new kitchen and appliances allow for easy meal prep. Central AC and heat, smart TV's in all the bedrooms, dedicated space for work, paddle boat, 2 paddle boards & fantastic views!

Location · Family · Comfort

Lakefront chalet w. hot tub, game room, & kayaks

Pet-friendly chalet with hot tub, private shoreline, gameroom, coffee bar, reading nook, and cozy wood-burning stove. Nestled amongst the trees, this home offers: o Your own private shoreline with firepit, fishing rods, kayaks and paddleboat; o Hot tub overlooking the lake;    o 5.5 acres to explore with wooded trails, limestone cliffs, and winter views;    o Gameroom with ping pong, air hockey, foosball, and Xbox; and    o Proximity to waterfalls, hikes, biking & skiing.

Family · Value · Access

Luxury Cooperstown Area Lake Home with Amenities!!

2027 Summer Bookings open 10/1, we only accept 6 night stays aligned with “Cooperstown Dreams Park” schedule, see their site for schedule. “Allstar Village” schedule does not align with us. The 2027 season is 5/30-8/22/26. Beautiful 3 bedroom on Canadarago Lake, 15 min. drive to Cooperstown. We now have 6 kayaks, a pedal boat, & a paddle board! Enjoy coffee viewing the peacefulness of the lake, if mornings aren’t for you, It is as beautiful at sunset with wine.

Location · Family · Hot tub

Cooperstown Hall of Fame, Dreams Park Baseball

***** From August 17, 2025 to May 31, 2026- Please be sure to add the number of guests staying at the property to get the appropriate pricing. There is an additional fee after 2 guests. *****There is an additional fee for pets. It is a $150 fee per pet per stay. ***** From May 31 to August 29, 2026 Please put in only ONE guest to get the summer pricing. it is a SIX day minimum/maximum stay. Check out time is 9 am in the summer.

Value · Location · Hospitality