House holiday rentals in Cayuga Lake

Our family had a wonderful stay! Lovely surroundings. Good books. Cool antiques. Perfect for a Fall getaway.

We had a wonderful stay at Evan's house. The location is great - secluded but not isolated, and not too far from shopping (Wegmans – 15 minutes) and colleges (Ithaca College – 18 minutes). The house was very spacious and tastefully done. For people that like to cook, there is oil, salt, pepper, ketchup and mustard in the kitchen so there's no need to buy or bring them. There were many thoughtful touches, including flashlights by the outside doors, labels by the lights and temperature controls, phone chargers by the beds, and an outside poop bag garbage bin. Our dog really liked running around the property. Evan was super responsive and always got back to me right away.

We loved this place!! There was so many amenities that we weren’t able to use because we weren’t in the house a ton as we were in a wedding, but boy did we miss out on them! We had a perfect stay and would absolutely stay again if we were ever in the area again. No complaints at all!

The home was a comfortable temperature when we arrived, clean, and perfect for a getaway. The pool was warm with plenty of pool floaties for everyone, plus there were extra pool towels. Would recommend and will be coming back!

We stayed for four nights with six people and three pets, and it was perfect for our needs. We were comfortable and the surrounding area is beautiful!

Beautiful, private spot. Clean and spacious. The first Airbnb in which I’ve stayed whose kitchen had everything needed and wanted. We were there late winter but I can imagine it is wonderful during the summer with the pool. Close to Wegmans; within 30 minutes of Rochester museums and Canandaigua Lake.

Our family stayed here right after Christmas & not only did the accommodations fit us perfectly, it was nice to be somewhere that was decorated for the holiday. The house was of course old, but that is part of the charm. The bathrooms were pristine & the grounds were beautiful! We would definitely stay here again! Thank you Martha!

Loved our time here. It was a great space to stretch out after spending time in NYC. Lots of fun extras for the kids like the toys and games in the shanty. Great proximity to church historical sites if that is of interest. Would recommend to anyone!

Randi was responsive and so helpful as we booked our weekend stay to visit our son. The home was so convenient - just a few mins away from campus and also from downtown. Its nicely furnished, clean and really comfortable. we normally stay in a hotel but Randi’s home was so much better! You can’t go wrong with this home - We are planning a return visit!

This is a charming spot, central to everything. We like to have a place to hang out as a family when we come to visit our child who is a student at Ithaca and this was an ideal spot! Nicholas made everything easy! The coffee and tea are a really nice touch!

Great place. Walking distance to the commons. Enjoyed our stay.

This charming cottage is nestled in a peaceful, safe neighborhood with easy access to all areas of Syracuse. The location was perfect for my several-month stay. I was grateful for how warm the home stayed during Syracuse's intense winter. The tub was a lovely feature and the bed was very comfortable. There were a couple of minor maintenance items initially, but Anna was incredibly responsive and addressed everything promptly. Overall, my extended stay was truly peaceful and enjoyable. I felt right at home and would happily return.

spacious and comfortable cabin on the lake, with an amazing view of the sunset on Seneca lake. exactly as described

Booked this place to celebrate a my birthday with some friends. We had 12 people and we had plenty of room for everyone. Check in/out was very easy, and everything that was said to be included was. The room with the pool table was a great hangout spot and is bigger than how it looks in the pictures. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone with a larger group of people. We had an excellent stay!

This place is lovely. Close to the state park, in the main stretch of town for a quick walk downtown. They took great care to provide all the necessities to make you feel right at home. It’s bigger than we anticipated providing space for all of us.

Lori's place was very clean and located in a very peaceful part of the area! We had several cars and needed somewhere with plenty of parking and this was perfect for that! She was very responsive and helpful and the house was very clean!

Great place for family and kids. Large bedrooms, activities in the basement for kids, and lots of open space for the kids to slide around and have fun.

We stayed only one night for New Year's eve. We had a lovely time. Beautiful view on the lake. The house is charming! Plenty of space. We would have stayed longer.. Derrick responded quickly to our queries. All was perfect! Thank you.

Beautiful little home! The host was responsive and friendly. Everything was clean and tidy. Great little hidden gem. 10/10 recommend if you want to get away from the world and have a peaceful quite place.

This was an absolutely wonderful property! We loved the location and it was a beautiful place perfect for our family of four and two dogs. I loved walking my dogs all over the beautiful lake area. We enjoyed fresh local food, very kind people, and the charm of a small lake town. Thank you to our host for being so responsive and helpful!

It was everything we could have hoped for while we visited my son at college. We will definitely be back next time!

Beautiful property in a beautiful, quiet neighborhood. This place was perfect for our family of 5 children. Becca quickly responded to questions. I would definitely stay here again.

We had a wonderful stay! The house itself is beautiful and well-maintained, and we felt right at home there. Jennifer was incredibly responsive and accommodating, allowing us to check in early and check out late which was a huge help. We truly enjoyed our stay and would highly recommend this property to anyone looking for a relaxing getaway.

This house is exactly what we were looking for. Private getaway with a great view out the back. The creek out back was great for sleeping with the window open (when the weather allowed). Large yard, quiet street which is great for walking along the rest of the creek. The kitchen was well stocked with appliances & cooking equipment (we added a whisk to the collection). Spike the mowbot was a source of entertainment for us. where would he show up next 🤣 Overall it was a great stay & we would definitely consider staying here again if coming back to the area!