Fitness-friendly holiday rentals in West Milford

My friend and I came to town to catch a NWSL game in Harrison. This spot was perfect! Walkable to the arena and to Newark Penn. Katie is an amazing host! She was responsive and friendly and helped to make us feel welcome. Her place is beautiful and cool.

We stayed for one month. It was a pleasant stay. No issues. Everything was as advertised -- no surprises. Would stay again.

Shaun was a great host who communicated very quickly when we had any questions. He has a great place & I definitely reccommend!!

The apartment was beautifully renovated, quiet, and comfortable. Its location is ideal, with easy access to shops, cafes, and restaurants, and it's right next to the Aqueduct Trail. Jay was responsive and quick to address all of my questions. We were sorry our stay was so short, but we definitely plan to return for a longer visit!.

Responsive host. Great parking and location

The place was great, location was perfect because we were able to catch express bus into NYC nearby and the host was very responsive

Celebrated my 1 year anniversary here and it was lovely! The decorations were beautiful and I absolutely loved our custom wine bottle! Thank you so much Shaquannah for everything! 😊❤️✨

This amazing apartment screams VIEW and LOCATION! The apartment has sweeping views of Central Park with beautiful sunrises for you to enjoy. It is located within JW Marriott Essex House with a common entry and exit from the hotel. Breakfast and meals are available at the Marriott on paid-basis. It is located at the south entrance of Central Park, its a 1 minute walk to 5th Avenue and a 5 min walk to Times Square. Everything that you may possibly need in New York is located around you. The apartment is on the 32nd floor and is well equipped with essentials. The host along with his property manager, Luke, communicated very well and made our stay comfortable. We will definitely return to this apartment for our next day in NYC !!

While having a vibe similar to the overlook hotel from the Shining, the place was amazing. Beautiful views and felt super cozy. Would recommend a stay here to anyone!

This is a great condo if you visit Mountain creek. The furnishings are very nice, great feel to the unit. Location wise it can’t be beat. It’s right near the pool, great patio and easy walks to the lift for mountain biking. Even being close to all that it is still quiet and relaxing. The unit was very clean, bathroom is great size and the hosts provided everything g you could want. Definitely would stay here again.

Great place to stay ! Host was responsive and had great local recommendations ! We really enjoyed our stay and will be definitely be back !

Where do I begin with Kings Airbnb? From the time I booked his Airbnb he communicated with me well. Upon arriving to the Airbnb there was lots of parking and easy access to the unit. When you walk into King's Airbnb you are greeted with beautiful Decor in every room. King's Airbnb will definitely be one I will revisit in the near future.

David was incredibly kind and responsive, always quick to answer any questions and made check-in super easy. It’s clear he put a lot of care into making their guests feel welcome.

We loved our stay in Helen’s apartment. Location - just far enough away from Times Square - but within walking distance. Lots of amenities close by. The apartment is so very comfortable.

amazing host! incredibly helpful and kind. check-in was easy, area felt safe, apartment was clean and comfortable. would definitely recommend and stay here again.

Massimo was the absolute best and sweetest, honest, helpful, generous, considerate person I’ve ever worked with on here. His home was so beautiful, clean, and aesthetically pleasing. He even provided snacks, water, and mash mellows and graham crackers along with the sticks if we wanted to use the onsite bonfire. He thought of everything down to little candy in trays, chocolates , probably the best bed I’ve ever slept in. There was not 1 thing about this trip I could complain about. I bragged to my friends who came over how amazing he was even at responding when I got lost. I’ve recommended him to a few people already so I hope he gets an abundance of business. It was worth every penny. He is an exceptional host and person. I will make it back to stay again. If you’re looking for pure comfort and ease don’t waste a burger second and book ! His place is worth it. Thank you so much Massimo you made my birthday amazing!!!!

David's place was a perfect accommodation for our family group of 7 people! We could walk across the street to the Full Circle for dinner or breakfast baked goods and coffee. the house has a wonderful yard work firepower (which unfortunately the rain prevented us from using. ) the yard is perfect for active kids who love to run around and explore. The location is also perfect for access to local wineries and to Minnewaska State Park. Thank you so much David!!

I had a good stay at this Airbnb. The place was very clean, spacious, and just as described in the listing. One of the biggest highlights for me was the location—it’s super close to MetLife Stadium, which was the main reason for my visit. Mr. Jay was a great host—very responsive, friendly, and easy to communicate with throughout the stay. A couple of things to keep in mind: the neighborhood felt a bit sketchy, especially if you’re planning to walk to nearby food spots or grocery stores. Also, there isn’t private parking due to space, so you’ll need to find street parking in front of the house, which is parallel-style. It wasn’t a big issue, but worth noting. Overall, it’s a solid place to stay if you’re looking for a clean and spacious spot near MetLife with a helpful and responsive host.

Suzanne’s home is absolutely beautiful! We had a great stay, albeit cold and rainy during most of it. The well-stocked house allowed us to feel right at home and during the rain we played plenty of games of pool and darts. The kayaks were fun to take out and we even caught a few fish (although it did seem the fish were smarter than us- stealing most of our bait). The view of the lake is amazing, the area is quiet, and there is an eagle that hangs out on the rock just beyond the dock!

We were extremely pleased with Shinto and his house. The house and the surrounding area were more beautiful than the pictures could capture. Shinto was a very accommodating and I couldn’t ask for a better host. Will definitely be returning asap!

We loved this place and would recommend to everyone! Jennifer and Jose were so kind and communicative and so helpful! It was such a beautiful place and we would definitely book again! Thank you for everything!!!

Beautiful & Calm home , host was really nice, easy to communicate, Our family had really good time I will recommend for everyone.

We were there for West Point graduation. The location was great and we could fit the entire family party in one place. Unfortunately, we have tall men in the family so its difficult to find beds that accomodate the 6 foot 3 inch uncle! But other than that, we all appreciated the house.

Pickel Farm is the sort of rental you hope for when renting an AirBnb. Lovingly cared for and maintained, the house is a home, not just a rental. The grounds are beautiful - tranquil location but minutes from Peapack (great coffee, restaurants...). We stayed with our three kids and thoroughly enjoyed our time. We'll miss Pickle Farm and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a home in the area.