Best lobster rolls in New York

Check out the top lobster rolls in New York, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals
1. Mary's Fish Camp
1. Mary's Fish Camp
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
64 Charles St, New York
Closed · Opens Thu 12:00 PM (noon)
(646) 486-2185
RestaurantFoodEstablishment
Coral
Great oysters. Also try their lobster roll & shoe string fries or grilled scallops.
Jonathan
Best lobster roll in NYC. Lunch or dinner. Great to sit at the counter!
Britni
Location: West Village Must Try: Lobster roll Loaded lobster rolls, fish tacos, and a fun, chill vibe. Lunch h…
1. Mary's Fish Camp
1. Mary's Fish Camp
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
64 Charles St, New York
Closed · Opens Thu 12:00 PM (noon)
(646) 486-2185
Coral
Coral
Great oysters. Also try their lobster roll & shoe string fries or grilled scallops.
Jonathan
Jonathan
Best lobster roll in NYC. Lunch or dinner. Great to sit at the counter!
Britni
Britni
Location: West Village Must Try: Lobster roll Loaded lobster rolls, fish tacos, and a fun, chill vibe. Lunch here is always a win.
2. Lobster Joint
2. Lobster Joint
host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
1073 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes in 26 minutes
+1 718-389-8990
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
LeeAna
Wonderful Northeastern-style seafood joint with fish fries, lobster rolls, clam chowders, etc. Get a pitcher a…
Anji
Lobster rolls, clams & other seafood faves come with cocktails & a backyard at this popular spot.
Freddy
Casual eat in or take out spot for fresh seafood. Lobster rolls are on point and priced reasonably. Portions…
2. Lobster Joint
2. Lobster Joint
host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
1073 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn
Open · Closes in 26 minutes
+1 718-389-8990
LeeAna
LeeAna
Wonderful Northeastern-style seafood joint with fish fries, lobster rolls, clam chowders, etc. Get a pitcher and some fish and chips and enj…
Anji
Anji
Lobster rolls, clams & other seafood faves come with cocktails & a backyard at this popular spot.
Freddy
Freddy
Casual eat in or take out spot for fresh seafood. Lobster rolls are on point and priced reasonably. Portions are generous. We recommend t…
3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side
3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
242 E 81st St, Manhattan
Closed · Opens Thu 11:00 AM
+1 212-249-4241
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Joni
If you are in Park Slope and want a lobster roll this place does our favorite buttery seafood sandwiches!
Lenny
Great clam chowder, lobster bisque, and lobster rolls
Catherine
Best lobster rolls in town! Although I think the crab rolls are even BETTER!
3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side
3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
242 E 81st St, Manhattan
Closed · Opens Thu 11:00 AM
+1 212-249-4241
Joni
Joni
If you are in Park Slope and want a lobster roll this place does our favorite buttery seafood sandwiches!
Lenny
Lenny
Great clam chowder, lobster bisque, and lobster rolls
Catherine
Catherine
Best lobster rolls in town! Although I think the crab rolls are even BETTER!
4. Luke's Lobster East Village
4. Luke's Lobster East Village
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
93 E 7th St, Manhattan
Closed · Opens Thu 11:00 AM
+1 212-387-8487
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Sne
How a lobster roll should taste. No filler. The even post a map of Maine showing precisely where today's lobst…
Jonah
$$ Seafood Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrew…
Chris
Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrews.
4. Luke's Lobster East Village
4. Luke's Lobster East Village
host-0host-1host-2
7 local reviews
93 E 7th St, Manhattan
Closed · Opens Thu 11:00 AM
+1 212-387-8487
Sne
Sne
How a lobster roll should taste. No filler. The even post a map of Maine showing precisely where today's lobster is from.
Jonah
Jonah
$$ Seafood Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrews.
Chris
Chris
Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrews.
5. Mermaid Oyster Bar
5. Mermaid Oyster Bar
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
79 Macdougal Street, New York
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 212-260-0100
BarRestaurantFood
David
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
Jeffrey
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
Sam
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
5. Mermaid Oyster Bar
5. Mermaid Oyster Bar
host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
79 Macdougal Street, New York
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 212-260-0100
David
David
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
Jeffrey
Jeffrey
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
Sam
Sam
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
6. The Mermaid Inn
6. The Mermaid Inn
host-0host-1host-2
20 local reviews
570 Amsterdam Ave, Manhattan
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 212-799-7400
BarRestaurantFood
Alexander
Oysters, mussels, lobster rolls, oh my!
Maeve And Roommates
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls and cheap oyster deal
Kristina
I LOVE oysters so this is my go-to spot - they have $1 oysters during happy hour every weekday from 5:30-7pm t…
6. The Mermaid Inn
6. The Mermaid Inn
host-0host-1host-2
20 local reviews
570 Amsterdam Ave, Manhattan
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 212-799-7400
Alexander
Alexander
Oysters, mussels, lobster rolls, oh my!
Maeve And Roommates
Maeve And Roommates
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls and cheap oyster deal
Kristina
Kristina
I LOVE oysters so this is my go-to spot - they have $1 oysters during happy hour every weekday from 5:30-7pm their sides and drinks are just…
7. Chelsea Market
7. Chelsea Market
host-0host-1host-2
129 local reviews
75 9th Ave, Manhattan
Open · Closes 2:00 AM
+1 212-652-2110
Point of interestEstablishment
Patrick
A great indoor street market with dozens of places to eat next to the High Line. Try the Lobster Rolls.
Brittany
Mecca for food and specialty stores. Connects to the High Line which is a wonderful stroll in good weather. Re…
Erica
Get oysters, clam chowder, and lobster rolls.
7. Chelsea Market
7. Chelsea Market
host-0host-1host-2
129 local reviews
75 9th Ave, Manhattan
Open · Closes 2:00 AM
+1 212-652-2110
Patrick
Patrick
A great indoor street market with dozens of places to eat next to the High Line. Try the Lobster Rolls.
Brittany
Brittany
Mecca for food and specialty stores. Connects to the High Line which is a wonderful stroll in good weather. Recommend eating at Los Tacos no…
Erica
Erica
Get oysters, clam chowder, and lobster rolls.
8. Red Hook Lobster Pound
8. Red Hook Lobster Pound
host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
284 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn
Closed · Opens Thu 11:30 AM
+1 718-858-7650
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Peter
The best lobster roll maybe on the Eastern Seaboard, no joke.
Tom
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
Terumi
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
8. Red Hook Lobster Pound
8. Red Hook Lobster Pound
host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
284 Van Brunt St, Brooklyn
Closed · Opens Thu 11:30 AM
+1 718-858-7650
Peter
Peter
The best lobster roll maybe on the Eastern Seaboard, no joke.
Tom
Tom
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
Terumi
Terumi
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
9. Littleneck
9. Littleneck
host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
288 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 718-522-1921
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Keely
Lobster rolls...nuff said.
David
Rustic eatery with delicious lobster rolls, a raw bar, daily catches.
Keely
Lobster rolls...nuff said.
9. Littleneck
9. Littleneck
host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
288 3rd Ave, Brooklyn
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 718-522-1921
Keely
Keely
Lobster rolls...nuff said.
David
David
Rustic eatery with delicious lobster rolls, a raw bar, daily catches.
Keely
Keely
Lobster rolls...nuff said.
10. Smorgasburg
10. Smorgasburg
host-0host-1host-2
130 local reviews
90 Kent Ave, Brooklyn
Closed · Opens Sat 11:00 AM
FoodPoint of interestEstablishment
Jazz
Highly recommended. Smorgasburg is open every Saturday on the Williamsburg waterfront at East River State Par…
Michelle
Smorgasburg is the food court that launched a thousand food stuffs. Every artisan New York food is present her…
Rebecca
Every Saturday, 11a-6p, on the water, 100 delicious vendors. Try the famous Ramen burger, lobster rolls, churr…
10. Smorgasburg
10. Smorgasburg
host-0host-1host-2
130 local reviews
90 Kent Ave, Brooklyn
Closed · Opens Sat 11:00 AM
Jazz
Jazz
Highly recommended. Smorgasburg is open every Saturday on the Williamsburg waterfront at East River State Park (Kent Ave and North 7th St)…
Michelle
Michelle
Smorgasburg is the food court that launched a thousand food stuffs. Every artisan New York food is present here set against the iconic New Y…
Rebecca
Rebecca
Every Saturday, 11a-6p, on the water, 100 delicious vendors. Try the famous Ramen burger, lobster rolls, churro and ice cream sandwiches, du…
11. Kittery
11. Kittery
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
305 Smith Street
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 718-643-3293
BarRestaurantFood
Chris & Don
A New England seafood house transplanted to Brooklyn, lobster rolls, fried clams and all.
Jeff
Great New England style restaurant with large front yard. The lobster rolls are great, but my favorite is the…
Chris & Don
A New England seafood house transplanted to Brooklyn, lobster rolls, fried clams and all.
11. Kittery
11. Kittery
host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
305 Smith Street
Closed · Opens Thu 5:00 PM
+1 718-643-3293
Chris & Don
Chris & Don
A New England seafood house transplanted to Brooklyn, lobster rolls, fried clams and all.
Jeff
Jeff
Great New England style restaurant with large front yard. The lobster rolls are great, but my favorite is the rich lobster stew.
Chris & Don
Chris & Don
A New England seafood house transplanted to Brooklyn, lobster rolls, fried clams and all.
12. The Crabby Shack
12. The Crabby Shack
host-0host-1host-2
24 local reviews
613 Franklin Avenue
Closed · Opens Thu 3:00 PM
+1 718-484-1507
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Monzura
Quaint Restaurant, great lobster rolls, crab legs, seafood pick-up or delivery
Adreinne
Yum! The best crab & lobster rolls are now 4 blocks from my house!
Carmine
Crab tacos, crab platters, lobster roll, Crab BLT, mac n cheese, corn bread.
12. The Crabby Shack
12. The Crabby Shack
host-0host-1host-2
24 local reviews
613 Franklin Avenue
Closed · Opens Thu 3:00 PM
+1 718-484-1507
Monzura
Monzura
Quaint Restaurant, great lobster rolls, crab legs, seafood pick-up or delivery
Adreinne
Adreinne
Yum! The best crab & lobster rolls are now 4 blocks from my house!
Carmine
Carmine
Crab tacos, crab platters, lobster roll, Crab BLT, mac n cheese, corn bread.