Best lobster in New York

Check out the top lobster in New York, reviewed and ranked by the city’s locals

1. Mary's Fish Camp

1. Mary's Fish Camp

host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
64 Charles St, New York
Closed now
(646) 486-2185
RestaurantFoodEstablishment
Jonathan
Best lobster roll in NYC. Lunch or dinner. Great to sit at the counter!
Coral
Great oysters. Also try their lobster roll & shoe string fries or grilled scallops.
Britni
Location: West Village Must Try: Lobster roll Loaded lobster rolls, fish tacos, and a fun, chill vibe. Lunch h…
1. Mary's Fish Camp

1. Mary's Fish Camp

host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
64 Charles St, New York
Closed now
(646) 486-2185
Jonathan
Jonathan
Best lobster roll in NYC. Lunch or dinner. Great to sit at the counter!
Coral
Coral
Great oysters. Also try their lobster roll & shoe string fries or grilled scallops.
Britni
Britni
Location: West Village Must Try: Lobster roll Loaded lobster rolls, fish tacos, and a fun, chill vibe. Lunch here is always a win.
2. Lobster Joint

2. Lobster Joint

host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
1073 Manhattan Avenue, Brooklyn
Closed now
+1 718-389-8990
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Freddy
Casual eat in or take out spot for fresh seafood. Lobster rolls are on point and priced reasonably. Portions…
LeeAna
Wonderful Northeastern-style seafood joint with fish fries, lobster rolls, clam chowders, etc. Get a pitcher a…
Eleah
$1 Oyster happy hour weekdays 4-7. Delicious lobster rolls, spacious back yard with picnic​ tables.
2. Lobster Joint

2. Lobster Joint

host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
1073 Manhattan Avenue, Brooklyn
Closed now
+1 718-389-8990
Freddy
Freddy
Casual eat in or take out spot for fresh seafood. Lobster rolls are on point and priced reasonably. Portions are generous. We recommend t…
LeeAna
LeeAna
Wonderful Northeastern-style seafood joint with fish fries, lobster rolls, clam chowders, etc. Get a pitcher and some fish and chips and enj…
Eleah
Eleah
$1 Oyster happy hour weekdays 4-7. Delicious lobster rolls, spacious back yard with picnic​ tables.
3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side

3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side

host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
242 East 81st Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-249-4241
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Mike
Great Seafood> Reccommend lobster schooner, crab roll and the empress crab claws etc. Great Service and Excel…
Zach
$$ - Seafood I had a lobster schooner, crab roll and the empress crab claws. The staff is friendly and this q…
Féline
The lobster meat that is used in the sandwiches come straight from maine, directly to Luke's shop, no middle m…
3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side

3. Luke's Lobster Upper East Side

host-0host-1host-2
8 local reviews
242 East 81st Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-249-4241
Mike
Mike
Great Seafood> Reccommend lobster schooner, crab roll and the empress crab claws etc. Great Service and Excellent Reviews.
Zach
Zach
$$ - Seafood I had a lobster schooner, crab roll and the empress crab claws. The staff is friendly and this quality is great!
Féline
Féline
The lobster meat that is used in the sandwiches come straight from maine, directly to Luke's shop, no middle men in between. It is much chea…
4. Luke's Lobster East Village

4. Luke's Lobster East Village

host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
93 E. 7th Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-387-8487
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Chris
Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrews.
Jonah
$$ Seafood Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrew…
Sne
How a lobster roll should taste. No filler. The even post a map of Maine showing precisely where today's lobst…
4. Luke's Lobster East Village

4. Luke's Lobster East Village

host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
93 E. 7th Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-387-8487
Chris
Chris
Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrews.
Jonah
Jonah
$$ Seafood Seafood counter serving Maine-style lobster rolls with toasted buns, plus clam chowder & microbrews.
Sne
Sne
How a lobster roll should taste. No filler. The even post a map of Maine showing precisely where today's lobster is from.
5. Mermaid Oyster Bar

5. Mermaid Oyster Bar

host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
79 Macdougal Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-260-0100
BarRestaurantFood
Sam
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
Alex
Great place with a Hamptons feel to it. Go for an Oyster shooter and try Lobster Knuckles Escargot!
Jeffrey
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
5. Mermaid Oyster Bar

5. Mermaid Oyster Bar

host-0host-1host-2
9 local reviews
79 Macdougal Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-260-0100
Sam
Sam
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
Alex
Alex
Great place with a Hamptons feel to it. Go for an Oyster shooter and try Lobster Knuckles Escargot!
Jeffrey
Jeffrey
Upscale-casual seafood spot with a Cape Cod vibe known for its lobster rolls & cheap oyster deal.
6. Pearl Oyster Bar

6. Pearl Oyster Bar

host-0host-1host-2
4 local reviews
18 Cornelia Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-691-8211
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Gustavo
Lobster roll and string fries... hard to beat.
Mark
The first, and best, of the Lobster Roll restaurants.
Alicia
Hands down the best lobster rolls
6. Pearl Oyster Bar

6. Pearl Oyster Bar

host-0host-1host-2
4 local reviews
18 Cornelia Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-691-8211
Gustavo
Gustavo
Lobster roll and string fries... hard to beat.
Mark
Mark
The first, and best, of the Lobster Roll restaurants.
Alicia
Alicia
Hands down the best lobster rolls
7. Green Acres Mall

7. Green Acres Mall

host-0host-1host-2
18 local reviews
Shopping mallRestaurantFood
Kim
A place where you can shop, eat, and go to the movies. Which they have Applebees, RedLobster, and Target, K-ma…
ALBERT
This is the closest shopping mall in the area and it's less than 10 minutes away driving. It also consists o…
Kim
A place where you can shop, eat, and go to the movies. Which they have Applebees, RedLobster, and Target, K-ma…
7. Green Acres Mall

7. Green Acres Mall

host-0host-1host-2
18 local reviews
Kim
Kim
A place where you can shop, eat, and go to the movies. Which they have Applebees, RedLobster, and Target, K-mart, Best buy, just to name a f…
ALBERT
ALBERT
This is the closest shopping mall in the area and it's less than 10 minutes away driving. It also consists of a Red Lobster, Applebee's, T…
Kim
Kim
A place where you can shop, eat, and go to the movies. Which they have Applebees, RedLobster, and Target, K-mart, Best buy, just to name a f…
8. Chelsea Market

8. Chelsea Market

host-0host-1host-2
129 local reviews
75 9th Avenue, New York
Closed now
(888) 727-7887
FoodStoreEstablishment
Lasata
If you like food and shopping this is a great place to see. Indoor market w/ food vendors (some shopping too)…
Michelangelo
If you like food and shopping this is a great place to see. Indoor market w/ food vendors (some shopping too)…
tamar
If you like food and shopping this is a great place to see. Indoor market w/ food vendors (some shopping too)…
8. Chelsea Market

8. Chelsea Market

host-0host-1host-2
129 local reviews
75 9th Avenue, New York
Closed now
(888) 727-7887
Lasata
Lasata
If you like food and shopping this is a great place to see. Indoor market w/ food vendors (some shopping too). Great place to grab a snack a…
Michelangelo
Michelangelo
If you like food and shopping this is a great place to see. Indoor market w/ food vendors (some shopping too). Great place to grab a snack a…
tamar
tamar
If you like food and shopping this is a great place to see. Indoor market w/ food vendors (some shopping too). Great place to grab a snack a…
9. Red Hook Lobster Pound

9. Red Hook Lobster Pound

host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
284 Van Brunt St
Closed now
(718) 858-7650
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Peter
The best lobster roll maybe on the Eastern Seaboard, no joke.
tom
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
Terumi
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
9. Red Hook Lobster Pound

9. Red Hook Lobster Pound

host-0host-1host-2
6 local reviews
284 Van Brunt St
Closed now
(718) 858-7650
Peter
Peter
The best lobster roll maybe on the Eastern Seaboard, no joke.
tom
tom
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
Terumi
Terumi
Nautical-themed joint serving lobster rolls & other New England-style seafood plus cocktails.
10. The Lobster Place

10. The Lobster Place

host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
75 9th Avenue, New York
Closed now
+1 212-255-5672
FoodPoint of interestEstablishment
Tamara
Fish market and restaurant (for oysters, lobster, etc.). Great seafood.
Archimedes
Lobster cooked to perfection at Chelsea Markets The Lobster Place
Kristin
The best Fish Market in town - where you can also eat lobster and different kinds of chowders and bisques...
10. The Lobster Place

10. The Lobster Place

host-0host-1host-2
3 local reviews
75 9th Avenue, New York
Closed now
+1 212-255-5672
Tamara
Tamara
Fish market and restaurant (for oysters, lobster, etc.). Great seafood.
Archimedes
Archimedes
Lobster cooked to perfection at Chelsea Markets The Lobster Place
Kristin
Kristin
The best Fish Market in town - where you can also eat lobster and different kinds of chowders and bisques...
11. Luke's Lobster FiDi

11. Luke's Lobster FiDi

host-0host-1host-2
2 local reviews
26 South William Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-747-1700
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
C
Awesome lobster or shrimp sandwiches.
Brian
Famous Lobster Rolls. Try it with a blueberry root soda from Maine!
C
Awesome lobster or shrimp sandwiches.
11. Luke's Lobster FiDi

11. Luke's Lobster FiDi

host-0host-1host-2
2 local reviews
26 South William Street, New York
Closed now
+1 212-747-1700
C
C
Awesome lobster or shrimp sandwiches.
Brian
Brian
Famous Lobster Rolls. Try it with a blueberry root soda from Maine!
C
C
Awesome lobster or shrimp sandwiches.
12. Talde

12. Talde

host-0host-1host-2
47 local reviews
367 7th Avenue, New York
Closed now
+1 347-916-0031
RestaurantFoodPoint of interest
Sergios & Fani
Late brunch. Pork, short ribs, kale salad, lobster bao, BBQ negroni.
Jada
Great Asian Fusion hip scene for dinner. Love the lobster tom kha and the brussel sprouts are amazing!
Lisa
It's the rage! Great bar apps if you don't want to commit to a table.
12. Talde

12. Talde

host-0host-1host-2
47 local reviews
367 7th Avenue, New York
Closed now
+1 347-916-0031
Sergios & Fani
Sergios & Fani
Late brunch. Pork, short ribs, kale salad, lobster bao, BBQ negroni.
Jada
Jada
Great Asian Fusion hip scene for dinner. Love the lobster tom kha and the brussel sprouts are amazing!
Lisa
Lisa
It's the rage! Great bar apps if you don't want to commit to a table.