Lidia's Guidebook
Food scene
Enjoy an easy breakfast and a nice coffee from Stars. Our breakfast favorites are the Morning Burrito and the Devil’s Burrito.
22 locals recommend
Stars Cafe
17 Grand AveEnjoy an easy breakfast and a nice coffee from Stars. Our breakfast favorites are the Morning Burrito and the Devil’s Burrito.
We love getting food from here, with the fried shrimp being our favorite. Though don’t always expect quick service!
22 locals recommend
Commander Cody's Seafood
41 Smith StWe love getting food from here, with the fried shrimp being our favorite. Though don’t always expect quick service!
Maria’s has tasty Mexican food. Portions are pretty generous. Our favorites are the shrimp burrito bowl, the steak quesadilla, and Maria’s salad.
16 locals recommend
Maria's Kitchen
55 N Ferry RdMaria’s has tasty Mexican food. Portions are pretty generous. Our favorites are the shrimp burrito bowl, the steak quesadilla, and Maria’s salad.
This pharmacy also has a grill with limited food options. We love the sausage egg and cheese on a roll with homefries! The milkshakes are great too.
14 locals recommend
Shelter Island Heights Pharmacy
19 Grand AveThis pharmacy also has a grill with limited food options. We love the sausage egg and cheese on a roll with homefries! The milkshakes are great too.
18 Bay
11 N Ferry RdDining here is really a treat!
Vine Street Café
41 S Ferry RdA nice restaurant that you can walk to from our house!
The Islander
63 N Ferry RdAn easy family restaurant.
Tuck Shop
75 N Menantic RdWho doesn’t love ice cream?!
Activity
To acquire a temporary parking permit (needed at various beaches on the island), call 631-749-1166.
Take a hike here! The lengths of the trails vary, so you can come for a quick walk or for a chunk of a day.
70 locals recommend
Mashomack Preserve
79 S Ferry RdTake a hike here! The lengths of the trails vary, so you can come for a quick walk or for a chunk of a day.
Most popular beach on Shelter Island. There’s a food truck that is typically parked nearby.
14 locals recommend
Crescent Beach
Most popular beach on Shelter Island. There’s a food truck that is typically parked nearby.
Wades Beach
114 S Midway RdAnother popular beach
Play some mini golf, enjoy some ice cream, or rent a tennis court
9 locals recommend
Shelter Island Whale's Tale
3 Ram Island RdPlay some mini golf, enjoy some ice cream, or rent a tennis court
Piccozzi's Fuel & Bike Shop
1 Bridge StRent a bike!