Guidebook for Shelter Island
Essentials
IGA Deli
75 N Ferry RdMarie Eiffel Market
184 N Ferry Rd Gourmet goodies
Bobs Fish Market
87 N Ferry RdFresh fish market, and down home restaurant
Arts & Culture
Shelter Island Public Library
37 N Ferry RdThe Perlman Music Program
73 Shore RdShelter Island Historical Society
16 S Ferry RdBeautiful historic house and grounds. They also have a farm stand of locally grown produce.
18 locals recommend
Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
80 N Ferry Rd Beautiful historic house and grounds. They also have a farm stand of locally grown produce.
Parks & Nature
Mashomack Preserve
79 S Ferry RdEntertainment & Activities
Shelter Island Whale's Tale
3 Ram Island RdMini Golf & Ice Cream
Venture Out Paddle Board Rentals
35 Shore RdShelter Island Yoga & Fitness
13 Winthrop RdPiccozzi's Fuel & Bike Shop
1 Bridge StRent a bike
Food Scene
Good old fashioned ice cream shop with delicious Ice Cream in many flavors
8 locals recommend
Tuck Shop
75 N Menantic RdGood old fashioned ice cream shop with delicious Ice Cream in many flavors
Everything Else
The Shelter Island Reporter is the local, small town newspaper. You’ll get the scoop on weekly events listed such as the Memorial Day parade, 4th of July fireworks, the Annual Fire Department Chicken Dinner, movies at the library, concerts, art shows, etc
Shelter Island Reporter
7555 N Ferry RdThe Shelter Island Reporter is the local, small town newspaper. You’ll get the scoop on weekly events listed such as the Memorial Day parade, 4th of July fireworks, the Annual Fire Department Chicken Dinner, movies at the library, concerts, art shows, etc