House holiday rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Pymatuning Reservoir

Guests agree: These houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1

Top Guest favourite

The living room features a stunning stone fireplace as its centerpiece, surrounded by warm wooden walls and floors. A staircase crafted from logs leads to an upper level. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, enhancing the lodge's rustic charm.

Home in Kennerdell

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 231 reviews

Misty Ridge - Kennerdell Getaway

Silence and solitude in beautiful NW Pennsylvania. This lodge offers a breathtaking view off the back deck, 600’ above the Allegheny River. A beautiful interior with a rustic feel. Plenty of wood work and a gorgeous stone fireplace in the center of the living room. The house is located only 2m from a boat launch on the Allegheny River, yet just 10m from WalMart. Come enjoy a peaceful stay in the great outdoors! Hiking, fishing, bike riding and more! If you're looking for serenity, this is it!

Guest favourite

A two-story gray residence is set against a cloudy sky, featuring a front porch with seating and a well-maintained lawn. A pathway leads to the entrance, surrounded by evenly spaced lighting. Trees border the space, adding a sense of privacy.

Home in Girard

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

"Meet me at the Creek" House - Elk Creek Getaway

You've found it! Base camp to enjoy all that west Erie county has to offer. For the fisherman and non-fisherman alike, you'll find it nearby. Walk across the road to Elk Creek and find yourself on prime steelhead water. Explore the array of local businesses - a variety of farmer's markets, antique shops, breweries, restaurants - many less than a 10 minute drive. At the end of the day, kick back next to the fire pit or enjoy the hut tub while taking in the stars. You won't want to leave!

Guest favourite

A two-story farmhouse is visible in the background, surrounded by open grass and bare trees. In the foreground, a welcoming sign for Hockran Family Farms displays the name and address, set against a cloudy sky.

Home in Andover

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 252 reviews

Hockran Family Farms Guesthouse

Fabulous Farm House - built in the 1940's this farmhouse is a family treasure. Fully renovated and modernized this home is a great place to relax and find some peace in a great small town with an abundance of local activities. This home is a great place for those seeking spiritual renewal or some quiet family time away, including all you nature lovers to the Pymatuning Lake State Park both in Ohio and Pennsylvania. This home is fully staffed by a great caretaker and local owner. Come Enjoy!

Top Guest favourite

A cozy living room is framed by large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. A sectional couch is adorned with various patterned pillows, while a wooden coffee table holds decorative items. A plush area rug adds warmth to the hardwood floor.

Home in Madison

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

White Sands Lake House

Welcome to a timeless retreat by the water - a century-old home that marries modern comfort with historic allure. The house boasts an abundance of original charm, featuring wood paneling, beams adorning the ceiling, and the original hardwood floor. The light and airy kitchen include quartz countertops, new cabinets, appliances, and luxury vinyl plank flooring. The spacious bedrooms, living area, and dining room are caressed by daylight, creating an ambiance that is both uplifting and soothing.

Top Guest favourite

The exterior of a modern ranch house is showcased, featuring a vibrant red façade and a metal roof. A spacious deck is visible, complete with outdoor seating and a view of the nearby creek and surrounding trees. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance.

Home in Garrettsville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 518 reviews

“Willow Ledge at Silver Creek”with Private Hot Tub

New Construction Modern Ranch House features rustic upscale design with beautiful cozy interiors and comfort at every turn. Stunning views await with floor to ceiling windows overlooking beautiful Silver Creek and surrounding nature. Private deck is spacious and inviting with oversize hot tub, concrete fire pit, gas grill, and outdoor dining furniture. A few minutes from great restaurants, the Brewery at Garrett’s Mill, and the coolest Coffee Shop. Perfect weekend getaway or business stay.

Top Guest favourite

Home in Lake City

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

House on Lake Erie with spectacular views:)

A spacious completely renovated home perfect for couples, families, and friends groups right by Lake Erie. Not enough to enjoy here! Our local amusement park Waldameer and famous vacation spot Presque Isle are 20 minutes away. There are hangout spaces within the home as well many spots outside. Whether you want to watch a beautiful sunset, relax by our fire pit area, or enjoy some grilling there’s something for everyone. Keep an eye out for our guest that lives nearby the American Bald Eagle!

Guest favourite

Home in Conneaut

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Lake front house w new hot tub!

Totally updated Lake Erie shoreside house w new furniture & therapeutic hot tub with fenced in yard w a charcoal grill! This location is very convenient to Conneaut Beach & harbor for the best fishing! ! Every detail for this home was thought out for the best traveler experience! The kitchen has beautiful granite w/ an island to gather w your family & friends! There is two upscale full bath baths in this home! Bed linens & towels are provided along w cooking necessities.

Guest favourite

A wooden deck is positioned near a man-made lake, surrounded by tall trees. Outdoor furniture is visible on the deck, providing a serene space for relaxation. Sunlight reflects on the water's surface, enhancing the natural ambiance of this peaceful setting.

Home in Cambridge Springs

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

The Great Escape: Waterfront,Nature,Togetherness

ESCAPE to PEACE & NATURE. Clean, spacious living on a peninsula surrounded by a beautiful, private man-made lake. Stunning views, incredible sounds of nature, Great Room, lofted ceilings, firepits,back deck, outdoor sectional. GREAT WiFi, office space, TOYROOM, Media room & living room. Wash/dryer, Central A/C, Keurig, 2 flatscreen TVs, Roku, Sonos Music, bikes, corn hole, air hockey. Enjoy a break from the rest of the world. Halfway between NYC/Chicago. ALLuNEED!

Top Guest favourite

An aerial view showcases a spacious single-story house surrounded by grassy lawns and trees. The roof features a neutral color, while landscaped flower beds line the front. A large driveway leads to a garage visible in the background, framed by open fields.

Home in Kinsman

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Outdoor Enthusiasts Paradise

Great location for all types of outdoor activities. Next to Bronzwood golf course and close to Pymatuning lake for great year round fishing. Nearby hunting, walking, UTV riding, snowmobile, biking, and many other outdoor activities. Entire house with outdoor fire pit available. We are located out in the country and it is very quiet and safe area. We offer self check-in with a pin pad lock on the door. We are close by but leave you to enjoy country living.

Top Guest favourite

A bright, open-concept living space is featured, showcasing modern kitchen appliances and a large island with bar seating. A dining area with a dark wooden table and decorative bowl is visible, along with comfortable seating in the living area. Large windows allow natural light to fill the room.

Home in Madison

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 205 reviews

Vincent William Wine: Lakefront winery guest house

This beautiful guest house is located on the property of Vincent William Wine Restaurant, Inn, and Wine Bar in Grand River Valley Wine Region. With a beach, close proximity to many area Wineries, Geneva on the lake, and other tourist attractions, the Guest House is the most ideal place for all your getaway fun. kayaks are also available upon request. Take a 5 min walk and enjoy an ice cream shop, or the several restaurants and bars.

Top Guest favourite

A scenic view of a lakefront home, surrounded by lush greenery. A wooden staircase leads from the dock to the house, illustrating a direct connection to the water. Several boats are moored at the dock, enhancing the lake experience.

Home in Conneaut Lake

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Lakeside Sunrise

Lakefront home w stunning views overlooking Conneaut Lake. Maximum of 5 guests in the main house (1 queen in MB & 1 sofa bed in great room). There is a twin bedroom & half bath in the basement. Guesthouse is available only May-mid Oct as an add-on rental but will be occupied Nov-April with a Winter tenant. Overlook the lake in porch gliders w your coffee. Suitable for a memorable couples getaway or small family vacation.

Top Guest favourite

A landscaped exterior showcases vibrant flower beds in a variety of colors, bordered by well-maintained greenery. The view extends to Lake Erie, with calm waters reflecting the sky. A spacious deck is visible in the background, providing an area for relaxation and enjoying the scenery.

Home in North East

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Lakefront Escape

Our home is located in historic North East Pa. The house sits on a bluff overlooking beautiful Lake Erie with steps to access the beach. We have 2 bikes, a fire pit and plenty of seating on the oversized deck to enjoy your view of bald eagles flying along the shore. A split air system gives Air conditioning in the entire home makes your stay very comfortable. We are certain you will love your escape to the lake.