Holiday rentals with lake access in Otsego

We enjoyed staying at Isobella and Pierre’s place. It was clean, comfortable, and convenient. Beautiful decor with lots of space to relax. Our dogs loved exploring the backyard and were very much at home inside. We appreciated the basket of doggy towels and dog shampoo; well used during our rainy stay. The only negative for us was the sulfur smell in the water (a natural phenomenon in the geological area). Beyond the home- Pierre’s dining recommendations did not disappoint!

Beautiful place to stay. We were able to fish in the pond and caught a lot.

Excellent location with private pond. This home was truly built for a family gathering. Wonderful entertaining spaces, large fireplace with an expansive kitchen to cook in. There is a large game room with board games to suite all ages, billiards, croquet, and a small row boat for fun.

Bills place is great. Perfect for a peaceful getaway on the water by yourself or with a small group.

This is a lovely family home. Unfortunate weather visited the area during our stay, and we lost power for a while. The host was extremely responsive… Told us where to find a flashlight, and apologized. there were many extra nice things about this kitchen. Teabags, coffee, filters, working appliances, etc. Would definitely rent again.

Lucy was a fantastic host—warm, responsive, and always available to answer our questions. The house was spotless, beautifully maintained, and equipped with all the comforts of home. Nestled in a serene setting, the property offered a peaceful retreat with a charming yard where our grandkids enjoyed playing lawn games. We especially loved kayaking on the nearby lake and watching the local wildlife. Our stay at the lake house was truly memorable—a perfect vacation in every way.

We loved Andi's beautiful home! A group of friends stayed there to attend a nearby wedding. We used the wood stove to warm up after a rainy hike and made a delicious French toast breakfast. It was a gem!

We spent a week at Laura's and loved the snow and quiet. It's definitely a drive to the main nearby towns, but the countryside is lovely. We know the area well and enjoyed checking out something new. The lakeside community was empty in the winter, but it seems like it would feel busier in summer. Nice kitchen equipment, comfortable beds, hot showers, and cozy spaces to be together. Couldn't ask for more!

It was a perfect place for 2. The home was beautiful inside and out. The property was well maintained and attractive. The setting was stunning. Having kayaks available was a bonus. Inside, nothing was missed. Communication was clear and simple; they offered good suggestions on restaurants and places to visit. Would definitely return!

We had a lovely stay at Alexandra’s apartment. The design was cozy and lovely with eclectic artwork tastefully displayed throughout. The fridge was well stocked with a variety of complimentary beverages, as well as a large variety of coffee and tea available. We had everything we needed and the bed and furniture were very comfortable. She was kind, welcoming and helpful. We would definitely come back!

We had a really comfortable stay at Eileen and Randy’s place. It was accurately described and immaculately clean. Eileen was very reachable and responsive and it was lovely to meet her and put a face to the name. We were visiting family in the area all the way from Sydney Australia. Eileen and Randy’s really was our home away from home!

Tracy was a great host and very communicative! If we are ever in the area again we’d love to book with her again.

Beautiful stay for our last night cycling the Erie Canal Trail. The home was easy to find on bicycle, despite the road being a bit hectic, there is a wide shoulder. The water frontage makes this stay extra special. Everything inside was perfect and Beth is exceptionally responsive!

Bernie was a great host. He met us to greet us and check us in and show us around the place because it is a little unique. The house is wonderful and oozes with history. There are a couple things about the set up of the unit to be aware of. The kitchen is completely enclosed within the house so there are no windows and no way to exhaust fumes - just be aware of this so you do not unwittingly set off the smoke alarm and disturb the neighbors in adjacent units. Also, the door to the bathroom, which is between the two bedrooms within the cottage unit doesn't lock, so you will need to come up with a system to alert your travel partners when someone is using the bathroom to avoid walking in on each other. Other than those two points for awareness, though, everything else is great. The bedrooms are huge, the beds are comfortable, the linens are pristine, the kitchen has everything you need, and the house is right by Otsego Lake and only a block from Main St. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay.

Absolutely loved this stay!! 10/10 will be back and will be recommending it to friends and family! such a romantic peaceful place to stay !! Christopher was an amazing host, always keeping in contact and ensuring I knew he was there for anything !!

I had a really relaxing time staying at Amanda's place. She was always quick to respond to questions. The place was very clean, and I thoroughly enjoyed the view of the water. The place is a quick drive to Hamilton where there are shops and restaurants. I would definitely stay here again.

Went away for the weekend and it was the perfect getaway for us (+ our dog) from the city! Quiet, peaceful, had all the amenities we needed to stay in (hot tub, porch seating, fire pit and streaming on TV), and close to some restaurants and a few cidery/breweries if you wanted to go out. Place was super clean and hosts were very responsive. Would definitely come back and stay for longer if we can next time.

Brian and Melissa were flexible with early check in and a later check out. It allowed us the opportunity to enjoy all of the Colgate commencement weekend activities. We were very grateful. Thank you for being such gracious hosts.

We had a great stay at Aubreys lake cottage. Unfortunately the weather in early June was not the best, mostly rain and cold, but the gas fireplace did a great job at talking the chill off and the cottage offered a cozy, rustic and comfortable accommodation.

We were looking g for a place for our family of seven while our son did ASV for Cooperstown. This house was perfect to either All Star Village or Dreams Park. There were cute little amenities and the hosts went above and beyond for the little touches they had at the house. It was clean, comfortable, and well stocked. Felt right at home. Air in each room was cold and had its own remote. Great outdoor space and use of games and fishing poles. I will recommending to all my baseball friends who are coming for the tournament.

Beautiful location with lakeside view. Such a peaceful and cozy home. We had everything we could have needed - canoe, kayaks, bikes etc. 20 minutes from Cooperstown Dreams Park. Absolutely gorgeous. One of my most memorable vacation spots. Highly recommend.

Lori’s place was everything listed ,and more !!!! We enjoyed the peace and quiet of the surroundings, the cabin was adorable, and access to the boat ,and kayaks was awesome!!! My husband and daughter enjoyed the fishing , and my son enjoyed his daily walks. I personally enjoyed sitting on dock , or the screened in porch enjoying a good book!!!! My family had a great at Lori’s place!!! Thank you, Kelly

This lovely cabin was just perfect in every way! The house itself was very private, nicely furnished and was stocked with everything you need and more to enjoy every part of the property. We enjoyed the three season porch and the interior fireplace the most where we lounged for hours in between walking to and from Sacandaga Lake to the property's dedicated access area. Though it rained all weekend, we could not have found a more quiet, serene and peaceful place to spend a long holiday weekend. We look forward to returning sometime soon!

Sunset is our family's go to for R&R when we need to get out of the city! We first discovered this gem 11 years ago and keep going back. The house is so inviting; cozy and warm, amazing views, 5 min walk to hiking trail. We cooked, watched movies, played games by the fire, and completely relaxed. We love sweet sunset cabin!