Holiday rentals with a pool in Long Island

We had a great stay at RH Pool House! The living area and bedrooms were spacious, the view was beautiful, and it was conveniently located to Stella Maris Resort and all their amenities. It was extremely clean and had everything we needed, including a cooler to use. Bruno was incredibly friendly and helpful and we appreciated him checking in on us and going above and beyond to help when we had trouble connecting to the Internet the first day. The pool was a nice bonus at the end of the day. We would definitely stay again!

The stay was very spacious and accommodating. Jill was very responsive and communicated very well. We will book our stay with her again.

The house and property: Peaceful. Pristine. Private. The host: Friendly. Knowledgeable. Responsive. Our family had a wonderful time at House Marlin! Cathy is a friendly, responsive, knowledgeable host. Check-in was easy. The house is clean and had all the amenities our family needed. We were steps from the beach and our kids loved the pool.

The White House was the perfect getaway for my family of 5. Located in Stella Maris, you have access to the beaches and the pool on site. Emma was friendly and responsive from the day of booking all the way to the departure day, making sure we were comfortable and were aware of the local attractions. Check in was easy and the house itself is very spacious with a well equipped kitchen and air conditioning throughout the house. The views from the second floor were also great. The kids room downstairs was an added bonus to have the kids play, watch TV and just relax. We really enjoyed our stay at the White House and definitely recommend this home when visiting Long Island.

Cathy and Francis were great hosts. Communicated well and assisted in navigating a car rental late in the day. The rental unit was extremely clean and the interior decor was exceptional following the island theme. Kitchen facilities were excellent for cooking in unit. Groceries stores were plentiful however supply ship comes in each Wednesday so some items may not be available. As well Cathy’s bistro “it’s all under the sun cafe and bistro” right next door was convenient and served breakfast and lunch. We explored island from one end to the other. Definitely require car rental to fully experience Long Island. Don’t hesitate to rent this unit as you will not be disappointed. Thank you Cathy and Francis and all your staff that made our vacation so memorable. Pam and Gilles, Saskatoon Saskatchewan Canada

Stunning location, great people - we ended up staying in the Flamingo house which was amazing. Loved the natural pools and the resort pools. Beach was gorgeous. Views hard to believe. Bar food was great and our waitress Shanelle was awesome. Love Beach was just down the road and very nice also. Snorkeled at the rock pools. Beds are older and decor is dated however space and decks were very nice. Resort food was good however a bit pricey for our budget, found some great takeaways just down the road. Met some really great people - had fun at the resort rum punch party. Drove to the Stella Maris lot at the cape (they also provide a shuttle), cabanas were taken up but the most beautiful beach I’ve ever seen! Only negative is I didn’t notice until we arrived that power was extra on top of the nightly price (fine print).

Another amazing stay with Jill at Stella Maris! Long Island has been a favorite haunt for years and Stella Maris has quickly become my favorite place to stay. Jill is always incredibly accommodating and communicative. She was an absolute god send this trip when my elderly in-laws and our 2 young children had a flight hiccup in Nassau. She went out of her way to help us make sure they got here the same day and were able to enjoy the vacation. She was equally as helpful and accommodating when we needed additional transport, set us up with great activities for the whole family, and made sure we had another amazing trip to Long Island!

I had a few issues with the TV, but outside of that, everything was great. The apartment was as described. I’ll be back.

Carolyn’s favorite is a gem. Amazing views, great space, easy walk to the restaurant, the beach bar, and the beach. Quiet, comfortable, fantastic!