Holiday houses in Hither Hills

I recently had the pleasure of staying at a charming Airbnb in Sherley. and it truly exceeded my expectations! From the moment I arrived. The check-in process was seamless. The host provided clear instructions. The apartment was impeccably clean, beautifully decorated, and well-equipped with everything I need. The location could not have been better! Situated within walking distance to local attractions, restaurants, and public transportation, I found it easy to explore.

We could only stay one night on a long road trip, but decided the treat was in order. Having come from DC, the peaceful atmosphere was a welcome relief. The bedrooms were comfortable and quiet. The internet was fast and the kitchen was very well equipped. Clean! There were even real cut roses on the dining table. Birdsong greeted us in the morning. The beach is so close. The backyard looks like a lovely place to enjoy as well.

Had a great weekend at the cottage! Meredith was so great letting us check in early and was super helpful and responsive. The cottage is gorgeous and has everything you need. Loved it! Thank you!

This house is so cute! Very homey and clean throughout! Gail was flexible with our move in and was very kind and communicative. We had a terrific stay and would not hesitate to recommend it!

We had a wonderful weekend stay at Eileen's beautiful waterfront home. The view from the living room and primary bedroom of the water was so peaceful. The kitchen was well appointed and the cozy living room made for a wonderful family gathering spot when we weren't dining out at the fabulous nearby restaurants, visiting wineries, or viewing local scenery. Eileen was incredibly responsive to small questions we had. We would definitely book again!!

A wonderful spot and wonderful host. Everything was cheery and thoughtfully done. I knocked off a star for the price mostly because I wasn't anticipating how expensive it is to get around by Uber in the area, and to find an accessible grocery store - otherwise necessary to have a car. Ended up ordering UberEats... my mom was at another Airbnb down the road and the difference in how we were treated as guests was astronomical. Marina did not charge me for having my little dog, there was a little firewood for us to use, fresh coffee and tea, and all the amenities! Marina was also very responsive and kind, and left a very helpful note about whether the beach is public or not. 100% recommend. In contrast, my mom felt badly treated by the host, the place was poorly kept and she felt it was way overpriced in comparison to mine (Marina's). Good thing she was able to come here during the day, and we spent most of our time here, in the yard or the short walk to the beach.

Maria's place is gorgeous, just as described. It is located in a tranquil neighborhood and right next to the lake, just 10 to 15-minute drive from the Main St of East Hampton / Sag Harbor. They have an outdoor grill and kayaks on site which is perfect for a group of friends. My friends and I had a blast there and I would recommend it !

Perfect getaway in Shelter Island! The pool house is as amazing as it looks in the listing :) Cute house on a beautiful, peaceful and very private green lot. Primael was very welcoming and responsive. She was also very flexible in terms of our check in and check out. Everything went super smoothly. We enjoyed our stay a lot!