
Holiday houses in Fairy Island
Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb
Top-rated holiday rentals in Fairy Island
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

Lake Lovers Hideaway near Lake Geneva
Perfect getaway with all the camping and lake amenities. Enjoy the sights and sounds of the Kettle Moraine with a clean and spacious hot tub, fire pit, propane grill, and activities to keep you busy. Even better, Lauderdale Lake access is less than a mile away with a pier for fishing, kayak for exploring, or bring your own boat for more lake fun! With parking space enough for two cars and a boat, day boat slip access, and Wisconsin favorites ready for you on arrival, you won't be disappointed!

Pet-Friendly Industrial 2 Bedroom Near UWW Campus!
This newly renovated two bedroom unit is conveniently located near UWW, Starin Park, and the Kettle Moraine! We are pet friendly! We are within walking distance to sports fields and UWW. Explore all that Whitewater has to offer with our personalized guidebook! Hike the Kettle Moraine, enjoy many local dining options and events, or shop your heart out. We are local hosts and strive to provide a five star experience! If your group is larger than 4, we have two other units in the same building.

Exquisite Modern A-frame all WithInnReach
An amazing space that truly caters to the guest experience. We've built this art piece to have our guests immerse themselves in all the amenities, from heated floors to in-ceiling speakers - all whilst losing yourself in the wood burning fireplace. At WithInnReach the attention to detail was paramount - with an emphasis of what we enjoy...amazing food through a well balanced kitchen, beautiful sound through Klipsch speakers and relaxation with floor to ceiling showers...enjoy to the fullest.

Wisconsin Treehouse Getaway!
Featured in Timeout Magazine as Chicago's Top 10 Airbnbs, and in other outlets as Wisconsin's most romantic and top 5 Airbnbs, this space has an immersive nature experience, overlooking a creek and woods with all modern comforts. Imagine yourself in a cabin in the woods to unplug and recharge, waking up to chirping birds as if in a Treehouse! 3 miles to Lake Michigan & dwntn. lf we're home, a complimentary Chai! Come, make lifelong memories at Racine's Best Kept Secret No local bookings.

Private House on 5 acres - Walk to Alpine Valley
Valley Oasis is a private 3 bedroom 2 bath home located on 5 acres next to the entrance of Alpine Valley Resort. Far enough off the road to enjoy the quiet beauty of nature. Woods located behind the house and a field next to it. Enjoy the outdoors on the deck, have dinner in the screened in porch, enjoy a fire in the fire pit, or warm up by the fireplace. You will have access to the entire house and immediate yard. The garage is not accessible. No smoking in the home. No parties allowed.

The Secret Garden
Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway in the lower level private garden apartment of our family home! Includes full kitchen; large great room with big screen TV, sleeper sofa, and foosball table; large patio outside surrounded by beautiful gardens; 2 bedrooms with king size beds and private wooded views; generously sized bathroom with full bath. A mere 30-40 minute drive from Lake Geneva, downtown Milwaukee, and more! Come enjoy your stay at our garden cottage space!

Cozy Country Cottage near Lake Geneva, WI
Our Cozy Cottage features 3 comfortable bedrooms and nightly magnificent sunsets. Nestled on a country road, the house offers plenty of space to rest after visiting Lake Geneva, Lauderdale lakes, biking at Kettle Moraine or site seeing in the area. It’s close to Walworth County fair grounds where the flea market, Das Fest and Rib Fest are held. This is country living with plenty of opportunity to enjoy the beautiful outdoors or the peace and quiet of the countryside.

A-Frame in forest on bike trail!
Classic A-Frame, in the woods. Borders the Kettle Moraine State Forest on 3 sides. Exterior: 2 acres, fully-fenced and dog-friendly. Hop on the "Connector" mountain bike trail right out the backyard. Or take a hike on the nearby Ice Age trail, Bald Bluff, John Muir, Nordic, or snowmobile trails. Interior: 1,500 square feet, 2 levels, open concept main living area with loft ceiling, wood-burning fireplace, 2 arcade machines, outdoor firepit, frisbee golf stand, etc.

A-Frame Retreat w/ Hot Tub, Sauna & Cold Plunge
Tucked in the woods near Lake Geneva, The Cozy Cardinal is a dreamy A-frame retreat with a hot tub, panoramic sauna, cold plunge, fire pit, and private forest trail. Watch birds and wildlife from the deck—this is a Certified Wildlife Habitat! Cozy up by the fireplace, sway in hammock swings, or enjoy s’mores under the stars. Dog-friendly and sleeps 4. Just minutes from downtown, hiking, and the lake—yet it feels a world away. Perfect for fall color and snowy escapes.

Historic Downtown Gem| Walk to Dining, Shops, Lake
✨ 1870s Elegance Meets Modern Luxury ✨ Welcome to Downtown Delafield’s most sought-after Airbnb stay! This beautifully restored historic apartment offers a 5-star luxury experience with original 19th-century charm and modern amenities—all within walking distance to the best dining, shopping, and nature spots in the area. Bonus perk: this cozy gem is perched just above one of downtown’s favorite restaurants—so you’re literally steps away from an unforgettable meal.

Mid-Century Dome by Lake Whitewater + Firepit
Stay in a one-of-a-kind Mid-Century lake dome with stunning geodesic windows and unforgettable acoustics. Perfect for couples, families, or friends seeking a unique getaway. Enjoy cozy mezzanine vibes, fire pit nights, fenced backyard, and lake access just 150 ft away. Hike directly into Natureland Park, kayak or paddle board in season, and explore nearby trails, skiing, and Whitewater dining — an easy drive from Milwaukee, Madison & Chicagoland.

The Little Farm Fontana 5 min from Geneva Lake!
Cozy cottage less than 2 miles from Fontana Beach and the sought after Geneva Lake! Minutes away from The Abbey Resort and just across the street from Abbey Springs Golf course, relax in this beautifully located home away from home out in the country with the luxury of quick and easy access to shopping and dining. We are within 15 minutes of downtown Lake Geneva if you are planning a day trip or a night on the town.
Popular amenities for Fairy Island holiday rentals
Other great holiday rentals in Fairy Island

Tichigan Lakefront Getaway

Peaceful Dog-Friendly Retreat

Luxury Wine Barrel Stay at Hidden Creek Estates

Farmhouse with Heated Pool on almost 160 Acres!

Lakefront 2BR w/ Kayaks + Paddle Boards | Dogs OK

Lakefront Luxury | 3BR Cabin w/ Piers + Kayaks

Mineola Manor

Lakefront House on Potter Lake
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Holiday rentals
- Indianapolis Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- Minneapolis Holiday rentals
- Milwaukee Holiday rentals
- Traverse City Holiday rentals
- Des Moines Holiday rentals
- Downtown Chicago Holiday rentals
- Saint Paul Holiday rentals
- Ann Arbor Holiday rentals
- Windsor Holiday rentals
- Wisconsin Dells Holiday rentals
- Naval Station Great Lakes
- Six Flags Great America
- Alpine Valley Resort
- Wilmot Mountain Ski Resort
- American Family Field
- Illinois Beach State Park
- Baird Center
- Lake Kegonsa State Park
- Milwaukee County Zoo
- Milwaukee Public Museum
- Marquette University
- Riverside Theater
- Bradford Beach
- Pabst Mansion
- Fiserv Forum
- Wisconsin State Fair Park
- Holy Hill National Shrine of Mary
- Lake Geneva Public Library
- Gurnee Mills
- Mitchell Park Horticultural Conservatory
- Discovery World
- South Shore Park
- Betty Brinn Children's Museum
- Atwater Park





