Holiday houses in Eagle Bay

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Eagle Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
Cabin in Eagle Bay
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Cabin with Beach Access- Fully Renovated in 2026

Walk down the quiet street to enjoy our access to two private homeowners association beaches, only for neighborhood use! One beach overlooks the mountains, the other in a sheltered cove with a sandy swim area and picnic tables. Located less than 10 miles to Old Forge and 2 miles from Inlet. Dine together on the new pine screened porch, sit together by a fire, or relax in one of three living rooms. Our cabin is walking distance to ice cream, bars, restaurants and more just park the car and relax!

FamilyLocationHiking

Top Guest favourite
Home in Eagle Bay
5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Eagle Bay ADK House Vacation

NEW LISTING! Year round 4 bedroom and 2 bathroom home with pine interior on a quiet private closed end road. Excellent snowmobile trail access right of Big Moose Road only 1 minute from Big Moose Yamaha. Fully furnished and updated. Guest must provide sheets, pillowcases and towels. We provide blankets, comforters and pillows. Fast Wifi and internet FireStick TV provided. Outside fire pit w/ chairs, new gas barbecue grill, & picnic table. Basement has dart board, pool table, & foosball table.

LocationFamilyGetting around

Top Guest favourite
A scenic view of a peaceful waterfront area, featuring a private dock painted in red. Two Adirondack chairs are placed around a stone fire pit, surrounded by lush greenery and tall grasses, with calm water reflecting the blue sky and clouds.
Apartment in Old Forge
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 166 reviews

Moose River cottage on the water in Old Forge

Soak in the Adirondacks from this rustic, newly remodeled one-bed apartment with a king size bed, full kitchen and bathroom. Start your day with a beautiful view of the sunrise over the Moose River. Feel free to launch one of our kayaks from our private dock, watch the stars from the hot tub or by the fire pit, take a bike ride on our bikes or just watch the amazing wild life and sunset from your private deck. Close to restaurants, shopping, hiking, and all of the summertime fun in Old Forge.

FamilyValueView

Top Guest favourite
Cabin in Eagle Bay
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Book for Summer Fun or the Fall Foliage Ahead!

Tucked away on a quiet road in Eagle Bay, Camp Adironjack offers the perfect summer escape just steps from 4th Lake. Enjoy easy days boating, swimming, fishing, and exploring the Fulton Chain, with hiking and local favorites nearby. Start your mornings with a walk to the water and end your nights unwinding back at camp by the fire. With garage space for kayaks, bikes, and gear, it’s ideal for couples, families, or friends looking to relax and enjoy the Adirondacks at its best.

FamilyLocationWalkability

Guest favourite
Cabin in Old Forge
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Tiny Pine Cabin

Tiny Pine Cabin welcomes you for your next getaway, located just a little over a mile up the road from the center of town. This unique cabin boasts one bedroom downstairs with a queen bed and a cozy loft just up the ladder with 2 twin beds, a well appointed kitchen with a custom built eat in island, beautiful granite countertops & heated tile floors in both the kitchen & bathroom, a comfy couch with electric recliners. Enjoy all that Old Forge and the ADK have to offer!

LocationFamilyWalkability

Guest favourite
A charming red wooden lodge is framed by tall green trees, with a well-maintained lawn showcasing fresh grass. The entrance is highlighted by a small covered porch and two white windows that bring light into the facade.
Home in Eagle Bay
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Big Moose Lodge Near Old Forge

Welcome to this charming Adirondack Lodge in Eagle Bay, just 15 miles from Old Forge. Enjoy the excitement of Old Forge, then retreat to the quiet community of Eagle Bay. This amazing property features 3 themed bedrooms with queen beds, 2 bathrooms, Wi-Fi and a laundry room. Relax in the cozy living space by the gas fireplace or enjoy the fresh mountain air on the out door patio or firepit. Hikers or Mountain Bikers will enjoy the multitude of trail in the area.

LocationFamilyCleanliness

Guest favourite
Cabin in Inlet
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Adirondack Cabin | Grill | Fire Pit | Trail Access

Welcome to Camp Bentwood! - Four-season destination in the heart of the Adirondacks - Two full bedrooms and a sleeping loft (3rd bedroom) - Two full bathrooms for convenience - One-car detached garage for vehicles or snowmobiles - Scenic fall foliage and winter snowmobiling nearby - Public boat launch on Fourth Lake and Arrowhead Public Park in Inlet - Nearby hiking, biking trails, and horseback riding Come experience all the Adirondacks has to offer!

LocationFamilySkiing

Guest favourite
A red house with a slanted roof is framed by trees with autumn foliage. Colorful adirondack chairs in white, red, blue, and yellow are arranged in a circle on the grassy area. A wooden fence adds a rustic touch, enhancing the outdoor setting.
Home in Eagle Bay
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Adirondack Red House

The Red House is a beautiful three bedroom home that offers the peace and quiet you're looking for. This cabin is nestled in the forest and situated between the hamlets of both Inlet and Old Forge. We are less than 1/2 a mile from three area restaurants. This camp has lake access rights on Big Moose Lake where you can enjoy canoeing, kayaking, water-skiing, and swimming in the warmer months. We are on a ridable road and located .3 miles to trail 5.

ValueLocationIndoor spaces

Top Guest favourite
Cabin in Inlet
5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Lakefront w/Dock on 4th Lake | Pineway Cabin | 3BR

Relax with the whole family or a group of friends at Pineway Cabin, a cozy 3 bedroom waterfront retreat on Fourth Lake with 50 feet of lakefront for swimming, boating, and relaxing. Thoughtfully stocked for comfort, it features an inviting living room and sunny enclosed porch. Located in Eagle Bay, just minutes from Inlet with shops, restaurants, and coffee, near hiking, the main snowmobile trail, and only 15 minutes to Old Forge.

LocationFamilySleep quality

Top Guest favourite
Two red Adirondack chairs are positioned on a wooden dock overlooking a calm lake. The serene water is surrounded by rolling hills under a clear blue sky, with scattered clouds enhancing the outdoor scene.
Cabin in Old Forge
5 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Ramblers Bears Den on 4th Lake

Welcome to our cozy, four-season lakefront and mountain retreat with private access to Fourth Lake. Unwind by the fireplaces, soak up the sun on the dock, take a refreshing swim in the sandy bottom lake, or explore by boat. Whether you're here for lake or mountain enjoyment or simply relaxing, you'll find plenty to enjoy nearby in charming Inlet (just 4 miles away) or Old Forge (a 20-minute drive)

FamilyLocationGetting around

Top Guest favourite
Cottage in Old Forge
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Cozy Lakefront Cottage | Dock | Kayaks | Fire pit

Lake + mountain views just 100 ft from the water with dock, fire pit, kayaks & spa-inspired ensuite. Escape to our Lakefront Boathouse, a cozy 3BR Adirondack retreat with vaulted ceilings, wagon-wheel chandelier & sliding doors framing the views. Cook in the chef’s ZLINE kitchen or relax in the spa ensuite. Turn-key with Roku TVs, linens, firewood & more — the perfect lakefront getaway.

ValueLocationCleanliness

Top Guest favourite
The boathouse features a rustic exterior with a red roof and dark siding, nestled among trees showcasing autumn colors. The spacious deck, illuminated by warm lights, includes chairs and a table. The serene water reflects the structure and surrounding foliage.
Home in Old Forge
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

The Boathouse on Fourth Lake

This historic boathouse is a rare find, situated directly in the waters of the popular Fourth Lake in Old Forge. Complete unobstructed lake views from all three sides of the home provide breathtaking sights during all four seasons. Enjoy the spacious dock, the open concept living area, swim in the private sandy bottom waterfront, and bask in the all-day sun provided by the north shore.

LocationValueHospitality

Popular amenities for Eagle Bay holiday rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Herkimer County
  5. Eagle Bay