Holiday houses in Cupids Cay

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Cupids Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top Guest favourite
A tranquil beach setting is captured at sunset, with gentle waves lapping against the shore. Lounge chairs line the sandy beach beneath swaying palm trees. An umbrella shades a seating area, while a silhouette of a person on a paddleboard glides across the calm water.
Home in Gaulding Cay Beach
5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Tui House, Eleuthera Escape

Tui House is a spacious 1500 sf home featuring a shotgun style to take advantage of the trade winds and island breezes. Soaring ceilings with exposed beams provide a light, bright, airy vibe, inviting you to cast off your shoes (and worries) and stay a while. Enjoy sunrise with your coffee from the back deck, and sunset cocktails from your front deck. An additional 1000 sf screened deck brings the total square footage to 2500 of living area! The screened deck offers a large dining and lounging area, complete with hammock swings to lull you into deep relaxation while watching the sunset. You won't find many vacation rentals this size! Each bedroom has a king bed, en-suite bathroom, closet, ceiling fan and dedicated A/C unit. The spacious master bedroom has a walk-in closet and French doors to the screened sunset deck. The nicely equipped kitchen features stainless steel appliances and may well bring out the gourmet chef in you. A large island invites the family to share breakfast and new memories. This space also has its own A/C unit, fun corner bench seating, French doors and beautiful sunset views. Down the breezeway between two sets of sliding doors is the media room where you can relax and stream movies and/or use as an office (no cable TV). A washing machine is also in this space with a clothesline on the back deck. Dedicated WiFi is provided both at the home and on the beach, within proximity of the main beach house. An outdoor shower stands amid the new garden. The landscape is dotted with flowering bushes, coconut palms, mango, banana, papaya and almond trees and when mature will offer fresh fruit for your enjoyment. Papayas are already available and incredibly delicious! The décor is beach bo-hamian, designed for comfort and smiles. Kiwi House comes with towels, extra sheets and pillows, blankets, beach towels, 2 paddle boards, 1 kayak and some snorkel equipment (best to bring your own for better fit.) A starter pack of toilet paper, paper towels and salt/pepper and oil in pantry is provided (vacationers are expected to purchase essentials beyond the starter pack.) Kiwi House has an identical sister property next door, Tui House. Perfect for large groups! Bottled water is recommended for drinking. **Please note, we do not have golf carts available. Due to a glitch in the system, some listings show old information offering golf carts.** A NOTE ABOUT ISLAND LIFE Island life can be challenging at times. The island often experiences power outages and water supply interruptions. Kiwi and Tui Houses are designed to circumvent these outages with a hybrid system of solar power/city electric and cisterns for water supply. However, there are times when water and/or power goes out for an hour or more. When the city power goes out, the Internet is not available. When cisterns run dry and we have to rely on getting city water, sometimes the water is unavailable due to scheduled city maintenance or water main breaks. We try our best to accommodate guests if/when this happens. The main beach house, the "Down Under" has very large cisterns and guests may take advantage of the water supply. Sometimes problems arise and we have to rely on vendors to fix problems. Please understand that things do not happen immediately on an island (no Home Depot here!) We do our very best to accommodate our guests and speedily fix anything that comes up. Island life includes bugs and other creatures. There are lizards who enjoy living in the house/rafters. It's part of living here. Sometimes during the year, caterpillars join our living spaces. We do our best to remove them but we do not spray pesticides or other poisons in our homes. Mosquitos and no-see-ums come out at dawn and again at dusk; wear long sleeves and long pants during these hours and use bug spray. Guest Access: Getting to Eleuthera Escape-Tui House and Kiwi House: The entrance to Gaulding Cay Beach is found directly across from Daddy Joe's Restaurant on Queen's Highway (one of the BEST restaurants on the island). Coming from north Eleuthera, just past the Glass Window Bridge, start looking for Daddy Joe's on the left. Take a right onto the sandy road across from Daddy Joe's and hang a left at the fork. You will see the Eleuthera Escape entrance ahead (Gaulding Cay Beach is a few more yards down the sandy road). Go through entrance and drive right up to the house. Please do not drive over coconut palm tree and other plantings. Park on the right side of the home. Coming from the south, we are north of Gregory Town and The Cove. Take a left onto the sandy road across from Daddy Joe's and hang a left at the fork. You will see the Eleuthera Escape entrance ahead (Gaulding Cay Beach is a few more yards down the sandy road). Go through entrance and drive right up to the house. Please do not drive over coconut palm tree and other plantings. Park on the right side of the home. PLEASE NOTE: Do not park behind the house as this is the septic tank area. Other Details: Check in is normally at 3 pm and check out is 10 am. We may be able to accommodate different times. Please communicate your needs and we will do our best to make it so! Additional kitchen items such as crock pots, bakeware, mixers, K-cup coffee machine are available by request. Beach chairs, chaise loungers, umbrellas and water toys are available at the main house, the Down Under. Paddle boards and kayaks are for use on the property only. Life jackets are available and recommended. Children must be accompanied by an adult. Some snorkel equipment is available. Use of home and equipment is at your own risk.

Guest favourite
Home in Governor's Harbour
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Cayo Loco Villa 2 PinkSand Deserted Beach 2 Adults

S2E2 NETFLIX "WORLD'S MOST AMAZING VACATION RENTALS"! Beachfront villa right on deserted secluded pink sand beach! Watch dolphins with your coffee/coconut water/tarts! Beach toys included! Eleuthera means 'freedom'! Tranquil authentic tropical island paradise fusing eco design w/comfort! 1 of 2 brightly colored villas! Beach stroll to dining/bar/pool! Fish/surf/boat/dive/kayak/paddle board/relax! Unspoiled pristine oasis! 1 bed 1-1/2 bath 2 ADULTS ONLY! NO SMOKING/KIDS/LOUD MUSIC/VISITORS/FIRES!

Superhost
A wooden deck features a circular dining table surrounded by chairs, with vibrant tropical plants in a pot. Expansive ocean views are visible in the background, framed by lush greenery and a clear blue sky.
Apartment in Governor's Harbour
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Lovely apartment near Governor's Harbour and Beach

Fantastic views of the Atlantic and Caribbean Oceans. Great location less than 5 minutes from Governors Harbor the capital. Right near island's best beaches such; Twin Cove Beach and French Leave. Right near lots of the island's best bars n restaurants such as Tippy's, 1648, Buccaneer Club and Pascals at Sky Beach Club.Air conditioned, high speed fiber optic internet. Cable and Smart TVs. Incredible oasis garden setting with pathways and sitting areas. Over 180 five star reviews on TripAdvisor.

Top Guest favourite
Home in Whale Point
5 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Lazy Turtle: "Best place we've EVER stayed!"

40 STEPS FROM THE BEACH AT ELEUTHERA'S BEST HIDDEN TREASURE: WHALE POINT 5% DISCOUNT for stays of 7 days or more! The Lazy Turtle is a newly built 2 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom villa with spectacular water views from every aspect. Located on the secluded peninsular of Whale Point, North Eleuthera, Lazy Turtle House is nestled between a pretty lagoon and a turquoise harbor where you will find some of the calmest and clearest water on the planet - sea turtles and reef fish just waiting to say hello.

Guest favourite
A seating area features three white cushioned chairs arranged around a wooden coffee table on a deck. The sunset casts a warm glow over the lush greenery and distant sea visible in the background.
Home in Gregory Town
5 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Sky Domek by the Cove

Welcome to our newly-built Sky Domek located on the top of a hill in Oleander Garden near Gregory Town. The minute you drive up you will be amazed by the 180-degree water-views and rolling lands surrounding our house. You can enjoy your morning coffee while taking in the sea on the back deck and in the evening you can enjoy the breezy shade, a drink and an amazing view of the sunset from the front deck. After an exhausting day at the beach, you can relax in a hammock nestled among the trees.

Top Guest favourite
A covered beach deck features four chaise lounges arranged comfortably beneath a thatched roof. The tranquil shoreline is visible in the background, with gentle waves lapping at the white sandy beach under a clear blue sky.
Home in North Palmetto Point
5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Every Room with A View

Recently remodeled, this cottage is fresh and chic. Walk for miles on the white sand beach, dream in the hammock in the shade of a palm tree, then sip your cocktail on the fully-screened deck. Grill your fresh catch outside or let your creative juices flow in the well-appointed kitchen. Then explore all that Eleuthera has to offer from this central location. RD (2B/2B) can be rented by itself for up to 4 people, or *with Morning Glory (next door) to sleep up to 10* (separate listing).

Top Guest favourite
An aerial view showcases a coastal cottage surrounded by lush greenery, overlooking a sandy beach and crystal-clear turquoise waters. A staircase leads from the cottage down to the beach, revealing smooth rock formations along the shore.
Home in Governor's Harbour
5 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

Ocean Front Home, Banks Road, Governor’s Harbour

A beautiful ocean front cottage overlooking secluded cove on Old Banks Road in Governor’s Harbour between Pascal’s and Twin Cove Beach. It is perfect for anyone seeking a peaceful getaway. New kitchen and marble bath and all modern amenities - generator, AC, Starlink WIFI, 4K smart TV, AppleTV, propane gas BBQ, fully-equipped kitchen with new appliances including dishwasher, Alexa, two new decks overlooking the ocean and elegant styling. The cove is a snorkeler’s paradise.

Guest favourite
A welcoming living space features a light green sofa and vibrant, floral armchairs. A woven coffee table sits at the center, surrounded by natural light from large windows adorned with greenery-patterned valances. A television and decorative accents complete the casual yet stylish ambiance.
Apartment in Governor's Harbour
5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

2BR/2BA Ground Floor Apartment pool/garden view (5

Relax and bask in the sheer beauty of an island paradise. This two-bedroomed apartment opens out onto the garden leading directly down to the pool. Open the large sliding doors to the fresh breeze and sounds of the tropics.. The kitchen is equipped with modern appliances, and all the cookware and utensils you need to prepare a delicious meal. Enjoy your creations in the dining area, or step outside to the private terrace for an al fresco dining experience.

Guest favourite
Home in Governor's Harbour
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Heart & Soul pool-breathtaking view-serene garden

Refresh Your Heart & Soul! Discover the Heart and Soul House, your exclusive getaway just north of Governor’s Harbour on beautiful Eleuthera Island. This retreat sits atop a hill, capturing cool breezes and offering stunning views of the water. Enjoy the expansive garden, take a dip in your private pool, relax on the covered porch, and soak in the breathtaking vistas of both the Atlantic and Caribbean seas. Experience paradise like never before!

Guest favourite
A modern, single-story structure is set against a lush green hillside, with a natural landscape of plants and trees surrounding it. Large windows offer glimpses of the ocean beyond, blending the building harmoniously with its environment.
Cottage in Gregory Town
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

“ShoreTing” oceanfront, secret beach

Featured on Magnolia Network, HGTV and Dwell Magazine, it is boho beach bliss at this modern and unique beachfront property located on a secret beach. The quaint Gregory Town is 2 miles to the North. All photos here taken at our property/beach. Built in the spirit of a modern surf safari outpost, this sophisticated yet understated property captures the true essence of adventure. Recent photo shoots include JCREW, ALO, and TOMMY BAHAMA.

Top Guest favourite
A panoramic view is offered through wooden slatted walls, framing the tranquil aqua blue waters and a palm tree. Natural light fills the spacious interior, which features a comfortable setting with a bed positioned to appreciate the serene landscape.
Holiday home in Gregory Town
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Skylarking waterfront cottage

Skylarking cottage is at the end of a rolling stone path that takes you through the tropical hardwood forest. Quiet and secluded, with floor to ceiling aqua blue water views. Complete with spacious deck, hardwood floors and a stone and wood outdoor shower. Explore the coastline on gin clear water with the paddle board or kayak - you are immersed in the natural beauty of The Bahamas.

Guest favourite
A serene balcony view features two white chairs facing a round wicker table overlooking Governor's Harbour. The expansive vista includes clear turquoise waters and palm trees swaying gently in the breeze, creating a tranquil atmosphere for relaxation.
Loft in Governor's Harbour
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

"PINK LOFT", Governor's Harbour

Pink Loft is located on beautiful Governor's Harbour Bay overlooking Cupid's Cay. On the upper floor of a renovated building, the loft has a fully equipped kitchen, spacious bathroom and is beautifully furnished in lively tropical colors and crisp new furniture. Beaches, shops and restaurants are within walking distance, and the sunsets from the balcony are spectacular.

Popular amenities for Cupids Cay holiday rentals